2/23-24/68 - Lake Tahoe, CA - DP#22 **
Epic 20-minute Viola Lee shredfest!!! Fucking MONSTER Little Schoolgirl. The most PERFECT China Cat Sunflower ever. Seriously, this is as good as '68 gets!
A friendly place to find some sick tunes :) Notes direct from my original Hoffman Forums posts!
Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...
2/23-24/68 - Lake Tahoe, CA - DP#22 **
Epic 20-minute Viola Lee shredfest!!! Fucking MONSTER Little Schoolgirl. The most PERFECT China Cat Sunflower ever. Seriously, this is as good as '68 gets!
Onward with 2011
Night 2 in Tahoe
Set 1 has a pretty terrible setlist FOR MY TASTE 
The bustout-nobody-cared-about of Dogs Stole Things opens the show.
Probably one of my least favorite Phish tunes, I can never remember anything about it even after listening. 
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - love this song but hate this set
placement. A bluesy opener followed by another slow song? No thanks.
It's ok though as this one is hot and good.
Poor Heart - now we're talking! BASS SOLO. Page SHREDS those keys!
Awesome version. Dare I say it felt jammed out - if that's even
possible! 
Alaska - DESTROYER OF WORLDS. I like this song a lot but it's
just another bluesy little ditty. Kinda the sister of Ocelot, if you
will. Amazing version, Trey melts faces. GET THIS.
Halley's Comet - fun and good as always. I will never complain of
getting this on a setlist, but there is literally nothing special about
this version. Good fun as always.
It's Ice - Now we're talking! After listening to that horrendously butchered 1996 Amsterdam version courtesy @ThirdBowl , this one makes up for it. An excellent reading of a song I ALWAYS love to hear. Great stuff.
Now, It may sound like I'm being overly negative with this set so far,
but it's all been highly enjoyable and excellently played - just not the
songs I personally enjoy seeing all together in freakin' set 
More to come....
-----------------------------------
From my Highlights List
Funnily enough, Harry Hood was the only song in set 2 that seemed sub
par! Not a great version imo. So therefore it is not on the list 
No ** rating tonight. The first set was way too inconsistent for that.
BUT, that Stash and the entire 2nd set were among the best stuff of the
summer. Absolutely grab those. 
8/10 Stateline, NV (Get Stash, then PROCEED DIRECTLY TO SET 2, HOLY FREAKING CRAP!!!!!!! JAM BONANZA!)
DOGS STOLE THINGS
Poor Heart
Alaska (HOLY FREAKING CRAP!)
It's Ice
>When The Circus Comes (unexpected segue!)
Ya Mar (PLAY IT LEO!)
Stash (Extremely odd DARK jam!!!!!! HIGHLIGHT OF SET)
Funky B (EXTREME! BEYOND AVERAGE HEAT!)
Instant Karma
Down With Disease (Goes Type II but quickly segues...)
>Runaway Jim (PLINKO. FREAKING AWESOME. Type II)
>Ghost (ROCKS TO HIGH HEAVEN! GOES FULL TYPE II. WHALE CALL!)
>Golden Age (WOW!)
>2001
>Sneakin Sally
Guyuute
Velvet Sea
You Enjoy Myself
Onward with 8/9/11, Stateline, NV (Lake Tahoe)
Awesome setlist tonight. Currently headbanging to Punch You in the Eye.
This is THE song that made me a fan (12/31/95!!!) I would definitely put
it as my favorite Phish song, no questions asked. End of story. Good
versions in 3.0 are extremely hit or miss. This one is total HIT. I am
very happy 
Everything has been played excellent so far.
Some shows have that raging-hopped up-too many energy drinks vibe such as 8/8 and 8/6
This has that smoother, excellent kind of vibe, if that makes sense.
To me, there are clearly different "vibes" that shows give, lol. This
feels like less of a full-on rage-til-you-die show and more of a
take-your-time-and-enjoy-it-all affair 
Party Time was a perfect opener - is it ever not?
Oh Kee Pah - unexpected and perfectly performed
AC/DC Bag - nothing special but a strong, album-ready version
>Mellow Mood - awesome digital delay segue into MM. A terrific version and I'm not one for reggae, so....
Rift - KA BLAM!!!!! CHECK OUT THIS FIRE!!!!!! HOLY HELL!!!!!!!!
Rift definitely kicked things up a notch and the fire and precision it brought has carried over to this Punch.
