An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Wednesday, March 6, 2024

1997-02-20 Milan, IT

 2 20 97 Milan

Stellar AUD on this, nearly SBD quality

Also, The Curtain might be the best opener ever, no?

:p 

Set 1

The Curtain into Tweezer was a magnificent opening. Tweezer had a great Type jam to it.

Chalkdust exploded and Soul Shakedown was great to hear again

The whole set put set 1 of 2 18 Paris to shame. It was that good.

Look out for the unbelievably amazing version of Taste.

Damn, what a set. 

Set 2 was a major letdown. Good playing but golly what a pedestrian set of song choices.

Set 1 was a total keeper. Set 2 is kinda a bore.  


1997-02-18 Paris, FR

 2 18 97 Paris in the dump truck this morning.

Distant but clear AUD. Not ideal for truck listening but lets go anyway.

Great setlist! 

Set 1 raged damn hard. Total fire. Runaway Jim and Stash both seemed to jam ever so slightly and were really standout versions. C Zero was a nuke but a lousy Slave closed the set.

Peaches to open set 2. Sounded great!  

Wow! Other than no jamming, this show did basically everything else perfectly. A great sleeper hit!

In the 2nd set, Maze, Reba and Hood were must hear. Hood was X Factor Magic all the way. Reba was played flawlessly at lightspeed.

Killer show. A solid 4.0, imo.

1997-02-14 Brussels, BEL

 Onwards to show #4 of my out-of-order, how-far-will-I-get run through of Europe, Winter 1997:

2/14/97 Brussels

Set 1

Exceptional Runaway Jim to open. Type I Jim's don't get much better than this. Peakage all over the place in the best way. Nearly 9 minutes long, this thing is an utter beast of a version. After a nice NICU, we go into a 23 minute YEM. YEM has a great jam - very patient and dynamic. Lots of breaking it down and building it back up, so to speak. Funkier than usual, imo. Chill funk deluxe. No, seriously, this thing RIPS. A+ must-hear YEM!!!!

Out of the YEM vocal jam comes a rare mid-set Sweet Adeline. Very odd placement, but I guess if you're gonna do an acapella number you might as well do it out of a vocal jam!!!

Next is a sequence of hotly played but ultimately nothing special songs - Axilla, It's Ice and Billy Breathes all turn in as-expected strong versions. Unexpected, however, is the rip roaring shredfest that is Uncle Pen. Seriously - I can listen to Trey shred the old bluegrass all damn day.

A hotter-than-the-sun-as-usual Antelope closes this very enjoyable set. All in all, the Runaway Jim and the YEM are all you really need, maybe the Uncle Pen too.

On to set 2!

Set 2

A slightly lethargic AC/DC Bag opens the set. Sounds good, but boy does it drag! Thankfully it picks up more steam as it goes along and by the end has turned in a fine rendition. Bag concludes and into a 9 minute Ya Mar we go. A very fine version that does not feel a minute over 5!!! Great stuff. Into a 12 minute Disease we go...

And of course, Disease is an absolute firestorm like you'd expect. 12 minutes of pure, molten, lave-type destruction right into your ears. A phenomenal Type 1 reading. Funky B follows up and keeps the heat going. Funky B is a little more groovy as expected, but by the end it's just laying waste to everything in sight. Perfect.

Reba is up next and features a brief mishap in the intro. Reba has a few moments of mishap, but they are few and far between and even mentioning them is nitpicking. Let me put it like this, 3.0 Phish would kill to play Reba this well. The solo is decent but never feels like it hits that next level you expect from a classic Reba. All in all, I'd rate this Reba a solid B+ or so for Phish 1.0.

The duo from hell, Walfredo and Rock A William are up next. Honestly, I kinda dig a good version of Walfredo. This one is very spirited but I still give the nod to the 2/13 London reading. Not a fan really of Rock A William. Scent of a Mule and A Day in the Life are both strong but they are among my least FAVORITE Phish songs, so at this point I'm just waiting for it to end.

Thankfully, Character Zero brings down the house again.

A good show, but not really anything to return to ever. The 3.3 rating on .NET is perhaps a little low - I'd give this a solid 3.5 

1997-02-13 London, UK

 After 2 16 and 2 17 yesterday, ive decided to do a casual, see-how-far-I-get, reviews-be-damned listen through of Europe, winter 1997.

General thoughts and notes of course, but these will be plowed through in the dump truck, lol.

Starting today while running errands with 2 13 97 London in my car.

Absolutely BLAZING Chalkdust opener! 

Ripping Wolfman into a FANTASTIC 2001. Putting this in the highlights list for sure.

