An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Showing posts with label 1999. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1999. Show all posts

Thursday, January 30, 2025

1999-07-09 Columbia, MD

 7/9/99 Columbia

Set 1

The show opens with a good Limb. Nothing crazy but gets the job done nicely. Continuing to ease us into the show, they follow that with a spectacular Farmhouse. God I love the Leslie on this. Really, really great reading!

After a standard BOTT (can you imagine the FLAME this set would catch if it was a modern show?!) we get a positively inspired, by 1999 standards, Divided Sky. Its good enough for me to call it a definite highlight, if not must hear. Its tight compositionally and Trey's soloing is relaxingly laid back yet still powerful. Very nice reading! Take note of Fishman - his playing is so nuanced and TIGHT. The guy was a BEAST in 99.

Unfortunately just as the set was kinda starting to finally get some heat, they follow DS with a rather subpar Train Song ....way to kill the set dead, guys

Finally, we get some ACTUAL heat with the Llama to follow, but my god it almost just sounds out of place by this point. And then Driver is next?!?! Look, I love Driver but this set is just zzzzzzzzzzz

Closing on a high note, Runaway Jim is pretty dang hot. Lengthy and strong version that is probably must hear. Total x factor all over, this almost deserves a jam chart, imo. Killer.

All in all, I enjoyed this set, but the up and down energy fluctuations were just dizzying. Definitely not a great set and there isnt much that NEEDS to be heard. Farmhouse and Divided Sky are both very strong but still not QUITE to that "must hear" level. Jim absolutely burned, but it always does. Jim is probably must hear though.  


Set 2

Always a great sign when Punch opens a 2nd set, especially in 1999 or 1997. Everything sounds about 20 times better than in set 1! Punch is TIGHT, performed as technically well as the best of em. Trey definitely WOKE UP during set break. Or was it the drugs....Either way, a GENUINELY GREAT version. A+

Punch fades to a close with some seagull sirens. Using that perfectly, they sliiiide on into a 19 minute Free>WTU combo. Free is taken at a very slow and downright sludgy pace. This sucker is sssssllllloooooooooooowwwwwwwwww. Holy hell its awful!!! Thankfully, this inspired the jam in a big way. Just sit back and sink into the paych-rock black tar pit that is Trey ripping it to high heavens and Gordo absolutely going THICK. Yo, this jam is crushing! HEAVY FREE!!! LETS GO!!!!! In the end, Free never escapes Type 1, but damn what a type 1 it is!!!!

So Free fades out to ambience and they quietly fade back up into WTU. Gotta love these 99 versions that just lay into the style of the year so hard. Love some modern ones, but the spooky beauty of one like this is just awesome. Killer. Welcome to the HAZE ZONE! This version is total X Factor Magic. Absolutely must hear. Wow.

So WTU fades itself down and they begin Meatstick. I really dig when it "rises" out of nothing like this. Good stuff and the flow of the set so far has been immaculate.

Finally its Big Boy time and we get a 40 minute Mike's>Twist>Paug! The song sounds good, then Trey hits a weird sounding siren loop (sounds like an alarm with dying batteries, lol) and its off to the races. Everyone is just zoned out, grooving it up together for a good long while, nobody in particular taking charge.
After 5 or 6 minutes of this, the jam quiets down into a much more low key groove. Still absolutely textural in nature, this a "whole band working as one" kind of jam. Extremely TASTY. Very slowly, the beat starts to go away and it seems like we are moving into ambient waters. For the next long while, the jam totally collapses as they patiently explore some interesting "space" jamming. Very ethereal yet dark at the same time, all the while somehow retaining a vague sense of groove thanks to Gordo refusing to settle down. Trey goes over to the super high pitched whammy sound and the beat picks back up signaling a return to proper rocking. Yo, this Mike's is killer. They totally put it out and then build it back up so perfectly. As the jam is rocking out again, around the 15 minute mark they go into a full blown Sweet Emotion jam ala Seattle 96!!!! After a minute or two, the jam shifts again and they go into Twist.

Still using the old intro, they slotted that PERFECTLY into the end of that jam! The jam rocks along as usual, getting really chill and laid back as well. Overall, Twist isnt anything noteworthy, its just a really nice type 1 affair.

And into Weekapaug we go! SLAPPA DAT BASS LIKE IT OWES YOU MONEY! Paug absolutely SOARS tonight!!! An absolutely kickass version!!!!! Nothing must hear, just know that its really great.

A terrific Hood closes the night with the hose we all needed. Not much to say! Grab it!!!

All in all, set 2 was miles better than set 1. Most of it, despite being great, STILL felt slightly....less than?? Hard to explain. The whole thing has this "this is great but none of these best anything else played this summer" kind of vibe.

Basically, just skip right to set 2 and let it unfold. Terrific flow and set placements. Free>WTU and Mikes Song are essential, but the whole set just plays out so flawlessly like a constructed piece. Major points for that.

Special note to the exceess expectations Punch and the absolute face melter Paug. Hood can come too.

:)

Saturday, July 27, 2024

1999-07-08 Virginia Beach, VA

 Been 2 weeks since I paused my "no hurry" 1999 listen through. Resuming this morning on my neighborhood walk, lol

Up next was....

7/8/99 Virginia Beach

Odd - on the truck stereo this sounded pretty sub par but listening through high-end in-ear earbuds it sounds TERRIFIC!!! Strange!!!!

Anywho, set 1 gets off to a nice start with a standard hot Julius. Total fire as expected. Awesome.

Out of friggin nowhere, we get probably the first true "What in the love of God is even happenning?!?!?" moment of the tour when they follow Julius with....a nearly 22 minute gosh darn version of FEE. Not Free - FEE!!??!?!

!?!?!???!?!?!?

Fee itself sounds excellent coming out of Julius. Smooth transition and great set flow with that!
---The fun begins at the 5.5 minute mark when the song winds down into a beautiful, kind of swirling piano outro, accented with Trey doing this repeating motif over and over....
----This is absolutely gorgeous!!! This is like the aural equivalent of the sun peeking through the clouds after a rain storm or something....
---This initial phase persists all the way to the 9 minute mark, whereupon the jam begins to increase in rhythm and intensity, slowly and perfectly. What the absolute hell is going on. This is incredible!!!!!
---Over the next couple of minutes they slowly build the jam ever skywards, quickly approximating something akin to a more low-key version of "that" section of the Camden '99 Chalkdust!!!
---At the 12 minute mark Trey hits the pitch shifter and we ascend fully into the clouds!!! We are soaring through the skies!! Twisting and turning and flying with the birdies!!! This is incredible!!! X FACTOR MAGIC, BABY!!!! LETS FRIGGIN GO!!!!!
-HOLY CRAP THIS IS ONE OF THE SICKEST THINGS IVE EVER HEARD!!!!!!!

---Sometime around the 17 minute mark the heatseeking missile jam slowly begins to turn into a more ambient kind of beast. Fishman keeping the rhythm super fast still, but everyone else is slowly turning this into some kind of ridiculous, swirling, vortex of psychedelic ridiculousness!!!!
-WHAT ON GODS GREEN EARTH IS GOING ON THIS IS BLOWING MY MIND!
--Around 20 minutes, 20 light years deep into outer space, the maelstrom FINALLY reaches a sort of conclusion point. Fishman slows down to a lower tempo kind of jungle beat and they end the jam unceremoniously at the 21:30 mark......

The Virginia Beach "Fee", Ladies and Gentlemen.....

:faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint::faint: 

After an "Ok, thank you..." from Page (as if they didnt just take us to Neptune and back...), they launch into Guyuute! And holy mother again...this Guyuute is FLAWLESS!!! Played at warpseed and with extra mustard, there isnt a hint of flubbage from anybody. This is Dream Theater-level execution on this one tonight. Holy CRAP!

