An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Showing posts with label 1998. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1998. Show all posts

Sunday, September 28, 2025

1998-07-15 Portland, OR - The O.G. Live Phish Series, Vol. 17

 In to work late today at 1030 so Im at the ""morning hype has subsided now im chilling" part of my day

The "1998" section of my day, if you will :)

So, skipping out of order from my "OG Live Phish Vol. 1-20" series of reviews I got distracted from 2 years ago, we jump ahead to Volume 17....

This review will be short it's hard to say anything noteworthy about a lot of songs in 1.0 shows considering the base level of excellence of most of them. It's like "well that was great and that was great too and that was also great!!!" By modern Phish standards everything would be highlight worthy.....

7/15/98 Portland

Set 1

Fresh off the summer euro tour, the band slowly glides into a lovely Wolfman to start the show. Very laid back, though it gets COOKIN in the back half. Nothing special, but know it's excellent.

Water In the Sky is next and I swear it just feels perfectly placed! Youll go "oh crap, that WORKS!" Great stuff.

I'm sure this review will be shorter than most - considering this is 1.0, even average readings of songs are still excellent on the whole, so differentiating between an average excellent version and a true must hear rendition is a little trickier than with modern shows, make sense??

After the excellent Water, comes a terrific 10 minute Moma. Basically Wolfmans counterpart, its nothing that special but is just overall REALLY NICE in the smoothest way. Good stuff. Hell, the vocals dont even come in until after the 5 minute mark!!

Guyuute is flawless. What is there to say? Horn is a nice little surprise. Horn is Horn, but out of it comes maybe the first must hear piece of the night. The song ends and they slowly morph into this really beautiful kind of hazey, atmospheric bliss jam. Total late night, starry sky ambience....just beautiful.... Slow building, growing from quiet peace up into a powerful kind of climax. This kind of stuff is why we Phish. Awesome.

And then Trey "ruins" the mood and rips us into a burning 9 minute Chalkdust. Typically killer reading, it kinda sticks out in this otherwise chill set. Still excellent though!!

Following lovely readings of Beauty and Brian and Robert we get the next must hear of the night. Cars, Trucks, Buses is loaded with extra rocket sauce. Check out Page's piano soloing - it's extra jazzy in a way that I have never heard out of this song. And then slowly it gets harder rocking until Trey is eventually on the wall pedal ripping it up. I'm calling this a genuine must here it's pretty dang sick.

Roggae is gorgeous as ever, this one sounding almost hypnotic. Nothing much to say, it's great. :p

Following Roggae, Trey gives a lengthy little speech regarding all the new songs that are playing and how they just recorded a new album prior to the recent European tour. "F-ck it, we'll play some new songs!" Lol

And indeed they do, moving the set onward with a killer version of Birds of a Feather. It's so cool to hear the song played very similarly to the album rendition, with lots of dynamics in the playing, as opposed to the straight up rager versions of later years. Great stuff.

The set concludes with a really excellent, and borderline must here in my opinion, version of Loving Cup. Hot but laid back at the same time. It rips as usual but has such a subtly groovy kind of....flow to it. Wonderful.

All in all, I generally really enjoyed this set from start to finish. No covers like this summer tour would be known for in the future, plenty of new material, a wide VARIETY of material....As expected from 1998, the set is chill as hell but, but more in that perfectly laid-back kind of way rather than a sleepy way. Plenty of heat, counter balanced out with groovy flowing vibes.

Id say the Horn outro jam, Cars and Loving Cup are must hear, but Wolfman, Moma, Chalkdust and Birds are all worth checking out as well.

:)  

 

Set 2

Really interesting and unique choice of a 13 minute Limb By Limb to open the second set! It's a genuinely terrific type 1 reading, good enough that I'm going to call it must hear. Just gooey and hot and flowing and powerful. Really killer reading.

After a brief minute or so of outro ambience it moves awkwardly into an excellent as well type 1 Simple. Really great stuff working as a perfect one to punch with Limb.

Great start to the set! And it only gets better from here, when we launch into a 17 minute Tweezer! And its obviously fantastic as expected. :) Following the typically unhinged 90s reading of the song, it immediately drops into a spacey, quasi ambient groove. Gordo and Fishman holding down the fort while Trey and Page layer synths and loopers and whale sirens atop. Very sick. After a groovy long while it gets a head of steam and slowly moves into a more rocking direction for a bit before winding up in the super funky stew kinda jam you expect from the song. Its hard to describe - its like a subtle 3 act play kind of jam. The kind you just sink into like a comfy sofa and let wash over you. Killer.

In a really awesome/awful ripcord/trainwreck moment, Trey actually picked up on a cool moment with which to make a transition out of the jam, leading into Free. It was actually a really creative and unseen kind of transition that would have worked amazingly. Unfortunately, Fishman seems totally startled and completely drops the ball, dropping out and ruining the segue entirely, lol.

Free, as a result, takes a long time to settle in, completely nerve racked by that horrendous disaster of a transition, lol.

