An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Saturday, January 18, 2025

2024-08-16 Dover, DE - Mondegreen #2

 8/16/24 Dover - Mondegreen #2

Set 1

The set gets off to an interesting start with a Bouncing opener! This actually works great, feeling more like an overture or into to the show rather than the "actual" opener. Very cool.

Kill Devil Falls immediately yanks us awake, however. A very interesting version, they take this one for a RIDE!! Not quite the robot hellscape of Light from 8/15, it still follows the same basic course, quickly deviating and totally going sideways for its duration. Relaxingly chaotic!!! Type 2 all the way, baby!! I dont know if Id call it must hear but is absolutely unique as hell and demands a jam chart entry!! Cool stuff!!!

The fun keeps going with a powerhouse Peaches!! The crowd roars approval and the boys burn it down. Awesome version for sure!!!

Free is really good but nothing special overall. Great little standard version with a little more funk than usual.

The first true must hear big boy of the night is Divided Sky. An absolutely inspired version, there is extra mustard all over this sucker. Played flawlessly, it just has that extra specialness about it. In a Gamehendge bereft summer, this just feels fresh!! Grab this sucker!!!

Small steps forward with set as me move into a very, very nice Tube. Only 7 minutes, but the jamming is great. Trey makes wonderful use of the whale siren loop and his delay pedals. Awesome stuff. Throw this on the highlights list as well. The funkiness slowly builds into a sizzling heat and they proceed to just tear our damn faces off. Definitely must hear! Sometimes the small treasures are the best treasures!!!! This smoked!!!

A really, really, extra excellent Mountains gives us a quick breather. Im burnt out on the song but this version definitely made me take notice. Definitely must hear!!! :) 10 outta friggin 10. This version was downright magical!!!!

Following Mountains, we get what may be the Reba of the year and one of the finest of this whole period of Phish!! Downright flawlessly played and tight like its 1995, it builds to the typical peak, but this one is so good it will give you goosebumps. Definitely must hear! An incredible reading!!!

Then, I was deflated when they moved into Twist (please shelve this for a while, im so done with 8 minute Twists!). However, this one is totally different to the laid back version from Bethel. This one just about goes type 2 and totally reaches a crazy rock and roll energy! This deserves a damn jam chart!!! Must hear? Probably. It's definitely refreshing!!!!

The set closes with a typically facemelting C Zero.

All in all, this set felt like a strange step down from night one for reasons I cant really place. Divided Sky, Mountains and Reba are all essential, while Tube, Twist, Peaches and KDF all deserve major mention.

Definitely a great set but I think it was perhaps a bit too "all over the place", if you will. 

Set 2

And the 2nd set opens surprisingly with an 11 minute My Friend! MyFr is a powerhouse. They dont really take it dark, but the rock it to hell and back.

Just as the jam fizzles out, they launch into a crushing No Men. This one ragers hotter than a supernova, eventually spending a few minutes in absolutely glorious Type 2 "screaming through robo space" land. This kicks SO MUCH ASS!!! X FACTOR ALL OVER!!! THIS WAS SPECTACULAR!! IF THIS DOESNT HAVE YOU HEADBANGING THEN YOU HAVE ISSUES!!!

And just as that jam reaches a natual apex, they launch into a 15 minute Ruby Waves. And holy moly this Ruby is a BEAST!!!! Super powerful, they rage hard until morphing into a funky kind of tropical island jam, or something. Very Twist like. They explore this far and wide until slowly things get dark and the jam devolves into a damn Melt jam!! Dark and broken and screwed up. Just fantastic. Total X Factor on this one. Essential!!

And out of the ashes of Ruby comes Pillow Jets. And oh my sweet Icculus. Top 5 or 10 jam of the summer right here. Holy mother of F......So PJ itself just annihilates, extra sauce all over. Then the jam suddenly moves into a crazy uptempo jam and we get ANOTHER PJ>Your Pet Cat pairing!!! The YPC back into Ruby is utterly DEVASTATING. Outer Space X Factor Dance Party gone wild!!!!! If must hear had a name, its the 8/16 PJ>YPC>RW. An absolutely masterpiece of jamming in league with the best of any era of Phish!!

WHAT ARE YOU DOING JUST SITTING THERE?!?!?! GO THROW IT ON AND LOSE YOUR MIND!!!!!

A nice Ghost keeps things moving. Its an excellent reading but stays in the "upbeat bliss rock" zone. Still, an honestly great version regardless. Really awesome outro with Page and Trey linking up. The outro jam really builds a strong head of steam and they shift flawlessly into a No Men reprise to close this psychedelic sandwich of ridiculousness. Im on the fence about calling that Ghost essential but it was definitely a perfectly fitting component of the set!!!!

Oh my effing god you guys. The Dead had their various sandwiches, but Phish just added a new all timer sandwich to the list......

AND NOW LETS JUMP INTO FLUFFHEAD!


As with Reba, Fluffhead is essential. Yet another dang near flawless reading from the boys. Not much to say. Fantastic.

The Harry Hood into First Tube is so great I'm not even bothering to say how so. Hood is, again, another must hear.....

All in all..... what do you say when you run out of things to say?!?!?! Set 1 was great but felt a bit "lesser" to me for whatever reason.

Set 2 was an absolute mother effing monster. Aside from MyFe, id say basically the entirety of set 2 and the Hood are must hear. For as incredible as night 1 was, this 2nd set was crazy, inspired and totally cohesive in the best way.

Juggernaut supreme.

Yea, I understand the 4.5 rating now...

 


No comments:

Post a Comment