A top tier Dirt is our first cool down of the night. Again, extra mustard all over this one with everyone laying perfectly into their fills and the dynamics of the piece. This sucker is delicate and its an absolute joy to behold. Honestly one of the best live versions Ive heard. Wow.....

A shockingly gorgeous Nellie Kane isnup next. Seriously, this one is actually must hear, imo. Its very nicely laid back and Page SHREDS so perfectly... totally unexpected!

The penultimate song of this nearly perfect set is a 14 minute Stash. Considering the perfection of that Guyuute, its very surprising that Trey is having very sticky fingers with Stash instead. Yucky, this sounds like 2019 Trey! Thankfully the jam more than redeems any flaws in the playing! When I say this version goes dark, I mean.....it goes DARK!!! I mean, this is basically what getting sucked into a black hole would sound like, Id imagine (actually, itd likely be silent but you get my drift!).

Absolutely incredible jam once again and another true must hear piece of music. Wow...Evil Phish at its finest....

Set 1 closes unceremoniously with a fine Cavern. :)


All in all, this set is absolutely RIDICULOUS!!! Honest to god, it is almost flawless aside from the start of Stash. The X Factor Fee, the all-timer Guyuute, Dirt and Nellie both being legitimately wond, that black hole Stash .... Is this show regarded highly?? Because this is just the first set and I cant imagine the 2nd will top it.

Also worth noting, that vague "drunkenness" or whatever that was going on with the Charlotte gig ain't present tonight, so thats a huge plus!

Jeez......Phish 1.0, amirite???  


Set 2

Set 2 begins with a fantastic 19 minute Birds of a Feather. The 7/23/99 Columbus rendition is my go-to, so I'm all about some '99 Birds! The song has barely even entered the "type 1" portion of proceedings when already, around the 4:45 mark, hints of "drifting" begin to appear. In other words, they are announcing they are subtly letting us know they will be taking it for a ride. :)
---Around the 6 minute mark, Trey and Mike begin to play more "in sync" with each other in a more rhythmic kind of fashion. Around 7:30, just as it sounds like they are going to drift off into the sky, Trey finally manages to begin to solo properly for the first time since the song began. Very interesting how he "delayed" his initial round of soloing and instead focused on building the jam together with the boys. Great stuff!
---Sometime around the 10 minute mark, Trey's soloing starts to go mightily askew. He begins playing with feedback squeals and the whole jam (still rocketing at 90mph, thank you) starts to get that crazy kind of "falling apart" vibe going on. Gordo and Page soon link up with Trey on a repeating back-and-forth motif (you'll know it when you hear it) and the jam starts to move into another area slowly....
---By the 12 minute mark the jam begins to quickly quiet down bit by bit. Fishman is still going nuts, but everyone else is playing as quietly and delicately as possible. This is pretty disjointed! :p If only we could anticipate the ridiculousness about to hit us!!!
--- Trey very soon starts to play the "If I Only Had a Brain" melody from the Wizard of Oz. He full on lays into it, playing it over and over and over again, FOR OVER 5 FRIGGIN MINUTES, until even Fishman gets in on the vocal action.... It's incredibly odd - the jam basically proceeds to "deconstruct" istelf to the tune of "If I Only Had a Brain" and ultimate concludes at the 19 minute mark....

Ok, all that being said, that was obviously must hear for the strangeness factor. I wasn't blown away musically like I hoped I would be though - honestly, that jam wasn't a patch on anything in the first set and kinda just sounded like Trey got high during set break and decided to play around, lol.

Your mileage may vary. Very fun but if I'm judging it's musical "greatness"?.....Yea, it's cool but not really anything mindblowing.

So with that being said, the Wizard Of Oz comes to a close and Trey leads us perfectly into Caspian. This one DRAGS big time like they trying to haul a log up a hill while fighting sleep. Good lord, boys! What happenned?! Wake up! Thankfully they lean into this excellently and Caspian has a wonderful outro solo with a bluesy tinge to it. This Caspian is 10 minutes, but somehow doesn't feel like it despite the tempo and feel. Just accept the vibe and sink down into it!

The bluesy outro solo of Caspian leads them to segue perfectly into a giant 12 minute Jesus Just Left Chicago! This sucker is MUST HEAR! Trey absolutely goes OFF!!! This is pretty much one massive guitar solo shredfest. Not much to say, it speaks for itself. Absolutely spectacular version!!!!!

The oddball set choices continue when the show moves onwards with Saw It Again. Not much to say at all, it stays type 1, doing it's gnarly, destructive thing, Trey just melting faces and the whole thing coming crashing down etc etc etc. Good stuff.

A very rare performance of Sleep gives us a nice cooldown afterwards. It honestly fits very well with the vibe of this set and the flow into felt great to me! Sounds good!

Up next is Meatstick. Hey, if we are just gonna throw caution to the wind with these song selections, why not Meatstick, eh? Trey does his usual Summer '99 "Meatstick Dance Public Service Announcement" as usual. Solid jamming, perfectly enjoyable, but nothing to freak out about either.

This "perfectly-enjoyable-but-is-it-really-going-anywhere??" set picks up some WELL needed steam with it's final two numbers:
Tube is pretty solid with nicely slick jam, running about 6 and a half minutes. Right away the jam dives into that "late-night" 1999-style of playing. Trey sets his whale-siren looper and that sound appears. Heck yes. Slowly and patiently they work their way through this thick groovefest. Gordo and Fishman keeping that beat on LOCK while Trey layers his vibrato notes atop. Just awesome. Unfortunately this is as deep as they take it and around 5 minutes in, Trey begins vamping, returning the song to the bluesy B section and out to finish. Up against the clock or something? That sucks! They were GOING FOR IT and then just "nah, no more jam". Bummer!

The set proper concludes with a very nice Simple. Very odd choice for closer but it fits the "we don't know what to play" vibe of the set so, hey, why not! The song proceeds beautifully as usual until around the 8 minute mark everybody slowly leaves the stage one by one until Page is left alone by himself to play out the show as if this was a Squirming Coil closer!!!!! Wonderful!!! :D

The encore consists of the injoke of Terrapin (because they played Terrapin Station HAHAHA at the 1998 show) with Character Zero to close.


All in all, this was certainly a highly enjoyable show. I one hundred percent enjoyed the first set more in almost every way, but it's not like set 2 was bad or anything, it just seemed to struggle to get it together at times. The song placements/selections felt "grasping at straws" and the jamming felt underwhelming, though still enjoyable. It's as if.....let's say the second set felt enjoyable but a tad undercooked. Whereas set 1 honestly felt like damn near perfection from start to finish. That might have been the best set of the summer so far!!!!

A very good show, definitely in the upper-tier of the 6 I've played so far! :D Probably an underrated show on the whole. Obviously Fee, Stash, Birds and that JJLC are all must hear. But seriously, that first set was just PERFECT!

Saturday, July 13, 2024

1999-07-07 Charlotte, NC

 On to Charlotte today. This show looks downright incredible on paper and all the reviews appear to back this up, so I have very high hopes for this one! :)


7/7/99 Charlotte

Set 1

The show gets off to an easy start with a typically solid and laid back Back On The Train. Nothing impressive in the slightest, lacking even standard Trey soloing. Hm.

Getting its 2nd appearance in as many shows, the boys keep us on our toes by going right into a 9 minute Whats The Use. Ok! Thats a great move! Its a fantastic version - Trey sets a massive "screaming seagull" loop that lords over the song. Man oh man this is Haze Annihilation Supreme...... And of course it winds down beautifully into nothing. Wow!! That was absolutely sublime!

And into Billy Breathes. Normally Id complain about another ballad so early in the show, but good lord does it not work great building out of WTU like that?! Billy has a slow start, never really peaking like it should. Its a very good version but not an exceptional one.

