An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Sunday, October 29, 2023

The O.G. Live Phish Series In Review - Vol. 11: 11/17/97 Denver, CO

 It's a very dark, rainy and miserable day, so let's move on to a perfect musical choice for the weather!

Onwards to Live Phish Vol. 11!!!!


11/17/97 Denver, CO

Set 1 -

Tweezer - You know some schitt is about to go down when the boys open the show with a Tweezer. :) Tweezer is Tweezer until 5:20 when the proper jam begins. Things immediately go into a jazzy style with Page on the piano, Mike all over his bass effects honking it up, and Trey doing his late-night porno-wah thing. :) The guys enjoy the hell out of this and really take their time building it for the next 4 or 5 minutes. Slowly, the guys alternate introducing different sounds or motifs to switch things up subtly, but on the whole they stay in the "late night porno groove" for a good long while. And it's friggin' GLORIOUS! Then around 9:45 Trey turns on his whale siren looper and things start getting darker slightly. Page is "pecking" at his keys, Mike is funking it up, Fishman is riding the cymbals.....Trey starts some melodic soloing around 10:45. Page sprinkles in a few "Metroid"-sounding keyboard effects from time to time. As with the previous "chapter" of the jam, the boys keep this going for several excellent minutes. Around 12:30 we seem to turn another corner - Page returns to the piano and starts doing some great lead work, while at the same time Trey is patiently delivering excellent lead lines. He and Page are really "weaving" in and out of each other and it's awesome!!!! By 14 minutes the funk is slowly receding in favor of a more straight-up "melt-your-face" classic rock mentality!!!! Page is still hitting those ivories, but Trey is damn near approaching Machine Gun status with his leads! All ripping, wah-infused runs, just pouring lava into the listener's ears non-stop. Jesus christ, man!!!! At 16 minutes they reach the inevitable peak, which leads to them immediately chilling the F out! But Fishman is keeping the cymbal-riding a-comin', allowing Page to lay down some textural synths on top of the newly funky groove. Trey turns his looper siren back and Fishman introduces some awesome stop-start jamming. The guys come in and out like clockwork. After one last round of stop-start, the guys end it for real. And the crowd goes bananas. Holy friggin' crap, that was one of the best Tweezer's ever! Let alone the fact that it opened the damn show!! HOLY CRAP!!!

Reba -
Talk about yer one-two punches!!! The guys took us deep with Tweezer and then yank us back to reality with Reba. :) Compositionally for Trey, it's not the tightest Reba, but neither is it the horror show of Darien 2000. It's about 90% there for him, so I'll accept it. I give lee-way to the composition-heavy songs in the late 90s, haha. The jam is beautiful as always. Trey is taking his damn time, playing as "slowly" as I think I've ever heard him!!! The guys are just building this aquatic soundscape that is beautiful and majestic. It's wonderful. Reba proceeds as usual, building to it's expected amazing peak. In reality, I don't think this Reba is anything special, but it is exceptionally glorious!!! It sounds like every other great Reba pretty much, but that's a great thing!

Train Song - Is Train Song. Is great. Love Page's piano and the vocal harmonies. It does work as a nice breather following the opening heat fest, but at the same time I don't like the set placement. I just don't think it fits very well, song choice-wise. But that's just me! Not a knock, just a preference for something else instead. Place this later in the show. :)