Not to be hyperbolic but this is surely one of the best Punch's of 3.0
SO FAR. I have extremely high standards for this song (again, 12/31/95
was my intro!) so I'm constantly putting down any version I hear. Not
this one. Terrific.
Set 2
Holy hell can I forgive them for that first set (mindblowing DARK Stash excepted!) because they are going nuts in set 2
Lots of Type II (unfortunately only several minutes at a time), but what they do jam is great and they are blazing it up.
You'll see when I post my notes
----------------------------------------
8/9 Stateline, NV ** (GET THAT LIGHT! ROCKET MAN!)
Party Time
Oh Kee Pah
AC/DC Bag
>Mellow Mood (VERY nice!)
Rift (Holy hell)
Punch You in the Eye (PERFECTION!!!!!!)
>Meat (Dank...)
David Bowie
46 Days
Gotta Jibboo (FREAKING ROCKS)
>Light (TYPE II OUTER SPACE DARK SLUDGE FUNK. AS GOOD AS GORGE ROCK AND ROLL. OMFG)
>Chalkdust Torture (Unqie Type I, HARRY POTTER!)
>Slave to the Traffic Light
>Free
ROCKET MAN!
Walls of the Cave (Harry Hood didn't do much)
Bug (HOLY CRAP TREY!)
The Squirming Coil
Interesting setlist - not to my taste but these are usually the gigs that surprise me 
So far:
Set 1
Moma Dance - horrendous as an opener!!!! Oh my gosh talk about a
non-opening, haha. It's a pretty good version though and gets very chill
for the jam.
Kill Devil Falls - Now we are talking! Jeez, if only they had switched these 2 in set order.... 
Man, on paper this set looks chill as hell!
Moma was a chill opener and then KDF started pretty chill as well.
I thought "better get used to this mood for tonight then I guess!"
KDF was SICK!!! It got going into some really, really nice chill jamming
before Trey eventually took the lead and led us into NASTY shredfest
jamming to bring it to close.
Awesome version. And into Roggae we go.
Extremely chill first set, but still highly enjoyable. Just don't play this set if you want to RAWK, lol.
But if you are cool with hanging out and some lovely more relaxed-pace Phish, this is the set for you 
Everything was pretty darn good. The usual suspects are all worth checkign out, not too much to go banana sandwich about.
Just a very nice laid-back set!
------------------------------------------------
Just now finishing up 11/3/18 Las Vegas #4
Holy hell was this one of the hottest runs of all time or WHAT?!
2 of the 4 shows I'd easily place in the tops of the year and the other 2
gigs have more than enough world-destroying highlights to have them not
far behind.
But back to 11/3/18 for a minute.
I mentioned earlier set 1 - it was excessively chill, but that doesn't
mean bad! It just had a super easy going vibe for some reason. Some good
jams in Tube, Kill Devil Falls, Moma Dance and Roggae though! Also, the
Mike's>Lifeboy>Paug was worth checking out as well.
A very strong B+ first set for me. 
Set two though has been a volcanic eruption of titanic proportions!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Easily as good as the other 3 second sets of the run (or set 3 of 10/31...)
We open with a dark monster Carini that tears us to pieces. It segues
perfectly but nastily into a DESTROYER of a 46 Days!! 46 Days segues
into SASS which is 15 minutes of wonderfully multi-segmented Type II
exploration.
Light, shade, bliss, darkness...its got it all!!!
And then BAM into Crosseyed. Crosseyed destroys for 11 more minutes like
you would expect it to. Type I explosion into a short-but-raging 2001.
2001 into a ripping Possum (is Possum ever NOT hot?!) into a 21 minute Split Open and Melt extravaganza.
Velvet Sea and Character Zero take us out.
Damn, I enjoyed these shows more than I had any right to. And I played them under less than ideal mood/listening conditions!
Peace and love. Y'all weren't kidding that 2018 was a scorcher of a year! ONLY 4 MORE SHOWS TO GO!
Cavern to open - It could just be me, but without checking stats this feels like a rarity in 3.0. Weird! It's so overplayed in early 90s shows that I thought I was sick of the song but this was a very nice version (probably being opener didn't hurt either).
If I Could
WOW!
I love this song to bits and don't understand why it can't be played as
often as Dirt or Waste, etc. What a damn great track and this version is
terrific.
Just beautiful!!!
Weigh
If It's Ice is my favorite song on Rift, this is probably number 2 for me.