The set finally awakens with a punchy My Mind before we go into a rare Sneakin Sally. Sally is the first must hear of the set. 12 minutes long, Trey wastes no time ripping it up before the whole band dive into a heavy funk jam led by Gordos popping bass and Treys loops. The funkiness eventually gets really quiet abd they slowly turn the volume down on this jam over the course of a few minutes, fading it out.... Sally was a resounding success! Must hear!

Up next is a raging Axilla 1 coupled with the Axilla 2 ending. Great blast of fire but kinda sloppy overall.

Really great and unexpected segue into Rift though! That segue was on point! Rift is very, very clean and Page's piano is surprisingly jazzy in a subtle way. Im calling this one a winner. Maybe not must hear, but worthy of a listen! Check this Rift out, its really, really good!

The hits keep coming with Wolfmans Brother. 10 minutes, this one reprises the the thick, soupy funk of Sally. I wouldnt call it must hear, but its a terrific type 1 banger worth checking out. Great stuff.
Page's jazzy piano shredding is awesome!

Wolfman fades itself out and we move into a 12 minute Maze. As expected. Maze annihilates in every way. Nothing to say! :)

Loving Cup is a great choice for set closer!
Trey really lets loose, going full nuclear bomb like its still Maze or something. KILLER!

All in all, this was certainly the most interesting set played in several shows, and the song selection was fine, but it felt like Trey, in particular, was not completely "on". Not excessively flubby, its a "feel" thing. Seriously, could this be drugs? Hard to explain.

Id say Sally and Maze were must hear but Rift and WTU were both top notch as well.

I feel like Set 1 of 7/4 is somehow better than this even though on paper this walks all over it.... This set feels less....INSPIRED, I guess. Does that make any sense? It feels a little tired in the slightest of ways - not tired, but its not FULL THROTTLE, ya know?

Just interesting stuff to compare and overthink about! This was an excellent set and Im thinking WAY too deeply about it! :) 

Set 2

Set 2 begins with a MASSIVE 23 minute version of 2001! Putting that "1999 sound" on full display, the first EIGHT MINUTES are a dark and tenseful ambient soundscape. Wow, they dont be playin 2001 like this anymore, eh?
---Finally, they launch into the drum beat and the jam begins its life. Very uptempo, this one! Egging on the audience, they build the jam slowly, working towards the theme but never dropping into it as if going "wait! wait! wait!" They tease the HELL outta that theme until it FINALLY appears at 13:45.
---Utter peaky madness ensues for the next two minutes with the crowd going insane and the band riding that theme for all its worth. Around 15:30 Gordo takes over and they all start to play around with the jam, messing with the rhythms etc
---The guys go back to vamping for a long while, Fishman leading the jam with his rhythm switchups until they decide to peak that theme again around the 20 minute mark. The song concludes afterwards with several minutes of screeching, ambient hellscapes to make our brains explode...

Um....yea. That was fantastic! Must hear! :p 

And out of the noise, Gordos bubbling bass intro signals the arrival of an 11 minute Disease. The overly "loose" Trey from set 1 is noticeable again (drugs?). Trey is rocking hard and soloing fine, but his playing has a noticeable "faking his way through it" quality that you cant ignore.

He's SUCH a good player that he can coast his ass off and fool everyone, basically. That is what this Disease sounds like. I mean, its still awesome, but REALLY LISTEN to Trey on this and Im sure youll catch what I mean....

All that being said, I would still put this in the must hear pile for this show. Even when faking-it-til-making-it, the pure heat and intensity of this version is something to behold. Hose annihilation....

This is the most SPECTACULARLY WORLD DESTROYING Disease of all time, and yet there is just something a little.....off about it.... 

So that nuclear bomb Disease melts down into a fascinating trio of My Left Toe>Velvet Sea>My Left Toe!!! This is freaking SICK!! MUST HEAR! Talk about a unique section of music!!!!! My Left Toe screeches and snarls like a scared animal in the night, waiting for its chance to bite. The perfect "outro jam" for that Disease!

I cant imagine being in the crowd for this - first that insane 2001, then that more-hose-than-Big Cypress-Disease into this strange, otherwordly piece of ambient soundscaping.....Welcome to 1999 Phish! :D

So, MLT fades down and they perfectly rise on into a beautiful Velvet Sea which in turn somehow returns to MLT. Dude.

After MLT fades away for good, they move into Bug. Normally Id complain about so many ballads in a row, but this just works!!! In the context of this set its perfect! And Bug is outstanding tonight, nearly rivaling the debut from Bonner Springs. FANTASTIC!

The set proper comes to a close with an ok YEM. It brings the party but its clear as day Trey is pretty "off his rocker" during this one, lol. No trainwreckage or major flubbage but it, again, wreaks of "fake it til you make it". Good but inessential.

Amazing encore of Possum and Funky B, both with Derek Trucks! Nothing I really need to say here!!

All in all, this show is SICK! Set 1 was great throughout but had few true highlights, while set 2 was pretty much flawless from start to finish with ridiculous jamming, inspired set placements and segue, and Trey losing his mind throughout.

And that damn encore!!

Hands down the strongest show of the tour so far overall, imo, even a tad above my much beloved 6/30 Bonner Springs

Alas though, it must be repeated, is this show a warning sign regarding Trey? He is just...he is clearly in some other world at times. Like a tipsy person walking around a party high fiving everyone, lol

1999-07-04 Atlanta, GA

 7/4/99 Atlanta

Set 1

A spirited My Soul is a fun kickoff to this show. The vibe is kinda laidback and relaxed in a great way! Page rips it up on the piano. Then Trey takes over and melts faces. Excellent opener! That was great!
This version SMOKES!

The relaxed party atmosphere is cemented with the following Ya Mar. A torally must hear rendering, Trey's solo is delightfully patient and slow building while Pages organ playing is outta this world. A+!!!!! This sucker even goes type 2 for the final few minutes! It dissolves into a weirdo jungle groove fest that is incredibly unique and strange. MUST HEAR!!!!!!

A terrific Farmhouse keeps the laidback vibes a coming. Standard but powerful. I wouldn't call it must hear but its genuinely excellent.

Following a rare Oh Kee Pah Ceremony we get a 10 minute AC/DC Bag. Bag builds some major heat and rages red hot. In the end, it never surpasses ordinary, but its downright excellent all the same!

The Wedge is a great choice for this feel good and laid back set. Inessential, Trey is kinda flubby on this one.

Vultures (potato to the throat!) is absolutely evil tonight, Treys soaring seagull lead work giving such a vibe to this. Fantastic! Must hear!!!!! This Vultures is friggin ridiculous!!! Holy bird squealing apocalypse!!!!

The crowd goes insane for the following I Didnt Know, vacuum solo and all. Feels weird after that Vultures, but hey, its great either way!

Back to the laid back vibe, we get an always welcome Fast Enough For You! Terrific version, Trey delivers an outstanding solo, making use of/controlling his squealing feedback like hes Frank Zappa or something. Really excellent. Must hear!!!!

In classic fashion, the set concludes with a giant 16 minute David Bowie.

All in all, this was a pretty great set. The big word is CONSISTENCY! It was CONSISTENTLY great! Unlike set 1 of 7/3 which was all over the place. They set the vibe from the get go and stuck with it all the way through!!! Like a straight line!!!

This wasnt the worlds most amazing set, but it was 20 miles more enjoyable than the majority of the previous show!!!!

Ya Mar, Vultures, FEFY and Bowie are all must hear!!! 


Set 2


Set 2 gets off to a great start with a 13 minute Ghost. This one goes deep and fast, covering more ground than you expect in the time that it has to do so. From the outset it is oddly uptempo and rocking. It turns in a dark and grimy kind of jam that morphs into some ethereal bliss type playing during the final stretch. That was excellent! Felt like they crunched a 20 minute jam into 13....