Fear not though, as the song goes on to deliver a STELLAR performance! Utterly kick ass, the usual Free wah abuse soloing is 10/10 and blazing hot. Eventually it somehow starts to get more rhythmic and groovy - when the cowbell comes out its game on!!! The jam gets funky but also kinda... tropical? Beachy? Either way its absolutely SICK and must hear regardless. A freaking COOL version!!!

:D

The set then continues with the slowest, goopiest Meat Ive ever heard. No, seriously. Meat is a slow song and this version is almost at half speed, lol. Meat is merely a little interlude however with the set concluding with Harry Hood.
Must hear. A terrific slow burn version in line with the rest of the show, the extra relaxed nature of this version adds a whole nother level of magic to it, just flowing like butter and with a wonderful peak. Hell yes. Grab this sucker!

Slightly disappointing encore of Circus into Tweeprize.

All in all this is a fantastic show. I'd probably rate it like a 4.3 or something. For set two, Limb, Tweezer, Free and Hood are all must hear.

Classic show is classic, enough said. Nothing else really needs to be said!!!
 

Friday, March 8, 2024

1998-11-21 Hampton, VA

 11/21/98 Hampton

Set 1

Wilson - Fun choice of opener! Surprisingly jammed out! For real, they take it to some super late-night-psychedelia kind of place with Trey just shredding the place to bits. Unique version to me! Don't miss!

>Big Black Furry Creature From Mars - Talk about a perfect 1-2 PUNCH IN THE FACE to kick the show off!!! HOLY FREAKING CRAP! EVER HEARD ANYONE PLAY THE SOUND OF A JET ENGINE TAKING OFF ON GUITAR?! NO?! WELL LISTEN TO THIS!!! Also, is this the longest non-broken-up BBFCFM?! Sure seems like it.

[​IMG]

Lawn Boy - Yea, Trey totally wrote a setlist for tonight I'm guessing. You wouldn't think so on paper, but when listening it just slides perfectly out of the hurricane-force maelstrom we just endured. And it's wonderful as usual. Big points added for great set construction. :)

Divided Sky - Now that we have the "hijinks" out the way it's time for some serious music. :) In early 3.0 versions, it sounds like the band/Trey have rediscovered a lost reverence they maybe once had for the song that they probably lost a little bit by this time in Phish 1.0. Ten-plus years of playing a song pretty regularly will do that to you :p What I mean is, the first four or so minutes of this version sound a little stiff and stilted. Everything is played fine and it's overall a typical excellent 1.0 Divided Sky, but it just sounds out of place or something. Like it doesn't belong anymore, ya know? Very odd feeling with this one!!! Yes, I'm overthinking in the extreme - isn't that the point of writing stupid reviews? :p And then we reach the infamous "pause" portion of the song. The crowd is going ballistic! And it's a friggin long pause too - I didn't time it but had to be a minute+ of just applause, haha. In the "quiet" part for the next couple of minutes, the stiffness continues, especially with Trey making lots of little flubs. No trainwrecks or anything but more missed notes than usual. Once the "upswing" occurs around the 9:30 or so mark, it's funny to hear Trey struggling with feedback bursts. I've never heard a Divided Sky with feedback squeals, so that's pretty cool, haha. Page is going nuts, Gordo isn't super audible (listening over laptop speakers....) and Fishman is being a little more "stompy stompy" with his fills than usual. I swear, this is the most ham-fisted Divided Sky I've ever heard. Were the other 1998 ones like this or is this just an off night for it? :p All in all, this is an odd Divided Sky for me. But it's still an adventure so...I personally was not very impressed by this one though I enjoyed it as usual. Would love to hear opinions on this one!!!

Cry Baby Cry - BUSTOUT! First since summer 1995!!! It's not particularly amazing, sounding rusty and one of my least favorite Beatles songs, so no list for me :)

Boogie On Reggae Woman - 4th version since the Dayton '97 bustout. Other an excellent extended Cactus solo section, this version does very little for me. Trey even sounds like he's mentally checked out by the end and ripcords us into....

>NICU - Not a great version. Trey is still "slipping up" throughout and it just sounds a little tired overall.

Don't know why, but it really sounds like the guys are having a hard time finding their mojo tonight. The opening trio of tunes was great but everything since has been tired or "underplayed"-sounding. Very odd. Or is this a substance issue creeping in? :p

Dogs Stole Things - Well, color me shocked that this is the next list-worthy tune for the night! The boys sound awake again, and Trey even lets it rip after being AWOL for a few songs, pretty much. Far from my favorite song and one I'd never hope for on a setlist, but a great version is a great version. Check out Page's wonderful piano fills in the verses behind the vocals. Friggin' awesome version. :)

Nellie Kane - Color me shocked, vol. 2!!! First version since 1994!!!! And it's a great one!! CHECK OUT PAGE'S KILLER PIANO RIFFING THROUGHOUT! And Trey is nimble as it gets once more. Nellie Kane is awesome tonight, haha.

