An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Sunday, November 5, 2023

2021-08-10 Hershey, PA

 Relaxing for the afternoon doing some much-needed digital "cleanup" of downloaded files, backing things up, organizing things, etc

After playing nine (NINE!) 2018 shows in 5 days (as well as 2 2021 shows last weekend), we move on the next 2021 gig, and supposedly it's the "worst" in many folks' opinions!

8/10/21 Hershey, PA

Set 1

First Tube - An outstanding F Tube to open the show, guns a-blazing. It's F Tube, it peaks hard, it rages, it melts your face from the word "go!". A terrific opener! No, seriously, this sucker DESTROYS. It has so much heat, you'd think they were closing the show, not opening it!

Axilla - The hottest 1-2 punch this side of the 12/31/91 Punch-Sloth!!! Wow! The only reason I'm not highlighting this is you've heard a million hot Axilla's, and this one is no different. But the set placement was perfection and it kept the heat turned HOT!

Fuego - Again with the great set placement!!! This is refreshing as hell getting it so early!!! And right away, as with FT and Axilla, the initial playthrough and soloing is just LOADED to the hilt with more energy and heat than a friggin' nuclear explosion. This is some ROCK SHOW FUEGO stuff, if that makes any sense. If you like your Phish red-hot and ready to ROCK, this is your gig it looks like!! Fuego ends up being an excellent Type I reading. It's a very "explored" Type I adventure, but it never fully leaves the Fuego confines. That being said at the very end they reach the "door opening" moment in the jam for them to lead it into outer space, but alas it as not to be and they ripcord it for Jim....

Runaway Jim - At least this Jim kicks tail! It becomes an outstanding, 10/10 Type I Jim. One of those versions where the soloing is just magical and Trey is hitting every "right" note. The band is just bursting at the seams (LISTEN TO FISHMAN, HOLY HELL!). EXTRAORDINARY JIM!! MUST HEAR! MUST HEAR! MUST HEAR!!!! HOLY CRAP!!!!

:bigeek:

Gumbo - Now that our faces are in a melted puddle on the floor, they give us a "break" and launch into the always-welcome Gumbo. For the sake of not highlighting everything, I'll just say this is a terrific Type I rager ala early 3.0 Phish. Nothing special, but always welcome to get and an excellent reading!

Sample In a Jar - Man, the boys are just in the mood to rock tonight, eh? See Gumbo, Axilla, Jim, etc. Terrific Type I rager, but nothing special. :)

Steam - Up next is a red-hot Steam to cool us back down a tad. But not really :laugh: I gotta say though, A+ on the set flow tonight. I swear, this set is sliding by like buddah, baby.

Sugar Shack - Surprise surprise! I'd say this is great but they play it as seemingly half-speed tonight which makes it friggin draaaaggggg. Otherwise I'd say it's performed excellently.

Llama - FAST LLAMA! LETS FRIGGIN GO!!!! And it's every bit the "25 energy drinks and 20 cups of coffee" rendition you are craving for. This goes toe to toe with any classic 1.0 reading. WORLD DESTRUCTION!!!! :eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:
:bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek:

Death Don't Hurt Very Long - OUTSTANDING!!!!!!
The guys are having an absolute blast and it sounds like Trey is trying not to crack up or something. That's always a good sign. Sick-ass synth solo from Page. Really nasty "rhythmic" jam in the final few minutes that shows potential to evolve into something more if they wanted. Ultra dark and heavy tonight - basically what Steam wants to - but will never - be.

Run Like An Antelope
- Really excellent noodling from Trey in the beginning portion. AND THEN HOLD ON TO YOUR DAMN HATS BOYS AND GIRLS!!!! HERE COMES THE SWIRLING VORTEX OF SONIC NOISE DESTRUCTION!!!! HOLY CRAP!!!! See Llama above!!!! Damn....

:bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek:




Guys....guys....GUYS!!!!! Listen to me. This set was the definition of BALLS TO THE WALL. You NEED to hear that Llama, Antelope, First Tube, Jim and DDHVL. This was one of the HOTTEST, most fire-laden first sets I have ever heard in my entire life. What the hell!? This threw me for such a loop! I was expecting a bad set considering this show's "reputation" and the disgusting 3.2 rating on .NET.

NO ACTUAL 3.2 SHOW HAS A FIRST SET THIS INCREDIBLE.

All in all...

:bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek::bigeek: 


Set 2

No Men In No Man's Land - A 16-minute barn burner to open the set always bodes well! Rages molten lava type 1 as expected for a good long while. The first signs of things getting wacky appear around 7 minutes when Trey does this slow, oddball creep northward for about 30 seconds. He lands upon a soloing spot and starts building the peak blissfully ever upward from there, turning on his robo wah in the process. As expected, Fishman is absolutely laying waste to his kit throughout all of this. Around 9 minutes the bliss starts to slowly drift....sideways. Page jumps on his synths and Trey is doing the Robot Goose Honk 5000 Extreme over yonder. Meanwhile we are still at a 1999 Birds of a Feather breakneck tempo. Throughout all of this, Trey is just going banana sandwich on his wah pedal, doing lots of wide-sweeping "washes", so to speak. Fishman is still exploding behind the kit like a 1000 fireworks all detonated at once and this jam has you going "hold on for your life!". At 11 minutes things gently change again with Gordo kicking on his FX and Trey doing tons of super cool and wacky delay stuff. Not the typical "cascading waterfall" either!! By 11:30 there is no doubt that Type II has entered the chat. By 13 minutes this runaway sports car of a jam shows zero sign of slowing down, but Trey returns to his normal tone and the jam begins another "building to a massive peak" section. What in the hell is going on - how does one play music this HOT?!?!?!??!