Ghost begins to morph and change and an all timer segue into Slave occurs!!! Boy, that was FRESH!!!! Slave, of course, is excellent. Loaded with dynamics, its downright magical, posessing that mysterious X Factor that modern Slaves can only dream of touching. Must hear, this is a stellar version. Wow! Full of yearning and passion, this one just builds and builds, slowly climaxing in the greatest way. An absolute show stopper. INCREDIBLE!!! HOLY CRAP!!!

Horse/Silent is the odd choice to follow that epic insanity. Hell, anything is a letdown after that. Solid stuff, nothing special. Actually, the slow build into the uplifting Silent chorus works wonderfully, flow wise, coming out of Slave! This version isnt special, but the pairing of Slave into Silent is worth a listen!

In a bit of a satisfyingly strange move, the cheerful peakage of Silent gives way to the dark intensity of Whats the Use. The drop into the song will hit you over the head! This version is outstanding!!!! Trey quickly sets a loop that gives them extra space to play on top. Even better, this is the debut! Wow, talk about coming out swinging on a debut performance! Just like the Bonner Springs My Left Toe, this is terrific and must hear. Grab this!! Spooky and strange ambient bliss rock. Or something like that....

Unfortunately, its over WAY too quick and they move jarringly into Wilson. Reliable choice though to quickly get everyone on their feet again. Interestingly, they go nuts with lots of whacky rock and roll jamming on this, completely breaking down the rhythms and going nuts. Very fun and weird!!!!! Maybe not must hear, but its certainly worth a listen!!!

A ridiculous Mikes>Monkey>Groove closes the set proper. Self explanatory. Weird and killer. Mikes has a spectacular funk jam that unfortunately peters out all too quickly and they go into Monkey. Out of Monkey is Paug. Excellent but inessential.

An interesting encore of Carini into a Meatstick reprise followed by thr Star Spabgled Banner closes the show


All in all, this show curbstomped the living daylights out of night 1!!! At the same time, it was not flawless. Set 1 was excellent and had genuine highlights but still felt "lesser" than a truly great should would, ya know?

Same with set 2. Set 2 had a lot going on but it seemed like a lack of certainty was their downfall during it. It was like they lucked into the incredible Ghost>Slave to open and then had no idea how to follow that, spending the rest of the set playing "catch up".


Set 2 was loaded with red hot energy but the song choices often felt completely random. Not that it lacked flow (it flows better than youd think given the songs played!), but the song choices all feel totally disconnected, if that makes any sense.

Anywho, enough blathering. This was a great, if imperfect show. For set 2 grab Ghost, Slave and WTU.

You know what? This was like one of those shows where its a great listen in and of itself, but at the same time you can clearly recognize its not at the upper echelon level (does that make sense?).

Check out the highlights! A fine show!

1999-07-03 Atlanta, GA

 Onward with 1999. Lax day in the truck allowing for sub-par (echoey...) AUD listening....

7/3/99 Atlanta, GA

Set 1

An absolutely blazing Chalkdust sets off the show with a bang. All fire, just face melting. This one really, truly goes the extra mile in that regard. Its downright apocalyptic in the amount of heat given off. Sweet Jesus, say your Rosary!

Up next is an 11 minute Gumbo in the 2nd slot. Gumbo is TERRIFIC!!! Well deserving of its Jam Chart entry, it quickly (and SMOOTHLY!) morphs into a dark, funky type 2 that is kind of tense, keeping you on the edge, guessing what they are going to do next. Dark Gumbo, if you will. Absolutely fabulous!!!!! Spooky Gumbo!!! It proceeds to dissolve into a scary, ambient space outro and fade itself out of existence....

Wow!!!

Unsure what to do, they awkwardly launch into Sparkle and, it kinda, well, is awkard! Lol. I dont really think it fits here tonight but maybe it was great in person.

Cavern fits nicely out of Sparkle. Smooth transition like its 1992 or something. :p Cavern is standard.

After that dual setlist "interruption", we reach the next heavy hitter with an 11 minute Taste. Trey takes his sweet time with the solo, beginning slow and quiet, milking it for everything its worth. Absolute patience on this sucker and its glorious! He takes minutes before the whole thing slowly builds to an EPIC and fiery nuclear bomb explosion of a finale! BRING ON THE HOSE! This was absolutely ridiculous!!! Must hear!! Shredtastic!!!! Oh my goodness!!!!!

A too-early Circus appears next, but ill forgive the placement as we just had our faces melted by that insane Taste. Circus is Circus. Its actually really nice but nothing special.

This up and down set gets going once more with a slightly lengthy Tube (almost 8 minutes). This thing is all over in the best way. Terrific "kaleidoscopic" playing where they bounce from sound to sound. Keys to piano, loud to quiet and dark. For 7.5 minutes, they cover a lot of ground and turn in a terrific little version of Tube. Definitely a major highlight, if not must-hear completely.

A typically killer Funky B follows and builds on the heat of that Tube. Now its a party! Trey absolutely tears this sucker a new one times infinity like that opening Chalkdust. Absolutely awesome!!!! Probably must hear!

A fun NICU keeps the "old school" vibe of the set going. Not essential but its always great to hear! A bit flubby but thats ok.

After an ill timed Waste (2 ballads in set 1?!), the set closes with the US debut of Meatstick. The first since that one 1997 Euro "version". Meatstick is actually really nicely played with a good solo from Trey. But it so WEIRD to close with it and the audience mustve been like "wtf is this?!".

In other words, slightly anticlimactic, I guess, lol


All in all, this was a flawed but still enjoyable set. Id say Chalkdust, Gumbo and Taste are what you need, with Funky B and Tube being enjoyable side pieces. A very up and down set, it felt like it had a hard time achieving liftoff, lacking "flow", in my opinion. Gumbo was the only true JAM and the other stuff was on the "incredibly hot" side of ordinary. Id rank this a B+ set.

Good but not incredible. :)

GUMBO AND TASTE! GET THOSE!

 Full disclosure, Im preparing to "suffer" through this 2nd set just based on the song selection/placement. Forgive me. :p

Set 2

A Twist opener. Definitely not my ideal choice. And its not anything noteworthy tonight. It basically stays in an unimpressive type 1 vamp for its rather boring duration. Let me put it like this, every version of 2023 is better than this.

And this enjoyable but utterly unremarkable Twist concludes and they move into Piper. EXTREMELY long intro - this Piper is 10 minutes and they reach the halfway point before beginning the vocals! Ok, get to the point.... Unfortunately, despite the raging power, this Piper, like the Twist before, is a complete and utter snoozefest. As soon as it begins to lift off finally, the damn thing is over. And they didnt "do" anything with it AT ALL except just play the song faster and faster! Im not sure which Piper is worse - that 7/3/97 one I complained about the other day or this "huffs and puffs but goes nowhere" version.

Ugh! What a lame double whammy to ruin the start of this set! :(

10 minutes seems to be the buzz term of the night as thats the length of the following Moma Dance. Interesting to see it in set 2. NOT interesting to get it after the previous two songs....Moma is just ok. It neither offends nor impresses. Solid with some average heat. If this was early set 1 Id be kinder, but after the double whammy of crap that opened this 2nd set, we deserve more than a lukewarm reading of a typically first set tune!!!

What is this B.S.?!

Oh goody! Now we have to sit through a dang Mountains In th Mist! Ugh! I love this song, its beautiful as ever, but this is NOT what this sinking ship needs right now! To be fair, this is the best thing of the set so far by quite a margin. Its exquisite!!!!

Thank christ we get a 14 minute Antelope next. Will this finally be the shot in the arm this set so desperately needs?! And thank Icculus it delivers!!! This sucker is nuclear!!! I mean, its Antelope, you expect as much. But they really take it next level, Trey coaxing squealing seagull sounds and dying cat shrieks from his guitar. The whole thing just explodes like you cant even imagine. Even by Antelope standards, this one is next level. Essential listening!!! Must hear!!!!