Foam - Page is turning out to be the MVP of the set. Gah, friggin' love his piano playing on this Foam. Trey doesn't sound as sloppy as Divided Sky but he doesn't sound super tight either. Trey tightens up by the end and this turns into a rousing Foam. Great peaking for the last couple of minutes!!!! Awesome Foam!

Wading in the Velvet Sea - Absolutely terrific! Wonderfully emotional playing tonight. Not much to say. It's beautiful!

Guyuute - KILLER KILLER KILLER. BUTCHER THE PIG! SLAUGHTER THE SOW!! Quite possible the best performance of the set so far! FRIGGIN NEXT LEVEL GUYUUTE!

Bold As Love - Good stuff but one of my least favorite covers.


All in all, an odd set. I never thought I'd hear a set where Nellie Kane was better than Divided Sky!!! The guys started the set strong, took a dive for a bit and then slowly peaked more and more the closer we got to the set break. Very interesting set. Not my favorite but I did enjoy it on the whole. 

 

Set 2

Sabotage - Ah yes. 3rd version of 1998 and last until 2011. Super fun. Freaking love Trey's vocals on this - for some reason he is just putting a grin on my face. :p "AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!" Adam Horowitz would be proud. Talk about a freaking blast to open the set, holy hell. Love it or hate, I friggin' LOVED it!!! :)

>Mike's Song - The jam wastes NO time getting funky immediately! Trey is doing his patented "wah scratching", and there is some cool repeating patterns happenning in the background. Of course Gordo is absolutely funking it up and Page is over on the organ doing stabs. Eventually Trey lays off the scratching and starts picking out some leads patiently. Everyone is locked in and riding the proverbial train together. Nobody is trying to lead, but everyone is along for the ride. Awesome stuff. This is one of those slow-build jams that just cooks and cooks, little by little, getting hotter by the second. Around 7:22 things start getting slightly metallic! Trey and Gordo lock in on a rhythmic pattern and turn the jam towards more Wilson-esque, heavy metal fare. By 8 minutes Fishman is destroying the kit and Trey is playing with his Whammy, making weird robot noises towards the heavens. This culminates in the next "plateau" where Trey goes all 12/6/97 on us, just destroying it on the wah pedal. Of course everyone else is killing it too, but what do you want me to say? :p This is pretty much how the rest of Mike's Song plays out, everyone just raging hard, Trey murdering his guitar, feedback squeals and all. EXCELLENT Mike's Song!!! Maybe not the A+ All Time Version Ever Played, but there's no reason this should not be on the .NET Jam Chart (it isn't!!!). AWESOME!

>Simple - Of course a Mike's>Simple is nothing new, but hot damn if that wasn't one of the smoothest transitions I've heard!!! The jam dissolves into the bliss we all know and love around the 6:30 mark. From there it just gets quieter, and softer and gentler. Softer than an infant's bottom. Absolutely spectacular playing all around, Page doing beautiful runs and Trey doing quietly psychedelic "squiggles" throughout. Around 8:30 the beat drops out leaving Fishman just doing cymbal taps. Gordo picks up on Trey's playing and he and Big Red start doing some circular kinda motifs. And by 10 minutes the ambient droning has begun - It sounds like we are chilling at the bottom of the sea, gazing towards the distant light of the sun shining through the water....They stay in this aquatic-sounding moodscape for several glorious minutes. Oh man, if you are anxious, put this on. This is some of the most soothing Phish I've ever heard. Around 13:30 the synthesizers begin to creep in and Trey and Gordo start doing lots of bendy things. Almost a country-ish vibe creeping in in a weird way. But there is still synthesizer pulsing along in the background very oddly.....At this point it feels like we've gone from chilling on the sea floor, to standing on the moon, watching the beauty of earth all those miles away, gazing at the stars instead of the sun....And just like that, it's over.....WOW!

>The Wedge - Huh. Definitely not what I would have expected to come next if I wasn't looking at the setlist!! In hindsight, it actually fits great coming out of the chill dissolution of that Simple jam!!! Great version as usual. Trey is "ON" this set - he's hitting the exactly "correct" notes in the best way. This Wedge isn't SUPER special or anything, it's just really, really friggin' NICE!

>
The Mango Song - Hey yo! Didn't see this one comin', didya?
Check out Page's AWESOME piano tinkling around 2:30. GORGEOUS!!!! Followed by some FLAWLESS playing from Trey...Ugh, *chef's kiss* And just, like, god damn the rest of the song is one of the most flawless renditions of Mango Song ever performed. Absolutely A++++++++ Mango. MAGICAL MANGO!!!

>Free>Ha Ha Ha>Free - Right into the main riff. No way that wasn't planned. That was a little TOO perfect. Free wastes no time getting down to business, Gordo absolutely destroying on the 4 string machine!!!! But all of a sudden in the middle of the jam they launch right into Ha Ha Ha. Now that was DEFINITELY planned! Love it. So perfect! :p The crowd is eating it up too, :p And then back into Free like nothing. Where did that come from, and where did it go?! And for 5 more minutes, cue guitar destruction. MACHINE GUN TREY IS IN THE HOUSE! LETS FRIGGIN GO!! That was AWESOME! :D

Weekapaug Groove - FREAKING GET IT CACTUS! LISTEN TO MIKE SHRED THAT BASS!!!! Surprisingly, Weekapaug actually gets quasi-jammed out. Trey inserts some obvious Mango Song references and the whole thing is just annihilating worlds in the best of ways. LIGHTSPEED WORLD DESTROYING MACHINE GUN EXPLOSION WEEKAPAUG GROOVE!!!! HOLY CRAP!!!