A rarity for sure and welcome as hell to hear. Its such a unique and fun
song! Trey stumbles through the intro but comes out alive and we get a
kinda rough and ready version that's more fun than anything 
And now into Sand...
Not the greatest Sand ever, but some incredible peak hosing (right term?
) going on in the back half. Trey just going bananas on everyone!
Sick.



Everything's Right - I love the song but not my preferred opener. I
can't complaint though as this gets very funky and Steam-esque. Nice
jamming, great opener!
AC/DC Bag - Wonderful version! Just a super tight, correct tempo, rocking version. Always great to hear!!!
Wolfman's Brother - I love this song. It's just so simple and FUN. And
this version is just terrific if you're dig WB. Total fun. If I was in
the crowd I'd be dancing my tail off, lets put it like that. Not an
all-timer but ultra fun and worth hearing 
EDIT: Spoke too soon. WOLFMAN'S IS FRIGGIN BLAZIN' HOLY HELL!!!!!! LET IT RIP GUYS!!!!!!!!!
Absolutely terrific first set, imo. FOUR jams over the 12 minute mark, good song selection, tons of energy, nice pacing.
Picking up from above...
Nellie Kane - is Nellie Kane
Funky B - is Funky B. Slayed as usual
Chalkdust Torture - A BEAST!!!!!!!!!!! 16 minutes. Type II, multi-sectional jamming of the highest order. Must-hear!
I Been Around - Fun to hear, very rare (in Charleston '19 I got only the 7th ever played!)
Joy - Well placed in the set, imo. Very good version, comparable to the gorgeous Farmhouse on 10/24/18!!!
Walls Of The Cave - You know what to expect. Still, it destroyed universes and left me in a melted puddle on the floor. DAYNG SUN!
The greatness continues in set 2!
Blaze On - still think the song is dumb, but the jam here is great. It
does that whole 2018 "minimalist" thing where they don't adventure too
much but do just enough to call it Type II and make it worth hearing
A real dance party this one is!!!
No Men In No Man's Land - See Walls Of The Cave^^^^
Fuego - It's Fuego and you know what you gonna get. Still, for the last
few minutes we enter Type II dark space. They easily could've jammed it
to oblivion from there but instead we go into Twist
Twist - I'm not the biggest Twist fan (I think the song itself is pretty
boring) but one can't deny it as a jam vehicle. Great stuff in this
one! They waste no time at all getting down to business. Around 5
minutes in they go from jazzy Type I into totally-abandoning-the-theme
Type II. It actually gets kinda Beatle-y sounding for a bit in the jam.
Kinda upbeat-melancholy. Like a Piper intro or something. Very cool.
This eventually gets a little darker and Trey starts slowly building up
his guitar prowess. We get some good 2000-esque semi ambiance. Piano
replaced by keys, funky bass, Trey doing guitar loops etc. Go check this
out ITS AWESOME!
Wow, Twist was definitely the jam of the night so far, imo.
Twist>Prince Caspian>Twist reprisal
Prince Caspian was barely a proper rendition of it, imo. They kinda just
launched into the choruses and immediately jumped back into the jam
It was such a brief departure I choose to view it as part of Twist, lolol
Then a nice Bouncing Around the Room to catch our breath.
Now Harry Hood.
Harry (We Have Come To Outlive Our Brains) Hood. Man oh man that woulda been sick if they took the plunge and went into
the song. They straight up jammed it for almost 2 minutes.
Contact - One of my least favorite songs. And even THIS is terrific tonight! Check out the KICK ASS piano raging from Leo!
Rise/Come Together - Not my favorite song, but this is so stupendously placed tonight I can't fault it at all. Come on, for real, go listen to this. It's the PERFECT closer for this show. I just wish it was longer.
This show was outstanding! I think I might even prefer it to 10/31!!!!!!
I love, love, love the KV material have been wanting to hear this show forever. So glad to finally be playing it 
So far:
Set 1
Buried Alive - A nice rarity to kick things off, but it's just "not good enough" to not make my highlights list for the show
Ghost - A wonderful "mini" Ghost with some great jamming despite its length. It's like 20 min condensed into 10!
>Crazy Sometimes - didn't see this coming, especially not segued out
of Ghost. But it was AWESOME! TYPE 2 DANCE PARTY WOO HOO!!!!!
Free - Trey destroys. Very nice.
More - More is More. Nothing to say. Great version but not "highlights list" worthy
Halley's Comet - Took a long time to get going. Finally the jam kicked
in for a few minutes. I thought we would go sky high but instead Trey
ripcorded us into Ocelot.