Revisiting the old school vibe of set 1, the scorched earth Antelope gives way nicely to a rare Contact. Good stuff. Contact is Contact, but they do a fun Little Drummer Boy outro jam which is a hoot.

Double encore tonight - Pretty noteworthy to mention we get a rare Bill Bailey with Page's father at the helm. Very nice!

And of course Hood to close.


Yo, screw this set. Set 1 wasnt perfect but it was always pretty good. The first half or so set was just purely NOT up to snuff at all! Twist and Piper were shockingly boring/uninspired and Moma was ok but not even up to the level of most first set versions. Bad ballad placement yet again led to the final stretch feeling like they were grasping as straws..... Thankfully, Antelope is terrific and worthy of Must Hear status. Insane version. But ONE great song does not redeem one of the most flawed sets Ive had the displeasure to sit through.

UGH!

Maybe on another day Ill enjoy this show but today I friggin hated it! :p 

 

Saturday, July 6, 2024

1999-07-01 Antioch, TN

 7/1/99 Antioch, TN

Set 1

Punch You In the Eye is my always-preferred choice of opener. Typically excellent version, this one sounds like its out of 1995, rather than 1999 - a total 180 from the 7/23/99 lightspeed version with keyboard intro jamming. Excellent, if not exactly all that special. Gets the job done but it feels like they have their foot on the brakes a little bit.

And unfortunately, having Billt Breathes in the 2nd slot does nothing to dissuade that feeling. Love the song and its great as ever but Im sorry, this placement is just not kosher. Honestly though, as with Punch, this version just kinda sounds like its lacking that certain something....like Trey is struggling big time with his solos and it kinda just feels a little stiff. Swing and a miss, unfortunately!

Guyuute follows this trend. An overall excellent reading of the song that is just "loose" enough around the edges to prevent it going next level. Think small flubs, struggles with guitar bends, etc. Its nitpicky stuff but thats the dividing line sometimes.

Up next is a wonderful treat - dobro master Jerry Douglas joins the guys onstage for an all timer reading of Wolfmans Brother. Obviously the dobro gives it a more laid back, country/americana kind of vibe. Its fantastic! Like, dang, I could see modern Bob Dylan whipping out a version like this as a cover or something. Just terrific. Obviously must hear!!!!
----About halfway through, Wolfman starts to jam - hearing the emerging cow funk mesh so nicely with the country vibes is just downright strange and satisfying as hell all at once. Its like 2 jams happening at the same time.
---Its particularly awesome hearing Jerry and Trey riff off each other, egging one another on. This jam is COOKIN!!!!

The hootenanny fun continues when they
bring on Ronnie McCourt and Tim OBrien on mandolin and fiddle -

Beauty of My Dreams, Doin My Time, Roggae, Water in the Sky, Back On the Train and Poor Heart continue the fun all the way to the finish line!!!

Of course, this is hands down the GOAT Beauty, what with the shredding fiddle and dobro. Just spectacular. Must hear stuff!

Rinse and repat for Doin My Time. It doesnt even sound like Phish is still on the damn stage for this one!

Roggae is MUST HEAR!!!! The extra instrumentation turns the song into a lowkey, bluesy kind of swamp stomp!!!! This is spectacular - Ive got goosebumps!!! X Factor Magic on this one. It almost starts to sound like 1972 Dead at points.....wow!!!! Trey and the fiddle and the mandolin all swapping phrases...this is outstanding!!!!!

Water In the Sky is already a country song, pretty much, so its amazing to hear it as Im assuming they might have heard it in their heads while writing the piece. The fiddle just sends this one into the stratosphere. Holy moly.

Repeat the above for Back On The Train. Its as if....this is what it should always sound like. I mean that in the best way. Just fantastic. :)

And of course the ripping Poor Heart to close.


All in all, holy moly this set is essential Phish listening!!!! The first few songs were just ok but felt very "going through the motions". As soon as the guests came on it was GO time! I would say Wolfman and Roggae are both truly MUST HEAR while the rest of the sitin set is not far behind.

Definitely not the kind of set Ill purposefully seek out, but Im sure glad I listened to it!!!! Wowzers! :D 

Set 2 - the 3 song, beat-the-storm set :)

The set opens with a BANG with an roaring, 18 minute Disease. And my freaking goodness this sucker doesnt just smoke, it buuuurrrrnnnssss. Big Cypress Disease, you have met your match.
---Its full throttle all the way to the 12 minute mark whereupon Trey pumps the breaks. The jam enters a more spaciously psychedelic zone. Still guitar meltdown annihilation, but there is room to breathe. Kinda. :p
Trey, what did this guitar do to you?! Somebody help the poor thing!!!!
---The jam slowly goes into outer space psych shred mode. Or something like that, I dont know what the hell you want me to call this. Its ridiculous and incredible.
--- Suddenly the synths comes out to play and things take a turn towards a brooding darkness. Exactly like watching storm clouds slowly approach on the horizon.
---After about a minute languishing in the haze of destruction, Trey begins to reintroduce the Disease lick from nothing and the guys launch flawlessly back into the song proper to close

Wow!!! That was one of the fastest, "hurry up, we need to go deep QUICKLY!" kind of jams ever! 18 minutes sounds like a long time, but that jam made it feel like 5! See, Phish was microjamming back in 1999! :p

And into Caspian we segue. That Disease was spectacular but definitely FELT kinda rushed, if you will. Excellent but "typical" version. Felt like a "coda" to Disease in the best way. Gets really nice in the last few minutes with a great Page solo section. Good stuff.

And into a 28 minute YEM to close the set! Gotta say, that non-segue was a little awkward. YEM OUTTA NOWHERE, haha. And the initial composed sections feel a little disjointed - not flubby, just loose.
----During the cymbal rat-a-tat section, they really lay hard into that vaguely ambient 1999 thing. To glorious effect. Piano inserts and squiggle effects abound!
---Despite the incoming storm, there is ZERO sense of rush and the jam displays the utmost patience from start to finish. This YEM is absolutely phenomenal. The final few minutes of hose explosion are maybe the finest music played all show!
---This YEM is ESSENTIAL listening of the highest order. Its pretty much PERFECTION. I cannot rave about this one enough. Its OUTSTANDING!

Sloppy hot C Zero for the encore to get us offstage quickly. C Zero is absolutely NUCLEAR IN THE EXTREME. NEXT LEVEL! MUST HEAR!

Funny, Im actually playing this as a storm is approaching and the sky is getting darker. How fitting!

All in all, this was definitely a UNIQUE show!! And musically it mostly gets a pass! I mean, the whole guest section in set 1 is essential and the Disease and YEM is set 2 are both bonkers good. Thats about 75% of the show being firmly in the "top tier" category, so.... Its pretty difficult to "rate" such a different show like this. Definitely worth a listen for anyone curious - Roggae and YEM and C Zero are worth the price of admission!

Friday, July 5, 2024

1999-06-30 Bonner Springs, KS

 6/30/99 Bonner Springs

Set 1

The show wastes no time getting going with a 20 minute Gin to open proceedings. Full on type 2, it quickly dissolves into that ultra hazy, screaming-seagulls style of deconstruction that 1999 jamming is well known for. Wonderful rebuild back into the song and out. Hot damn. Remember when crazy stuff like this was a dime a dozen and noone batted an eye?!

Farmhouse in slot 2 actually works great to bring us back to terra firma. Nothing special but the placement really did wonders for it.

The following Tube is way too short but delivers the type 1 goods. Horn is Horn.

Up next is the Phish debut of Back On The Train. Not exactly a complicated song, but it sounds excellent from the get go. Funky, down home rock and roll. A strong version by any measure. Great debut! Funnily, they completely butcher the ending and it just kinda collapses upon itself.

And into a 14 minute Maze we go! GET YOUR SUNSCREEN! WE GONNA GET FRIED! :D Absolutely MASSIVE organ solo from Page on this sucker followed by the wah pedal guitar mutilation you expect. This one deserves it's jam chart status - Trey rips SO hard he nearly fumbles the whole thing himself. Absolutely nuclear.