[​IMG]

Tubthumping - Why. Why god why!? :p Features Tom Marshall as well as Carl on Trumpet again! :D It's funny hearing the guys trying to not bust out into laughter. The trumpet is pretty friggin' hysterical, holy hell :D


All in all, Night 2 of Hampton Comes alive was a success. On the whole, I prefer night one, but there is no arguing with the second set of 11/21 at all! The Mike's>Simple is essential listening as is the out of this world incredible Mango Song and the Free sandwich. Nevermind the "gone plaid" Weekapaug! :D The first set of this show was definitely the weakest of all four sets in the 2 shows, in my humble opinion. But this 2nd set was one of the best 70 minutes of continuous music I've enjoyed recently!!! Terrific 2nd set!!! :D

1998-11-20 Hampton, VA

 Playing night 1 of Hampton Comes Alive for the first time right now (seriously doing this "release order" archive shows run :p )

I've listened to only 2 or 3 Fall '98 shows and mostly have been scared off by the "strange" looking setlists :p

Very excited to get some more Fall '98 under my belt! I'm aware of the more "party" vibe of these shows and the mass of covers as opposed to them being giant musical signposts. I'm going in with a clean slate hoping to have my face melted. :)


11/20/98 Hampton

Rock and Roll Part 2 - I know 1998 was "The Year of the Cover", but did anyone see this coming (or friggin' Rhinoceros for that matter?!). Great opener bit to get the crowd pumped!

Tube - Very short and VERY sweet. A good candidate to put on a "non-album songs" fake-album. Too short to really get going enough to make it list-worthy - I mean, it's short. Still great though!

Quinn The Eskimo - Great fun! FIRST SINCE 1987!!! Great to hear it sung by Mike. I can't recall offhand but aren't those 2012 versions I've heard recently sung by Trey? This definitely get the positive vibe going and keeps the PARTY feel from Tube. Pretty awesome! I mean, it's not anything better than your typical 2012 rager version of Loving Cup, but this was a bustout, no? And to get it as song 3 of the show is great.

Funky B - Keeping The Party Going, Vol. 4 :p Not the overplayed beast it would become in early 3.0 (as awesome as EVERY one of those versions is....), it's nice to hear it "fresh" when they hadn't completely figured out how to make every version sound the same. :) It's not really anything special OVERALL, but like Quinn, it just has a little extra sauce tonight and again, wasn't this kinda a bustout for the era? So points for that. A merry time was had by all! EDIT: Funky B was absolutely NOT any sort of rarity by this point, but it's still weird for me to hear a 1.0 version after so many 3.0 ones :p

Guelah Papyrus - Great setlist choice!!! Really nothing special about this version though.

Rift - Good version, but nothing special for the period. Less fire than expected but still expertly performed! Fishman is without a doubt the MVP on it though. He is just annihilating that drum set!

Meat - One of my favorite "deep" cuts (no pun intended ;) ). Always great to hear. For the final minute, the song drifts into ambience, ala your typical 2012 song ending. Good version, not really anything special still.

Stash - YUCK! EW! WORST INTRO BUTCHER EVER! GROSS! PUKETASTIC! YUCK!! :( Thankfully this seems to have spurred them on and the song portion is terrific. Extremely dynamic playing tonight and this is one of the best performances of the song I can think of as far as little unique fills, enthusiasm and just overall extra oomph! Hard to explain without hearing it. Somewhere around 6:45 or so it sounds like a jam starts to develop with Page and Trey slowly beginning to stray outside the "lines" of the song. Fishman and Gordo get in on the action as well and we are officially doing a slow launch into something deeper. But then at 8 minutes Trey plays around with the Stash theme a bit keeping us firmly in Type I itching to go Type II territory. They are just walking that tightrope but refusing to take the plunge! By 9:20 things have finally begun to PEAK and the real raging commences! Even the crowd picks up on this and they elicit and audible roar!!! By 10:20 all four members of the band are absolutely strangling their instruments, just smashing this Stash into friggin' pieces. How they manage to make listenable NOISE while remaining IN KEY is one the greatest things ever :) By 12:30 they cap it off and Stash is no more. An absolutely terrific Stash. If I wasn't this tired tonight I'd probably rave about it even more. A great example of a version that COULD have gone into a massive Type II beast easily but didn't need to in the end. Terrific Jamming Restraint on this one. A+ Stash!

Train Song - Perfect cool down!! For real, talk about a good spot after having our faces melted by Stash, haha. Absolutely delicate in the best way. Allllmmmooossstttt list-worthy, but not quite. Train Song is Train Song. Every version is like this. :p Still great!