Ghost - Four songs into the show. Three of those four are Tweezer, Reba and Ghost. Yup, this could only be 1997!!! Jesus christ..... Funky etc as normal until about 6 minutes when Trey jumps on the wah and Page starts using his "THX Synth Intro" stuff. Lots of spacey and angular keyboard stabbing us in the ears, lol. Then at 6:45 Trey turns on the looper and the porno wah scratching makes a return. But not for long! Trey opts instead to change gears and starts soloing with, what, an octaver going? Page jumps on the piano. Around 8 minutes there is a great part where the band suddenly builds intensity very quickly like a rising wave, only for it to "crash" about 10 seconds later like it never happenned. Very odd but cool! So by 9 minutes Page is doing some very nice piano work, Trey has returned to vamping, and Mike is being Mike (sorry, can't hear him that great). Around 10 minutes, the darkness dissipates slightly for a more upbeat and blissful sound! The guys are heading back towards a more straight-rock-based vibe. Page is pounding out that piano and Fishman is keeping things "straight and simple". Trey is picking his spots to insert fills. By 11:30 things start slightly getting "out of the box" once more, with Page and Trey both syncing up on a repeating, melodic trill-based motif (you will know what I'm talking about when you hear it!!!!). By 12 minutes the train has arrived in Blissville!!! The intensity is amping up big time!!! Things aren't dark anymore, but they are absolutely suspenseful and HOT!!! This is extreme tension building!!!! By 13 minutes Trey is just going BONKERS BANANA SANDWICH on us!!!!! The guys are rocking the F out!!! Things finally cool off a tad around 14 minutes. The boys start funking again. Page goes to his Clavinet and Trey is doing some rhythmic vamping like the middle riff in Rush's "La Villa Strangiato" (the one immediately following Lifeson's guitar solo). But then by 16:30 the guys amp it back up and start rocking down the house, everyone once again "syncing up" on a motif and just riding it til the cows come home. But then after another "wave crash", Trey jumps onto his wah again and the guys proceed to deliver Dance Party Deluxe for a few glorious minutes. At 18 minutes Fish introduces the cowbell and you know IT'S ON!!! But not for long - things very quickly die down and get quiet. Mike is doing a nice repeating bass rhythm while Trey turns on his "octave up" whammy pedal feature to give us some high pitched noodling. Page is laying back throughout this. With Page playing around with his own wah pedal/tremolo effects and Trey doing his noodles, the guys are funking it up once more. Slowly we begin to approach ambience and within a minute this epic jam reaches a conclusion.


Holy hell that Ghost. For the first 10 or so minutes I was thinking "this is awesome but kinda less-than-I-expected", and then once that bliss section entered, it's like the jam was elevated and they were able to take it to the next level. Truly outstanding, if maybe SLIGHTLY overhyped, but still A+ and incredible all around!!!! Let me review this on a day where take some Adderall (took a "break day" today!) and I guarantee you my review of the Ghost would be 12 pages long :D

>
Fire -
After some "one more song then we are gonna take a break" remarks from Trey while Ghost is dying out, the boys proceed to launch into Fire. And holy mother of god, fire it is!!! I still remember my first listen to this, driving 80mph down the interstate....yea, don't listen to this if you're worried about speeding tickets! There isn't anything else really to say. It proceeds as expected, hotter than the hottest Antelope this side of 1994, yo! Terrific.


All in all.....Dude, the F you want me to say?! Yea, this was one of the best sets of the entire series so far. Just an absolute behemoth!!!! I mean, Tweezer, Reba AND Ghost?!?!?!?! IN SET 1?!?!??!

Ok, let me put my brain back in my skull and get ready for set 2!

Set 2

Down With Disease - AND NOW A FRIGGIN DISEASE OPENER?! The crowd sure won that setlist lotto on this night!! The song proceeds as expected (ala destroying worlds like the Big Cypress Disease) until the 11 minute mark. Right around there, somehow the guys start slowing things down. Trey is still annihilating harder than a nuclear bomb, but the tempo has decreased and the guys are just slow-headbanging us to oblivion. Absolutely glorious (word of the night!). At 12 minutes the backing quiets down even more, though Trey is still just absolutely exploding over anything and everything the other guys are playing. Then at 13 minutes the tempo suddenly shoots back UP to the original Disease speed!!! This is downright RIDICULOUS! THIS IS INSANE! THIS IS LITERALLY THE NEW HOTTEST THING I'VE EVER HEARD!!!! 12/6/97 has been defeated!!! What the good golly miss molly is even happening any more?! This is like one continuous 17 minute orgasm.....I'm not even exaggerating.....:faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint:At 15 minutes Trey returns to the Disease them but doesn't commit and instead leads the band into a new section. Everyone synching up on a rhythm, lightspeed tempo.....And outta nowhere he derails us to go into.....