Stash is friggin spectacular as well

Walfredo is Walfredo, but I doubt it ever sounded better than this. Great version, seriously.  

Ok, this entire first set, just about, was one massive highlight. Energy and enthusiasm out the wazoo, a great flow to the set, and all around extra mustard to the proceedings.

Chalkdust, 2001, Walfredo, Taste, the wah-annihilation Character Zero....

Killer.

 Set 2 begins with the bluesy, fiery, ripping trio of Julius, Cars and My Soul before a great Punch You In the Eye.

Out of Punch comes a strange, dark kind of jam, nearly 9 minutes. Very unique and probably the sole jam highlight of the night. Wow. Extremely strange, like that Carini from the 2012 New Year's run. It's not just feedback, this is an actual jam. Super dark, like you are being slowly pulled into hell or something.

Dude!!!!!

Then the jam dissolves perfectly in a magical Slave that just goes on forever in the best way. 

Man oh man, the set construction on this sucker is just sublime. Seriously, this has to be one of the best flowing shows I've ever heard.  

THIS MAZE! HOLY MOTHER OF CRAP ON A CRACKER THIS MAZE IS DOWNRIGHT DEMENTED OH MY GOODNESS.

My god, that Hood. Is this a particularly well known version? Because this was X Factor Magic with a capital X.

No, seriously, this is an all-timer version and, honestly, maybe the best version I have ever heard. I am not exaggerating.

 

1997-02-17 Amsterdam, HOL

 Got through 2/17 for the first time this afternoon. Holy crap on a cracker.

Disease>jam>Carini>Epic jam>Taste>Disease Reprise.

Dude.

1997-02-16 Cologne, GER

 Just finished 2 16 97

A strong 3.8 to 4.0 kinda show, imo. Really only let down by the sheer lack of jamming.

Crosseyed was almost a strong jam, Free had its moment, and Bowie was ridiculous. Other than that ...

That Bowie is the main takeaway for me and the musical highlight of the show, imo. Definitely Live Bait-worthy. An incredibly flawless fire punch to the face.

I really enjoyed this show a lot, even with such little "replay value".

2021-10-26 Santa Barbara, CA

 10/26/21 Santa Barbara, CA

This looks like a bit of an "off" night after the previous two. Let's see...

Set 1

Pebbles and Marbles - A 20 min version to open the show?! What is this, 2003 or something?! Rages hard on the Type 1 as expected until somewhere around the 9:30 mark. At this point, the jam takes on a spastic late-night kind of groove. Over the next few minutes it just gets wilder and wilder - everyone smashing their instruments as hard as they can with Trey doing nimble lead work atop it all. It's like they are VERY SLOOOOWWWWLLLLYYYY working towards a kind of peak down the line. This goes until around the 14 minute mark. Trey starts to play with delay FX while Page jumps to the electric piano. We are firmly in Type II, boys and girls!!! Around 15:30, the synthesizers come out to play. Page is doing these squiggle lines all over the place and Trey is bouncing off of him, answering his calls. ELECTRIC NOODLE BOOGLAOO! Around 17 minutes, Gordo starts singing the Pebbles and Marbles chorus refrains and the jam shifts into overdrive, going back to a "let's rock and peak this to hell" Type I sound to finish out. But alas it is not to be - Trey starts scratching like he wants to go into BOAF or something and the jam moves again into another zone. It sees the song move into a kind of slower, more groovy pace. Very slowly they notch the tempo down bit by bit until they arrive at an area suitable enough for....

Wow. Where the hell did that come from?! That was sick!

>
Makisupa Policeman -
Wow, talk about a segue, lol. Great stuff. Pretty lengthy and quite funny. Must-hear stuff. :) HELLO! HOW ARE YOU!!?? ROBO MAKISUPA!

Sample In a Jar -
7.5 minutes on this, it rages hard, then right at the 4 minute mark, a legitimate jam develops out of nowhere!! Are they taking this Type II?!?! Yup! It suddenly starts to get real chill and quiet sounding. Wonderful melodic playing ensues and the song slowly "fades out", if you will, with some nice robot playing in the final minute from Trey and Page. It almost sounds like they could transition into Waves or something. Yo, this was must hear. Absolutely unique and worth a listen. Wow!

>The Silver Light - Debut and only performance, with an actual segue into it out of Sample! Wow! Listen to how silent the confused crowd is, haha. This is totally excellent and sounds very rehearsed for sure. It definitely doesn't feel like a debut, being much tighter than you'd expect. They definitely worked on this one hard!!! Play this again!