Possum - Rages as usual, but Trey does a lot of interesting "pattern"-based playing that makes this notable compared to other Possum's. Worth a listen!

Roggae - Just sublime and gorgeous. Check out Cactus tearing it up!!! A+ Roggae all the way around. Just POWERFUL!

Driver - Ooh, a nice "rarity" again (not really for the time, but overall). But like Train Song, Driver is Drive. Good as always but nothing special.

Split Open and Melt - Around 4:30 the jam begins with Trey allowing some feedback for a few seconds. Fishman keeps the Melt rhythm going but Page, Trey and Gordo all latch onto a new repeating motif on top of it. At 5:30 the dynamics start to occur with Page pounding away on the piano while Trey plays subtly with the wah. By 6 minutes Fishman begins to deviate greatly from the Melt rhythm, keeping the time signature but altering the parts being played. By this point Trey is just politely soloing on top of the "bed" that the other three are putting down. But I mean you could say the exact same three about the other three guys at this point as well. By 7:30 Fishman start throwing in some cymbal accents that signal another "section" of the jam. This jam is evolving slowly, still rooted in the Melt rhythm overall. But by 8 minutes things are slowly beginning to drift a little bit sideways. Pure Type 1.5 Territory. By 9 minutes Trey's soloing is getting a little bolder and hotter with the overall intensity of the jam slowly beginning to ramp up second by second. It's like someone is turning up the oven heat, one degree at a time. It's getting hotter, but it's taking it's damn time! By 10 minutes Trey has begun his psychedelic shredding like we are heading for a 12/6/97-style meltdown again!!!! Crazy delay and backwards guitars abound!!!! The other three guys are just tearing it up, all great in their own way, but Trey is clearly Lead Soloist during this portion. This all goes on for a while and it feels like the jam never truly PEAKS. It gets darn hot but never feels "finished" to me. An odd feeling. But they do bring it to a natural conclusion point so I give points for a "proper" ending. An excellent Melt on the whole, but as with Stash, it really just "bubbles under" rather than reaches Volcanic Eruption status. Very interesting.



All in all, set 1 was very enjoyable!! It played out about as I expected. I'd say Stash, Roggae and Melt are THE main highlights to grab. The set flowed way better than I expected though!!! Played right through like an assembled playlist. I know Trey abandoned setlists by this point, but does anyone know if he "constructed" these 2 shows? Seriously, the set flow was perfect!

Great first set! Definitely go in with no expectations and ride the Vibe Train. :) 


Set 2

Bathtub Gin - Lots of VERY different piano playing from Page during the verses!! Never heard a Gin with piano fills like this!!! Sick! Bring it on, Leo! Somewhere around 6 minutes or so the Type I begins. Love how audible Mike is on this recording. Every live Phish release should have a mix like this. It's PERFECT. Like listening to a Rush album or something. :p Back to Gin, some awesome Page soloing around 7:15 and Trey is still showing restraint. Fishman is slowly amping up the energy with each passing minute. Cactus is absolutely tearing it up - seriously, he's just going all John Entwistle on this sucker at points. AND I CAN HEAR HIM FOR ONCE! :D Something changes around 8:45. There is a some "switch" that gets flicked, so to speak, and the jam just begins to liftoff seriously. Page is still going absolutely bonkers as well as Mike and Fishman. Really, Trey is the one laying back the MOST on this Gin!!! Ah yea, Cactus, hit those bass effects around 10 minutes! :D AND THE INTENSITY KEEPS BUILDING!!! Seriously, Fishman keeps amping it up more and more and more and MORE!!!! Around 10:30 the boys hit a massive raging peak and I swear I can hear the crowd cheering way in the background. This Gin is SUPER TENSE in a great way! Feels like when I'm hopped up on Adderall and Caffeine! :D By 11 minutes Trey is focusing on repeating motifs and licks and everyone else is just POUNDING away on their respective instruments. Seriously, I wouldn't be surprised if Page broke a few keys on this Gin, holy crap. For the last minute or 2, the guys slowly begin to de-escalate from the volcanic-eruption peak they just tackled. The ending of this Gin is like the slow relaxing exhale after a long day at work when you get home, kick off your shoes, and just go "AAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!" :) FRIGGIN A+ WORLD-DESTROYING GIN!!!! Doesn't go super out-there, but it DEMOLISHES everything in it's path. Best performance of the show so far!!!

Piper - And it's 1998, so of course we have to go from the quiet outro into a Piper because what else? :p Not complaining! Love me a good slow-build Piper (the best kind!). This one rises quietly from the ashes of that titanic Gin. Like a monster waking up slowly, cracking one eye open at a time, stretching out and relaxing before getting up to kill. Golly, the acceleration and gradual intensity increase on this Piper is SO perfect. The first vocals don't even occur until 3:45!!! As with most Pipers of this vintage, it proceeds to do exactly as you expect it to and overall isn't super special, it's just done SO perfectly well!! Great little "sleeper" Piper! Love the "come down" for the last 30 seconds before launching into....