A beautiful Limb By Limb chills us out after that razing. Limb stays type 1 but seems to have extra fire and turns in a particularly strong performance.

The set ends with a nicely played Golgi.

All in all, this was a surprisingly varied set! Excellent flow as well - it felt constructed! The Gin and the Maze are must hear with a special nod to Limb. Great start to Summer 99!!!

:) 

Set 2

Shock and surprise Coil opener!!! Pretty well played and chock full of energy, it actually gets everything going very well, if you can believe that! Great version and the placement is very refreshing. The outro jam is awesome - instead of dying into a piano solo, they just keep on going, working the song, slowly building back the energy. It dies down for a while and we do eventually end up with a piano solo, but then, slowly full band ambience emerges with tons of feedback and the guys LAUNCH into that opening D chord of Free!!!!

UNEXPECTED SEGUES FOR THE WIN!

Free is 14 minutes of spectacular awesome sauce. It aint the 7 23 Columbus masterpiece but itll sure do until we reach Ohio! Trey goes all outer space robo funk rock on this sucker. Textural synths galore. This is SICK!!!! They bring it down heavy and thick like its the late night groove party. Stuttering backwards robo fx, etc. Then it explodes and they rock it to a massive conclusion. SPECTACULAR!!! MUST HEAR!!!

Whats that? You need more fire in your ears? Ok, Birds of a Feather it is! Pure unhinged insanity. Basically, Maze Part 2. Holy hell. Nuclear annihilation....

Simple rises from the destruction and keeps us going, the blissful outro giving way to upbeat, hazy ambience! This in turn morphs, incredibly, into one of the best placed Swept Away>Steeps ever. THIS SET WAS CONSTRUCTED, I TELL YOU.

That pair in turn fizzle perfectly into Piper! The build up into Piper out of Steep is the definition of "peaks and valleys perfected". Setlist creation 101 right here, boys and girls! And of course Piper just shreds blissfully to the heavens and back as expected.

After a short break, the boys cool us down again with the Phish debut of Bug. All 9 minutes of it. Powerful as ever, great for a debut. Absolutely soaring, very hazy and FULL of that "1999" sound. Screaming seagull Trey in the best way. Fantastic debut!!!!!!!

And holy mother of Satan are we in for a shock when Bug melts into a ridiculous, evil, ambient jam, aka the debut of My Left Toe. Full on "2 23 24 Chalkdust" evil on steroids. People in attendance must have been losing their minds. I'm listening in a friggin dump truck and lord knows I just lost mine! Dude!!!!

As if we didnt just debut a new song and descend into the pits of hell and back all within 20 minutes, we return to finish the set with Stash. Stash is a gnarly beast. Not must hear, but it sure gets dark and foreboding. Evil Stash is best Stash! :)

Nice encore of Bouncing and Sample to keep us from having a heart attack after all of that stressful music :)

All in all...HOLY CRAP THAT SET WAS INCREDIBLE!!!! Set 1 was a good warmup, but set 2 was top to bottom perfection! They NEED to release this show!!! The Free was ridiculous, the Simple>Swept/Steep>Piper was nutzo, the Bug>My Left Toe was insanity... EVERYONE NEEDS TO HEAR THIS SET! Good golly talk about coming outta the gate swinging - there was SO much going on!

Wow!!!!! :p

Im exhausted! Awesome show!

Friday, March 29, 2024

1999-12-31 Big Cypress, FL - 2023 revisit

 Tackling The Big One again today.

50/50 chance on it being a perfect "driving day", so to speak.

So im starting it and seeing where we end up lol

12 31 99 Big Cypress
.
Killer RJim to open. Funky B was great as always.

Tube was something special. Really terrific version that seemed about twice as long as most.

And then some vacuum action with I Didnt Know.

Good stuff so far :)
Its great to be replaying this with four more years of listening "experience"..... 

Punch You In The Eye - Very underrated version, imo! Absolutely smashing, tight as hell, and rages hard. 97 through 99 was definitely peak time for this song!  

Where I left off before, Split Open and Melt was a monster. About 22 min or so. It was a little "all over the place at once" for me, but im sure most will love it.

Guyuute, like Punch, was a surprising standout. One of the most nailed, badass versions ive heard. Amazing.

Great first set. Almost a show in itself! :p 

Clocked in at 545 am today and restarted the midnight set.

Currently in the middle of the shredfest Llama.

I have mixed feelings on that Disease. Its 20 minutes long, 12 of which are pure Type I guitar rape before it slowly starts to chill out to a close.

Hot take, its not a great Disease. It does too little with it's runtime and, quite frankly, gets kinda boring at times.

But its a friggin face melter all the same so I cant be too harsh :)

On to Gin...  Gin is crazy. Whacky-ass rhythmic, vocal led kind of jam!!! Super unique and awesome! :D
Then it slowly morphs into a weird, kinda ambient, eastern sounding jam. Yo, this Gin is a masterpiece 

Twist was objectively excellent. Not the jam I wanted, but it was really good. Basically morphed into ambient bliss.

This led to Caspian. And check it out - its way better than you remember.

Up next was one of my favorite jams of all time, the 30 minute Rock and Roll. A shred fest of headbanger proportions, about halfway through it gets a cool NICU-esque jam going which in turn leads to a lengthy ambient section before returning to a peak. Must hear, all day long :)

Currently in the middle of YEM. This one is refreshingly unique with a super chill, kinda jazzy, late night vibe. Awesome.

CHEESECAKE VOCAL JAM!  

Crosseyed and Painless

For some reason I had completely forgotten about this. Jesus christ on a cracker. This is one of those monster "how much more insane can this get?!".

In competition with the 7 23 99 Birds of a Feather and the Red Rocks 96 Mikes Song as the hottest piece of music ever unleashed on mortal ears....

Then after Josie we get the Sand/Quad Top odyssey!! Probably the overall best jam of the night and serious contender for a top 10 jam ever played imo. Tied with Rock and Roll as my favorite thing from Big Cypress

You all know this sucker. Go revisit it.

Slave to the Traffic Light.

This feels like the turning point of the set or something. Most of the super jams have now passed and things are deep and hazy.

This is a spectacular 15 min version well worth your time!

There is only about 2 more hours of soundboard (well, video feed) before my composite switches back to AUD.

Yes I know there are cuts, but ill take 5.5 hours of pro audio with 3 or 4 short cuts over an AUD all day, every day. Im gonna "patch" the sbd one day but just havent had the time.  

Reba was impressively flawless and full of energy. Terrific slow build solo as well. In light of the other monsters in this set, I can't help but think this Reba is underrated! :) 

Bowie felt ramshackle but had a decent jam

Axilla, My Soul, Uncle Pen - all good

Drowned/After Midnight - perhaps the most underrated of the evenings super jams? Pretty kickass.

Bittersweet Motel is the perfect break.... 

Piper - ok, THIS is the underrated jam. Holy hell. If you like NOISE, this is the jam for you :)

And talk about perfect timing, I got through Free. The sbd ends and I get through Lawn Boy and I get called in.

Day is over. Rain last night screwed things today...
Talk about a perfect pause point for tomorrow though!!!  

Just finished that last 100 minutes or so of Big Cypress

So that 35 minute Roses are Free...that sure was...somethin', I guess. Definitely "music" to zone out to, lol.

Love the Meatstick ending of the show. It SOUNDS like what you feel like after staying up all night.

What a crazy show and vibe... 

 

 

Sunday, October 29, 2023

The O.G. Live Phish Series In Review - Vol. 8: 7/10/99 Camden, NJ

Onwards to Live Phish Vol. 8!