>
Olivia's Pool- Look, I don't hate Oblivious Fool, but c'mon man, that was a terrible set call imo :p
That being said, points for originality but that was definitely "deflating", but that's ok because this is still hot as a mother and likely the go-to version of OP (if such a thing even exists, lol). And thankfully it's over as quickly as it began just for the guys to launch into....

>
Johnny B. Goode -
OF COURSE THEY HAD TO DO THAT!!! Ok, it's amazing. Seriously. I remember the first time listening to this losing my mind going "what in the hell is going on?!?!??!?!?!" And yea, it basically picks up where Disease "derailed" into Olivia's Pool. Just machine gun destruction. Holy mother of god.

>
Denver Jam -
So JBG eventually turns a page into a Type II jam. Huh. Who woulda thunk! Immediately, things get quiet-yet-funky again. Trey has a weird "squiggly" sound going on his looper as he and Mike both solo lead on top of it. Page is laying out. Eventually this turns into a louder rock/funk jam that sees the guys doing the whole "riffing on one idea for 5 minutes" thing to aplomb like in that opening Tweezer. Just exploring every last nook and cranny of a motif/idea before moving to the next area. Around 6 minutes, Fishman starts really messing with his beats and patterns, leading Page to insert wacky piano runs while Trey does wah pedal "explosions". This is sick stuff, yo. Things get kinda latin-sounding for a while and it's amazing. Fishman doing all kinds of weird percussion fills, Page on the piano, and Trey just "blasting" away every few seconds as if doing a manual loop! But then at 8 minutes things finally chill out a little bit. Fishman gets SLIGHTLY less crazy and Trey calms down, returning to selective lead lines. We are heading for that ambient cliff, yo. By 9 minutes things are reaching that aquatic sound again. Page toyfully plonking out notes on his piano haphazardly, Trey doing watery leads, Fishman riding those cymbals. Very nice! At 10:30 Trey turns on his octave up effect and the drums drop out, leaving just Trey noodling, Page still plonking his ivories and Fishman riding those cymbals. Mike is doing some wacky bass effects in the background though which is cool. On another night, this would've been the greatest setup for an I Am Hydrogen segue ever, let's put it like that! And with that we segue into....

Jesus Just Left Chicago - Dang it, not again....
sorry, just really am not a blues guy, no matter how good it is. Give me any other song, just about. Please. Ok, that being said. Its JJLC. You get exactly what you expect and it's excellent. There is nothing else to say! Great version!!! Love the crowd clapping along!

When the Circus Comes to Town - Is Circus. Is good. Next!

You Enjoy Myself - After 20 minutes of hell (for me, anyways), we get a perfect pick me up. Much better compositionally for Trey than Reba was (and Reba wasn't even that bad or anything!). As the song builds, you come to realize that it's a downright EXCEPTIONAL rendition! The '97 cow funk invades every nook and cranny of YEM tonight, making this one of the most infectiously funky and party-tastic readings of all time .Just 10/10 in every way for me. Outstanding. There's nothing to say, just go listen to it!!!!

Character Zero - Is C Zero. Kills. :)


All in all....I think the word to describe this show is OVERKILL!!!!

Ya know how I've described Phish 1.0 as being like that sugary, excessively sweet cake frosting that you love but is also just "too much" in the best way? Yea, this show is basically that. :D

I definitely "prefer" set 1 as a listen, but set 2 is just as good, if not BETTER! The guys perfect the art of going "out there" while maintaining a good set flow for the most part (can we stop with third quarter ballads/slow songs, PLEASE?!).

And when they do go out there it's next-level. Very little in the way of ambience tonight. It's all "volcanic eruption molten lava comet explosion FIRE" :)

Picture the pure rock and roll HEAT of 12/6/97 (sorry to reference it constantly, it's a go-to for me) combined with the perfect amount of that funky vamping they perfected.

I hesitate to call this a "perfect" show or anything because it felt very UNIQUE!!! This didn't feel like a "normal" show!!! It felt special for sure!!!!

Wow, just....I mean, you don't need me to tell you to go listen to this beast.... :)

No comments:

Post a Comment