Axilla - Is Axilla. Is good. Isn't even super hot, really. Just ok!

Roses are Free - For some reason I had low expectations but was rewarded with an excellent version!!! Definitely list-worthy, imo. Just a terrific straightforward reading.

Farmhouse - Works surprisingly good coming out of the chill down of Roses. A nice slow "decline" in intensity over several songs instead of going from a rager straight into this. A great "little" version. Love the effects on Trey's soloing (Leslie?). Really great!!!

Gettin' Jiggy With It - WITH A VACUUM CLEANER BEATBOX! Absolutely terrible in the best way, the way that only Phish can do. Almost as terrible as Trey's Las Vegas 2004 dance routine! :D You never you never needed to hear Fishman rap until hearing this. :p Must've been a blast in person though. So much fun, haha.

Harry Hood - Magical! @Harry Hood , any thoughts on this one? :) Just beautiful!!!!!!! On another night I'd write a big thing about this one but it was seriously fantastic. A+

Character Zero - Is CZ. Rages

Cavern - Is Cavern.Well, not really. It's got Carl from the Great Country Horns! :D



Maybe this is just the vibe of fall 1998 that I'm not aware of due to listening to this show "out of context", but a lot of the songs felt like they didn't reach full potential. Not that the performances were poor or "ripcorded". But there was a definite vibe of "there is more in the tank than they are letting out" and I don't know if I'm crazy for thinking that or not. Things like Tube and Roses and that Stash....Great stuff but it was like they just did not care to make a musical statement tonight (even though there were a lot of them! :) ). An odd show in a way! Highly enjoyable and an absolutely FUN listen, as we all know. Just interesting to compare it to other shows is all!!! It was definitely a good show and I can see me giving it a listen again down the line some time!

The Gin, Stash, Roggae and Harry Hood are the definite highlights if you were to press me :)

 

 

Sunday, October 29, 2023

The O.G. Live Phish Series In Review - Vol. 6: 11/27/98 Worcester, MA

 Live Phish Vol. 6

98 11 27 Worcester, MA

Been about a week since I've had time to listen properly again. I've heard this show once or twice, last April for sure I remember. I don't remember much except for the insane Weekapaug.

Excited for this one!!


Set 1 -

Funky B - I love Funky B but at this point I've reached "saturation point", what with it being one of their most-played covers ever (and almost each one sounds the same!). Very nice one tonight though - oddly "chill" vibe. Love how present Mike is in the mix - where is Trey? :p Great as always, if you've heard one Funky B you've heard most of them. A great version but nothing noteworthy. :)

Ya Mar -
Ooh! Great to have a double Mike opener!!! PLAY IT LEOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!! Still a bit too chill for my taste, but a rip roaring good time was had by all! It feels extran lengthier than usual (almost 11 minutes) and the guys make great use of the time. Page takes the bulk of the soloing for the first half and then Trey comes in with beautifully uplifting melodic leads for the back half. Great time around the 6:45 mark where you can clearly hear Mike trying to play along with Trey's soloing!!! Then things approach ambient Type II, , just about, for a solid minute or so near the end. Really terrific Ya Mar!!! Wowzers!

Carini - After the sunshine and daisies opening duo, the best thing we can get is a jump into the darkness! :D Love Trey trying not to laugh during the lyrics. He's totally going "god these lyrics are so stupid" in a good way :D Good version but pretty short and nothing even happens jam-wise. Not bad by any means but you expect SO much more from a Carini and this one just leaves you wanting!!!!

Runaway Jim - An excellent little Jim. Nothing you haven't heard before, but it's great to hear the guys just giving it a little bit extra that's hard to define. The last few minutes feature, in particular, exceptional piano pounding from Page and Fishman annihilating his cymbals. Trey is doing exactly what you expect. Not quite enough for me to highlight this, but this was still a great Jim!

Meat - Nothing special. I like Meat but this one does absolutely nothing for me tonight.

>Reba - Gotta say, the lightspeed segue into Reba is a blessing. The overly chill vibe tonight and nothing special versions of both Carini AND Jim had me kinda starting to, dare I say, lose interest! :( Terrific, A+ reading of the composed part of Reba!!! They friggin' NAILED the tough part for about 99 percent of it!!!! WOW!! Didn't expect that from 1998 :p Love the beginning of the jam - Fishman is doing interesting "drop out"/stop-start patterns to kick it off. Then Trey comes in ever so delicately like a ballerina tip toeing through a room full of set mousetraps! By 9 minutes, the Reba jam is in the typical "Inca Roads" territory we all know and love. Again, Mike is absolutely trying to solo along with Trey and the result is glorious!!! Like getting two solos instead of one!!! And good golly, the band is tight as F, even through a couple of unexpected stop-start moments!!!!! It's like they wrote and practiced this jam or something!!! At 10 minutes there is an incredible 20 second sequence where the guys all sync up on a repeating, stoccato motif, and seamlessly play together like one instrument. Again, as if they had rehearsed this or something!!! Also, Page on the piano is friggin' amazing....so gorgeous!!! Of course by 12:30 Trey and Page are both going bonkers, annihilating worlds. PEAK UPON PEAK UPON PEAK!!!! Take that, Mt. Everest!!!!! A literal 10/10 Reba. This should be at the top of everybody's go-to Reba list. THIS WAS ONE OF THE BEST REBA'S I'VE EVER HEARD. IT WAS PERFECTION FROM START TO FINISH. WE EVEN GET THE WHISTLE TO CLOSE!