7/10/99 Camden, NJ

I've heard this a few times before casually, but the only thing I really know well is the incredible Chalkdust. Definitely excited to pay close attention to this show! :D


7/10/99

Set 1

Wilson - Nice to have as opener for a change!!! Nicely weird "heavy metal" version!!! Trey is doing some Iommi-esque riffing and the other three guys keep the "pulsing" beat going in a very metallic manner. This doesn't last too long and the song ends in the manner you expect from all Wilsons. Really, this isn't THAT special, but it is pretty nice on the whole. Good opener!

>Chalkdust Torture - And here we go!!! This has long been one of my favorite versions/jams of all time. I listen to it and ALWAYS end up going "how the hell did we get from there to HERE?!" The jamming begins around 3 minutes in as usual. Around 3:30 Trey stumbles onto a brief sustained note that foreshadows the soaring peaks he will reach later (but enough teasing for now!). Page is on the keys and the jam is rocking out, but it also has a slightly chill kinda vibe as well. Hard to explain. Almost like relaxed feeling about it. OOH! OOH! OOH!! Right at 5:20 things take a SUDDEN sharp turn!!! The guys have one of those moments where they "stumble" into a new area by accident. Things get dark for about 20 seconds before they quickly change course into a much more blissful direction. Page is on piano and this is sounding like some 2011 version of Light or something. All smiles and good vibes! Trey is just noodling around melodically, and Fishman is constantly playing with the drum pattern. It sounds like they are on the verge of returning to Chalkdust Torture proper for a while. They are walking that "take the plunge/don't take the plunge" tightrope for a while! Hell, at 7:25 it straight up sounds like we are back in CDT again. BUT NOT FOR LONG!! About 15 seconds later Trey and Page "sync up", playing with each other. Page is doing double duty, rocking the piano and the organ at the same time. Fishman is keeping the CDT beat going and Mike is just doing his best "I don't know what to play so I'll play everything I can to try to fit in" stuff. :) At 8:58 Trey returns "accidentally" to the bliss from earlier!!! But this time they are CLEARLY going SKYWARDS!!!!!!!!! Everyone else follows Trey to Heaven. Trey is doing the upper-neck, bendy sustains that are the hallmark of this jam. Remember how I've said I can't usually remember most jams particularly? This is one that I will NEVER forget what it sounds like!!! SO UNIQUE! This sends chills down my spine and arms!!! Trey is just at the very top of Mount Everest or something, playing the highest notes he can, so melodically and methodically!!! This is like Bird Song plus Adderall on steroids or something. Just PEAK PEAK PEAK PEAK PEAK!!!! How in the F did we go from Chalkdust Torture to the most uplifting, spine-tingling, smile-inducing musical peak this side of 3.0??!!! I don't know how to really describe this jam, but once you have heard it, you will likely have the same "what the hell was that?!" reaction!!!! By 12 minutes, Trey steps down from the mountain and the guys all sync up together, bringing the volume down a bit (though keeping the rhythm spastic!). Some cool stop-start jamming begins around 13 minutes, initiated by Fishman and cemented by Mike. Page is on the wah pedal with his Clavinet (?) and Trey is just spacing the hell out. Mike and Fish are totally the focal point here, holding down the fort like a great version of Sand or something. And then very slowly Trey perfectly introduces the Roggae motif and we make the turn.....


>Roggae - Holy crap, I didn't realize I needed a breather so soon but I'm glad we got it! Nice call, Trey!! After that "heavy metal" Wilson, the light/dark dichotomy of this Roggae actually, thematically, feels like it belongs extra well. If that makes any sense. How do they transition from light to dark like this and make it so seamless?! The heavy parts make me headbang and the soloing from Trey in the back half is just gorgeous like a soothing I Am Hydrogen or something. Really love Mike being so high in the mix yet again (a constant with this LP series - what's the deal here???). Ya know what? This Roggae actually gives me strong Neil Young vibes. I could totally hear him doing this in the 70s with Crazy Horse, ala Danger Bird or something. Seriously, think about it!


Water In the Sky -
On paper, this first set looks a little...aloof for my taste. But when listening, man it flows great!!!! Water is a great pickup after the cool-down of Roggae!!!! Mentally, I've just got a stupid grin on my face. So great. Great soloing from all involved. AN ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING VERSION!!!!! A+ WATER!!!! WOW!!!!


Back At the Chicken Shack - I don't care for the blues usually and this is one of my least favorite covers, so.....let's get this over with! :) Great stuff though, Page slays as expected, laying waste to his arsenal of keys. Very nice solo from Trey too. On the whole, a great version but not a favorite so.....look, do you want me to just highlight everything or try to remain judicial about this? :p

Sparkle - Is Sparkle. Is great but sounds like every other version ever played. :)

>Bathtub Gin - I'm calling that a segue. Come at me. Good version of the song as usual. Jamming begins around 5 minutes in and returns to the "chill" vibe the first section of Chalkdust had. Very "active" playing from Mike, while Trey is taking his time just picking out the occasional note to sustain. Around 6 minutes, things start to get quiet! Fishman starts riding those cymbals, giving us a late-night Gin kinda vibe. But while the rest of the band is keeping it low, Trey is slowly amping up his energy bit by bit. But the band latches on and they all start to jam together around 7 minutes. You can hear and feel the intensity slowly building, like watching a loaf of broad slowly rise. Page is pounding the piano, Fishman is crashing those cymbals and Trey is doing sweetly melodic playing. By 8:30 we are rocking out! No more late-night Gin! Trey is starting to rip it up more and more and the rest of the band is doing that "play everything as hard as you can all at once" thing that they do so well. :p Things rock on in typical "Type I Gin" fashion for a good while now. Around 10 minutes, Page starts inserting the occasional keyboard alongside his piano. The guys all "sync" up and hit upon a slightly metallic groove. At 11 minutes we are full steam ahead, Trey tearing it up, playing with his Whammy pedal, while the rest of the band holds down the fort and lets him start to experiment. By 11:30 we are firmly in Type II finally. Mike has a nice jungle groove happenning. Trey sets a looper and begins to vamp over his loop while Page tries to figure out how to insert his keys. Some very "Metroid" - sounding keyboard insertions here and there. Also, TREY STARTS A FRIGGIN' "I'm A Man" JAM. DUDE. NICE!!! :D So by 12:50 we get Phish jamming out the main motif of "I'm a Man". Wonderful, lol. Best part is when Page jumps on the organ, just cementing this into reality. CHECK OUT PAGE'S PIANO AT 13:50!!!!!!!! This jam continues for a long while and it's absolutely awesome. I mean, it's long enough that they could've separated this into it's own track and I wouldn't complain!!!! THIS IS FREAKING SICK!!!! Around 15:30 we finally leave the jam behind a bit. Looper still going, Trey transitions to doing "porno wah scratching" instead, letting Mike rip it up and Page sprinkle in keys here and there. The jam reaches a natural conclusion around 16 minutes and dies it's death.......


Golgi Apparatus - PARTY TIME!!! After that deep-in-thought Gin journey, this Golgi was a perfect choice to bring us back to reality! Now, now, children. We can't be getting too "out there" just yet! And ya know what?! THIS GOLGI IS FANTASTIC!!! Seriously, a Golgi that is THIS good in 1999?!?!?! Trey is playing with his phrasing in a very nice way, "pushing and pulling" his parts and giving this Golgi some added spunk. This sounds like they rehearsed the song for a month just to bust it out and have it be this good, seriously. Wow, I haven't been THAT impressed by friggin' GOLGI APPARATUS in, like, maybe ever....DANG!!!!

And with that, set 1 comes to a close......



Wowzers!!! That was an awesome set all around! Way better than I "expected" it to be!!! I mean, I knew it'd be good, but for some reason I had "doubts" when looking at the setlist and knowing the 1999 "vibe", if you will. Well hot damn if that wasn't absolutely terrific on the whole. Hell, the opening Wilson was probably the "worst" thing about the set!!