>Halley's Comet - A nearly 12 minute Halley follows The Silver Light. Halley freaking rages tonight - I can't stop boppin' my head! Immediately, around 5:45, the jam begins with Trey on robo fx, honking it up. Page follows suit, quickly jumping onto the snythesizers. Around the 8 minute mark, the FX jamming gives way to a slightly tropical, more Twist-flavored jam, sounding like the initial Halley's jam they jumped over in the first place. Basically, it's back to the Type I you expect from Halley. Great stuff. This goes until 11 minutes when the jam goes into Type II robot ambience to close for the final 30 seconds. Beautiful....

>Mountains In the Mist
- Great segue. Absolutely friggin' GORGEOUS tonight! No, seriously, this version is damn exceptional, like a 1974 Stella Blue or something. MUST HEAR!

Mull -
3rd version yet of the song. Totally excellent on all fronts. Grooves like a mother. Love this song and every version is just gravy. Great stuff. COULD YOU PASS ME A TACO?! The boys let it RIP and this version is a friggin' volcanic eruption of awesomeness. Sick. It even goes Type II robo weirdness for the final 2 minutes!!!!

>Set Your Soul Free - Trey kinda ripcords the end of the Mull jam and they go into a rocking, 13 minute Set Your Soul Free. Very uptempo! Trey's playing is ferocious and inspired, just ripping it up, hitting all the right notes at the exact right times. Fiery raging. The sucker then proceeds to go Type II, into a blissful yet strange and kinda psychedelic mish-mash of sound. Absolutely must hear, it's probably the best jam of the set besides the opening Pebbles affair. Underrated as hell, I'm gonna say. Please go replay this magical sucker. X Factor abound.



All in all, this set really surprised me! I was prepared to be let down, but EVERYTHING was worth a highlight. If it wasn't a debut, it was opening with a 20 minute jam into a rare cut, if it wasn't a blazing hot Mull it was a type II Sample or a psychedelic Set Your Soul Free. There was a TON going on in this set. If it wasn't all primo when all is said and done you can at least say they effing tried. Hard. A+++++++ for effort on this one, boys and girls. Wow.

 

Set 2

Blaze On - 13 min Blaze On to open. It spends most of it's time in upbeat bliss mode, all nice and melodic. Somewhere around the 11 minute mark this starts to take a darker slant. Eventually it comes to a close and they wind up at Sea of Stars. Definitely worth a highlight, but this version leaves you wanting more. They go deep but it leaves us just as it was getting going!

>Beneath a Sea of Stars - Pretty darn lengthy (13 minutes itself!), this is a superlative reading. It mainly does exactly what you expect, but it's the way they just grab it and refuse to let go. Around the 9 minute mark, things start to get a lot stranger and we shift into a psychedelic kind of Type II. Very cool meltdown-style Sea of Stars!!!!
This is incredible - full on dark psych meltdown!!!!! What is this, Split Open and Melt?!?!?! Must hear!

>
46 Days - Absolutely ridiculous full-blown Melt-style, well, MELTDOWN!!! ROBO MELTDOWN!!!!
This sucker rages hard. Eventually they make a proper return to the 46 Days theme. Trey sees his chance and twists the theme into Sneaking Sally and away we go.

>Sneaking Sally - HOLY CRAP THIS WAS THE FUNKIEST PIECE OF MUSIC PLAYED ALL DAMN YEAR! X FACTOR MAGIC! 10,000 PERCENT MUST HEAR!!!!

>Weekapaug Groove -
And into a very unique, Type II, STANDALONE Weekapaug Groove! Does it's thing, goes to unexpected places, then rages to a finale.

About to Run - Nuclear Annihilation.

If I Could - Is If I Could. Excellent cooloff. 10/10 friggin' version. Just ridiculous in it's gorgeousness.

Sigma Oasis - Yet another song for the highlight reel (literally the whole show at this point...). A ragin, red hot, synth laden Type 1 reading.

F Your Face - Is F Your Face.

Meatstick - Of course it has to come after F Your Face, lol. Perfection.

The Lizards - Excellent reading as ever. Yet another worthy of the highlight reel.

A Life Beyond the Dream - See, the Lizards.



All in all, a highly enjoyable set. Lots of great jamming early on with a focus on segues and short bursts of jamming, ala Inglewood, rather than longform improv. Everything was highlight-worthy - the guys were just killing it tonight. Honestly, it's hard to find much to say about this show because they just lay it all out right in front and shove it in your face. From About to Run onwards it's basically just a run of songs played as-is, but they are all excellently performed with high energy and aplomb.

Maybe not the greatest show of all time but a solid followup to Inglewood. The 3.9 rating on .NET is probably correct. I just wish this show had a LITTLE more meat on it's bones.