13 minutes and 41 seconds in - :wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf::wtf:

Immediately following that "robot peak from the Lord", the jam "quiets down" for the first time. Trey is completely in outer space, using every effect under the sun, while Gordo is honking it up big time and Page is trying to figure out how the hell to step back into this maelstrom! It's the aural equivalent of a soupy, swirling, hurricane storm. Unfortunately at 15:30 Big Red starts singing the chorus again and you know "oh man, the jam is over....". And just like that, this budding MONSTER comes to an awkwardly forced conclusion....damn....that was....no words....


>
Soul Planet - * facepalm * You ended that jam for Soul Planet?! REALLY?!?!??!
Ok, you guys know I adore Soul Planet and this flowed better than it had any right to, but I can totally understand the complaints now. :p :biglaugh:Right at 3:29 the jam achieves liftoff. Page is on the keys and while the tempo is breakneck, the jam has a much chiller, jazzier, vibe to it than that INCENDIARY No Men. The intensity is slowly building. Trey kicks on his FX and is scatting along "screaming through space...screaming through space....".... At 4:45 Page returns to the piano and the clearness of it gives this jam a certain weight. So now it's Page on piano, Trey on Goose Honk 5000 Robo FX and the whole jam is like a rocket hurtling through outer space. Ultra-wacky but super badass. By 7 minutes Trey has toned back most of his FX and we are in a straight on Type I guitar-solo jam for a bit, until he has trouble hitting the right key and unintentionally ends up steering the jam into the next phase!! The playing becomes much more melodic, still anchored by Page's pounding piano, letting Trey just blissfully peak it up on top of it all. Soaring to the skies!!! By 10 minutes Page goes to his keys and Fishman goes all half-speed on us, altering the tone of the jam to a slower, more powerful exercise in peak-building. At 12 minutes, just before reaching the top of Everest, Trey does a weird, in-jam ripcord of sorts and forces them into a funkier direction. Lots of bluesy power chords, almost going back to that DDHVL/Steam thing. I swear, if Trey tossed in the Steam lick here, the whole universe would've erupted. The song fades out with a quasi-reggae jam leading you to think "are we getting Makisupa now?!?!". But alas, 'tis not to be! Instead, Trey does something unlikely and slowly leads the band into....

>NICU - YES! THAT SEGUE WAS AWESOME! THANK YOU LORD FOR NOT BUTCHERING THAT!!!! I DID NOT SEE THAT COMING! :D This is why we Phish!!!! Really excellent type 1 version

>Joy - Holy freaking hell, that was the greatest set placement/transition into I've ever heard!!!! PERFECT!!!! Joy is Joy but it was an excellent version and came at the exact perfect point in the set. A+ all around.

Scent of a Mule - MULE! LET'S GO!!! Here we go again with the perfect set-placements!!! Awesome and wacky, what with the new robot sounds and everything (Galactic Cowboys for rule, jah feel?) Excellent and weird as always. Great stuff.

Golden Age - It feels like the set takes a turn here. Golden Age is pretty chill. And not super extended. Sounds kinda "loosed" tonight, for sure. Golden Age ends up being very nice but never does enough, really. Fine version but nothing anyone will be shouting about from the rooftops in years gone by. I really wonder why Trey decides to move out of it though as it was building a head of steam for sure...

>Prince Caspian - Ok, that was one of the absolute WORST calls I've ever heard. Dang it, Trey.... Love Caspian, but Golden Age was congealing into something and then.....ripcord. :realmad::realmad::realmad::realmad::realmad: What's even worse is that Caspian is incredibly nice featuring a spectacular peak from Trey, but it's also just short enough to make you go "that's it? You wasted Golden Age for that?". Dang, man....

>Number Line - Oh no, the dreaded 3rd quarter Number Line set derailment....What is going on?! I love Number Line, but this show was going spectacularly until that Golden Age ripcord....And then Trey goes "nah, I don't really feel like doing much with Caspian either, sorry." MAKE UP YOUR MIND, TREY!!! PLEASE! Number Line tries its hardest and turns in a fine performance, but it's also nothing to write home about either. You've heard many other versions that are even better. A for effort, though.

The Lizards - Ooh, it pains me so to not highlight this. I adore The Lizards and always love hearing it. Just an ok version - the guys sound tired at this point, like they have, blown their....um, you know what I'm saying. It's an ok version, but it's not super tight and, like Number Line, you've heard a million other much better renditions.

Character Zero - See Above. What happenned?!

Rock and Roll -
Thank you lord!!! Our savior!!! An inspired encore choice and it brings down the house. Great stuff!!



All in all....yea, I guess, well....see above!!! The set was going amazingly up through NICU. Then Golden Age got killed and the set nosedived. It wasn't even the songs chosen (though that didn't help) but the ENERGY was sucked out of the set. I can't describe it but I've never heard another show go downhill that much out of nowhere.

Not a classic show, but a damn fine one. If this is the worst of the year, this is the greatest year of Phish ever played, ya dig?

A great show well worth at least one listen!! :D

No comments:

Post a Comment