 

 Set 2

Tweezer - An ultra-funky, 20 minute Tweezer to kick off the proceedings? Nice.... And golly, this one GROOVES. Slower than usual, it trudges across the tundra like a behemoth. And at 4 minutes, the jam absolutely launches out of the gate from the word GO! Trey sets a feedback loop then proceeds to quietly jam the Tweezer lick for a bit, letting the guys follow suit before seamlessly returning to the song again like we didn't just have a perfect jam beginning....And the next verse is just CHAOS. Loopers going, everyone crashing about.....Definitely the most "chaotic" version of the SONG portion, yo. Then at 5:50 we return to the jam with Trey kicking things off with some very nice sustained holds. Everyone is clearly still playing around with the Tweezer theme and things are not getting too introspective yet. Everyone is just rocking out slow and hard, Trey doing melodic leads while Fish and Mike play around with the rhythm a bit. Some very nicely timed "crashes" and other things. Then at 7 minutes Trey lays back as Page begins to make his entrance on the piano and keys with his wah pedal. Keep in mind the "screaming seagull" feedback loop is still going strong. At 8:30, Page is carefully placing nice keyboard notes while Trey has turned on his octave-up effect on the Whammy, doing those ultra-high, chirpy-sounding leads. By 9:45, Trey has returned to "porno wah scratching" and lets Page take the lead. But nobody is really claiming the front and center spot...Everyone seems content to be laying back, just building this Tweezer slow and thick. And good golly is it THICK!!! Thicker than THICK WATER!!!! By 13 minutes, everyone is still "vamping" together gloriously. This is one of those sit back and let the groove take over kind of jams. Everyone is really contributing equally, building this "house" of music higher and higher with each passing moment. Each player laying down bricks as a team. This sounds like what you imagine people THINK Phish sounds like when you hear them snobbily go "oh, you like Phish??????" (You know what I mean). At 14 minutes the jam takes a dark turn, and we return to late-night vibes. Everyone is getting quiet and it's a dark and starry night, rather than a sunny, bright afternoon, ya dig? By 15:30 there are hints of ambience creeping in but everyone is still playing together!!!! Fishman is riding the cymbals but also focusing more on tribal tom-tom hits instead of the snare. Page and Trey seem to be locked in together pretty well. Very "aquatic" sound to this jam now. It's like we are underwater, looking through the blurry mass of ocean, into the depths below....Not a black hole affair by any means, but we have left Partyville far behind, so to speak. Page reverts to piano while Trey is placing notes hear and there, slowly dissolving the jam into some watery blissfulness.....By 18:30, if you told me I was listening to a 2012 jam you could have had me fooled! Yea, we are in Type II blissful ambience...beautiful and stirring. Just launch into What's The Use? already, dammit!

>Mountains In the Mist - WTU would've been PERFECT out of that, but ya know what the second most perfect choice is? This guy right here. And good lord the "resolve" of that jam turning into this song was so perfect.....Like a slow exhale after a panic attack or something. I mean, "Mountains" is "Mountains", but the placement of this version out of that aquatic soundscape...that's like 90% of what makes this awesome. It's all about the SET UP! :D Ugh, this was so nice....

Birds of a Feather - And it's off to the races! :D Another perfect set call! The song portion again has the "chill" vibe, almost like they are whispering the song to us or something. Very cool. But then of course it's full steam ahead once the chorus hits! The jam begins for a while as expected. Fire upon fire, yet you can hear Trey slowly trying to "tug" the band unsuccessfully off the beaten path (or maybe he was just high? :p ). This finally happens right at 5 minutes in another of those totally accidentally yet completely perfect moments of band interplay! This lasts about 10 seconds where it sounds like they are going to launch into a different area, but instead they resume to Birds shred-fest. Page does the Trey thing and starts "hinting" with his keys that they should go somewhere else too. This time it's Trey's turn to say "not yet" and instead he forces his guitar destruction upon us. :) At 6:30 the guys have ANOTHER one of these brief "moments" of "hinting" at other realms. C'MON BOYS, STOP TEASING US!!! Hard to explain what I am getting at, but if you listen you will clearly make out these spots. It happens again - this time FOR REAL - at 7:20 with Trey doing a full-tilt reprise of that soaring Chalkdust jam of the heavens!!!! Holy mother of crap this is incredible. The whole band is playing together, yet Trey is also climbing Everest again....It's like they didn't have enough of the CDT jam and wanted to play it again!!!!! FINE BY ME! :D Incredibly uplifting, blissful, yet also shredding all at the same time!!! Just checked the .NET jam chart - Hah! I was right about the CDT "reprise". They hear it too. :) By 10 minutes this is like total rock and roll annihilation on par with the Big Cypress Down With Disease or the 8/14/93 Antelope!!!!! Around 10 minutes we leave the CDT jam again and head for darker pastures. Trey and Page both hit a sustained note, with Trey opting to loop it for a never-ending feedback squeal. Fishman turns up the HEAT and leads us into some breakneck funk jamming!! Basically, picture Birds of a Feather played at 2x speed!!!!! But while the rhythm is lightspeed, the playing itself is VERY quiet and delicate. Trey, Mike and Page all "vamping" it out quickly. Then at 12 minutes Fishman introduces the woodblock and Page jumps back onto HIS wah pedal for some honky keyboard interjections. Page is "tickling" his keys like a good Maze jam, Mike is popping his bass a bit, and Fishman is just going absolutely bonkers. I mean, it sounds like he's playing his entire kit at times. :D Trey is still vamping away to his heart's content, and Page is the one doing the closest thing to "soloing" of any of the 4 (but still, not really). And then at 14 minutes it just DIES! Like, wtf, man, where did the jam go?!?!?!? They just ripcorded that sucker!! :(

>When the Circus Comes to Town - Love the song, love Phish's versions, but every one sounds the same and you know what you're gonna get. Still very nice though and the set placement was tops like that Mist out of the Tweezer! Great version! :)

Fluffhead - After a VERY lengthy 90 second pause (1976 Dead would be proud!), Trey gives us a sloppy intro to Fluff and the crowd goes nuts. The chill vibe of tonight's show is working in Fluff's favor. Very nicely different, but only just so. To start, I can't remember the names of the various sections of Fluff so I'm not gonna go super in depth, but this Fluff is sloppy but right in the best way! Hard to describe! It's not REALLY sloppy, but it's very loose. Almost as if they were busting it out after a long time, but still knew it well enough to pull it off (if that makes any sense at all). Nice build of energy towards the back end and it feels very triumphant as the set closer tonight!!!! All is normal until 13:45 when they guys latch onto one part of the structure and decide to ride it out unexpectedly!!!! WOW!! Another one of those "accidental" moments I keep going on about! But they then revert quickly back to Fluff proper and Trey let's it rip as usual. Just heat and fire, this Fluffhead feels like a steamroller, just mowing down everything in it's path! MOVE OVER PEOPLE, FLUFFHEAD IS HEAR TO CRUSH YOU! :D And then at 15:45 TREY HITS THAT FRIGGIN' CDT SUSTAINED NOTE AGAIN!!!! GOOD GOLLY LET'S HAVE A LITTLE MORE PEAK WITH OUR PEAK, EH?!?!?! Dang.....

While My Guitar Gently Weeps - Not my favorite Beatles/George song and not my favorite cover, but great choice to change it up this night! Genuine rarity as well, so points of course for that! Big points for Trey, his soloing is great and totally makes this one. :D Good stuff!

Tweeprise - Is Tweeprise. Kills. Perfect end!



All in all....holy crap. The Tweezer>Mountains and Birds of a Feather is absolutely must-hear. Terrific set all around. Not too much to say - it's kind of a behemoth! Like, there isn't much to say because it's already all been said, lol. On the whole, I think both sets were about equal. You could get away with "cherry picking" this show if you want, but the whole thing flowed together great so just play the whole thing and shut up. :)

Dang.....