Old Home Place - You don't follow up a Reba like that. Just about anything will fail to live up in it's wake! So Old Home Place is a good choice to cleanse the palate with a great bluegrass stomp that isn't either Nellie Kane or Ginseng Sullivan. And the playing is terrific - get it Page!!!!!!!!

Dogs Stole Things - Not my favorite song, but man, since that Reba, it's like the guys finally woke up!!! And by golly do they kill it! Great DST worth a listen!

Vultures - Only the third version of 1998, it's already sliding towards "slight rarity" status. Terrific to hear as always. Includes the "potato to the throat" line followed by stifled giggles from the band. :) Awesome Vultures! As expected, everybody just goes ham on their respective intruments, like one massive, full-band explosion, ala a good Split Open and Melt! FIRE! FIRE! FIRE! FIRE EVERYWHERE!!! KILLER!!!!!!!

When The Circus Comes to Town - Very nice version but every one is the same. Heard one you've heard 'em all. See Funky B. Fine version and nice set placement! :)

Birds of a Feather - It's 1998, it's BOAF, it's freaking FIRE. It's exactly what you expect and it's GLORIOUS! Fantastic set closer!!



All in all, I was kinda disappointed by the set at first. It really felt "off" for a good while. Then Reba hit HARD and it was like the switch was flipped and from there on out the set became damn-near must hear! Basically, pretend the show begins with Reba and go from there.

Seriously, that was hands-down one of the best, most jaw droppingly outstanding Reba's of all time. Holy hell.

 

Well after 10 friggin' days I finally have time for set 2 of 11/27/98 Worcester :)
This will be a subpar review - I'm excited to listen but also slightly forcing myself to "just get it over with finally", so this is being played at home while changing my guitar strings and cleaning my room :p

11/27/98 Worcester, MA

Set 2

Buried Alive - A very STRANGE and atypical Buried Alive to open set two!!! It SCREAMS "1998" Phish! Trey is doing his "porno wah scratching" and the whole thing has a slightly slower, heavier, more MENACING vibe. Like Black Sabbath doing Buried Alive or something!! Lots of Trey doing his weirdo sound effects and string scrapings etc. The whole thing is only 3:37, but it sounds like a perfect "Halloween" version of BA or something! FANTASTIC!!! :D

Wipeout - Wtf?! They don't segue into it, but they start a random-ass Wipeout performance out of nowhere! Killer fun! "Ladies and gentlemen, JON FISHMAN!!!" :D

Chalkdust Torture - Immediately followed by the most perfectly placed CDT ever, right away Mike and Trey waste no time immediately inserting Wipeout quotes GALORE. :D Very funny and the crowd goes nuts! "Can I live while I'm young">Wipeout teases. So perfect. And then around 3:30 Fishman and Mike introduce a great reggae/NICU-style vamp out of nowhere and we launch into an impromptu, glorious, minute of "Mirror In The Bathroom"!!!!! :D :D :D THIS IS WHY I PHISH. THIS IS SO MUCH FUN!!! THIS IS BONKERS AND INCREDIBLE!!!! :D And then of course they launch right back into a ripping CDT guitar explosion section....Serioualy top-tier A+ CDT. One of the best "shorter" versions ever played. 8.5 minutes of glorious, weirdo FUN and insanity!!! Holy mother of crap....

>Dog Log - MOTHER FRIGGIN DOG LOG!!! WHAT?! WHY?! OUT OF NOWHERE?!?!??! Dog Log is just Dog Log, but that's one of the ultimate rarities so I can't NOT highlight it! :) On any other night, they would've gone into My Soul, so props to Trey for choosing DL instead, lol. Great piano from Trey! Sounds like "Sweet Home Chicago" from the Blues Brothers film during the jam section. AND THEN THEY RIP BACK INTO CDT TO CLOSE IT OUT LIKE OUT OF NOWHERE! DUDE!! WHAT?!?!??!? :D

>Sanity - ANOTHER MASSIVE RARITY!!! WHAT?!?!? WHAT IS HAPPENNING?!?!??!
What is the deal with this song? It always comes out of nowhere and crushes. This one sounds like Heavy Metal Pink Floyd or something at times. Killer. "BOOOOMMMM!!!!! POOOOWWWWW!!!!" Hysterical and insane. Holy crap.

>Buffalo Bill - EXTREME RARITY THREEPEAT!!!! WTF?!?!?!

Mike's Song -
Right away, the jam begins with the whale siren looper. Good golly miss molly listen to Mike absolute FUNK IT THE HELL UP! A few minutes in, Trey starts a second looper that gives the jam a very dark and late-night vibe. Organ stabs throughout with Trey just "riffing" with the occasional lead fill. Trey is soloing it up, but he's milking it, slowly building the heat, not just exploding right off the bat. The band follows suit and we get 10 glorious minutes of some of the best full-band jamming this side of *insert favorite versions here*. Of course the last few minutes explode into the kind of 12/6/97 fiery ridiculousness we know and love. It's a great payoff after some great building. Absolutely 10/10 outstanding Mike's Song :D

>I Am Hydrogen - Is Hydro. Is great. Lengthy version!!!! Terrific ambient segue out of MS into Hydro. You think it's gonna launch into Simple but instead they ride it out and slowly "dissolve" into Hydro. It's glorious.

>Weekapaug Groove - And of course we complete the holy tryptech with the greatest Weekapaug Groove of all time. GET IT LEO!!!! Holy hell, Page is going Bonkers Banana Sandwich on this sucker!!! After a terrific Type I jam of the Gods, we get another damn Wipeout tease/jam before returning to Paug proper. But then, right at 12 minutes, everything dies down!!! Somehow we go from Volcanin Eruption to smoldering ashes of Fukuoka 2000!!!! Wailing feedback looper in the background, spacey synths starting to sneak in, Trey doing his "backwards guitar" effects, Gordo shredding it up near the top of the neck, Fishman constantly changing up the beat, adding different percussion elements.....WELCOME TO TYPE II, MOTHER EFFERS!!! :D How the HELL did we get here?!?!?! Great moment at 14:30 where Trey and Page sync up, both doing some "whirly" playing in step with one another. Gordo is still exploring the upper reaches of his Modulus and Fishman is going tribal on us. At 15:17 the squiggles appear! By 16 minutes things have gotten DARK. Trey is noodling more than Jerry Garcia in a Ramen shop!!!!! SQUIGGLES!! SQUIGGLES EVERYWHERE!!!! Throughout all this, Page is carefully placing choice notes on the keys and piano, with Mike seemingly playing along with him. Then at 17 minutes Trey begins the BACKWARD SQUIGGLES!!! What in the holy hell is even happenning anymore?!?!? At 18 minutes Fishman reintroduces a more standard kind of drum patter and slowly begins leading us back to "proper" music. :) Page is plonking darkly on the piano Mike is laying it down thick, dropping heavy bombs. Trey is still in friggin' outer space La La Land. At 19 minutes, Page hits upon a major key chord/note that signals the "Weekapaug" sound to return. Fishman latches on and, while we don't get Paug, he definitely knows the direction we are heading for. By 20 minutes, things become extremely "sparse" and the jam dies a death with no return to Paug. THAT WAS MORE BALL-BUSTING THAN THE CLIFFORD BALL HARPUA!!!!!! Still, absolutely incredible MUST HEAR piece of music!! Definitely one of the coolest things I've ever heard and VERY unique sounding!!!!

[​IMG]

>
Run Like an Antelope - The lack of climax is forgivable as they choose a great song to lead us out of the darkness with!!! The major key country noodling of the intro jamming is like a breath of fresh air after the claustrophobic cluster-F of that Paug. That's not a knock on Paug but a complement to both! :) The "launch" occurs much sooner than I feel like many versions do. The ensuing jam before the song proper is very jazzy!!! I mean, you wouldn't really call it jazz but it has a swing to it! Funky and danceable in all the right ways. Very "chicka-chicka" on the guitar front like Steve Lukather has joined Phish for a few minutes. The guys jam it great for a good long while, slowly building. The first standout solo is from Page on piano right around 6 minutes in. But by 7 minutes we reach glorious "status quo" and build to a raging hot, volcanic eruption Antelope peak as expected. And it's friggin' glorious!!! AND THE SONG HASN'T EVEN REALLY STARTED YET!!!!! The volcano erupts until about 12:30 when things "die down" slightly into a funky/jazzy jam leading to "Rye Rye Rocco" etc. Surprisingly the song doesn't last much longer and comes to a conclusion around 15:30. Either way, what was here was out-frickin' standing. A+

Wading In the Velvet Sea - Bring the hate, people. Ha ha, you can't! This one is fantastic and gorgeous and exactly how a great Velvet sea should be!! A+!!!!

Golgi Apparatus - I often think the Junta songs sound "out of place" in 97-98 among all the funky material, but this Golgi fits perfect right here tonight!!!! After the emotional blunt force trauma of that impeccably impressive Velvet Sea, this is the "Suzy"-style party we all needed! :) Great version free of flubs and loaded with energy.

Wipout Reprise - OF COURSE! :D


All in all, set one had it's moments with Reba being the CLEAR winner by a mile, but ALL of set 2 is MANDATORY listening of the highest order!!! One of the absolutely best sets ever played, held together as if connected by some unbreakable thread. X Factor Magic from start to finish. A great gig but an INCREDIBLE set. Truly one of the best sets of all of 1.0!!!! Holy moly.....