I love Ocelot but C'MON, TREY! 



That really SUCKED, lol.
Oh well, at least Ocelot is excellent with some genuinely great semi-ambiant jamming!!!!! Worth hearing!
Ocelot - A truly magnificent version. More than makes up for the ripcorded Halley's Comet!!!!!
Theme From the Bottom - GRANDIOSE AND SPECTACULAR. ROCKS LIKE ITS 1995!
First Tube - EVEN MORE GRANDIOSE AND SPECTACULAR. EXPLODES LIKE ITS 1994!

All in all this was an EXCEPTIONAL first set, imo. Not a weak link in the chain. Holy hell that was SICK!
On to Faceplant Into Rock!
-------------------------------------------------------
Home from my family's place in Summerville, SC (near Charleston).
It's good to be back in my own bed in Greenville 
So last night I got through set 1 and 2 of 10/31/18
Set 1 destroyed. I love KV so Set 2 was sure-fire winner as well.
So far in set 3:
Set Your Soul Free - I love this song and it always rocks. This one
stayed pretty "in the box" and wasn't anything special, but still
another good rocking version.
Tweezer - 16 minutes. Tons of different land covered with this. Dark, light, fast, slow, spacy... absolutely worth hearing!!!!
A Song I Heard the Ocean Song - just beginning now but the segue into it was great
-------------------------------------------------------
My live posting that night ended there. Here's my final highlights list though!
10/31/18 - Kasvot Vaxt********************************** (One of THE great shows of 3.0!)
Ghost (Great mini jammign with a Buried Alive reprise!)
>Crazy Sometimes (Type II Dance party!)
Free (Trey absolutely DESTROYS!)
Halley's Comet (Gets good jam going then ripcorded into Ocelot :( )
Ocelot (Dark and jazzy semi ambiant Type 1.5 jamming!!!! EXCEPTIONAL)
Theme From the Bottom (Grandiose and rocking. ABSOLUTELY TERRIFIC!!!)
First Tube
Set 2 - Kasvot Vaxt - ALL
Tweezer (Dark space to uplifiting bliss. Very varied!)
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing (Great dark jamming!)
Backwards Down the Number Line
Loving Cup
Gotta say the first set on paper looks horrible as far as song selection goes.
AC/DC Bag was too drudgy as an opener - I like the song but it's always
hit and miss for me. If its uptempo and banging, then all right! But too
often it feels like it is dragging or something. This is one of those
versions. It was still pretty good though - I'd give it a B+
Martian Monster and Ass Handed are both SKIPs for me.
On to Everything's Right - I really enjoy this tune. This version is
exceptionally chill and laid back. The jamming doesn't really go that
far out, but we do get some nice jazzy playing for a few minutes. Pretty
solid stuff!
So, as usual, it appears I spoke too soon.
Everything's Right ended up being a heavy banger towards the end and 555 KILLED. I was straight up headbanging along 
Also, I didn't realize until I checked .NET that the first set includes Theme and Gin, so points get added for those.
I hear great thing about the upcoming Ocelot as well....
This isn't Ocelot. No, this frickin' CAN'T be.
WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?! THIS IS FREAKING AWESOME!!!
Let me put it like this, if you played this jam for someone, they would
never, ever, in a million years realize that it stemmed from a mere
Ocelot.
WOW!
Oh yea, Wedge was pretty rockin' too
Ok, so Theme and Gin to end set 1. Theme seemed very good and quite
powerful. Gin was 13 minutes of "just ok". Just a "generic, good Gin".
Limb By Limb into 2001 was again fun but unspectacular. Just good stuff.
YEM was great though and the rocking Suzy sent us happily on our way.
This show was about as good as night 1. A solid B+ gig that just screamed "warm up" for the most part (aside from that incredible Ocelot!!!)
Ok, so a ripping 9 minute Free to open things up with a bang. Why is this almost never an opener?! It's perfect for it! 
Up next we have - on paper - insanity.
A 12 minute Possum, then a 14 minute Moma and a 16 minute Ghost.
A short 7 minute Funky B to breathe and then back into it all with a 12 minute Stash.
Huh.
How 'bout that.
Possum was pretty interesting sounding. I can't recall hearing one quite
like it, although I've not heard a single full show from 2011 through
2019 outside of 1 or 2, so I'm sure it's just me.
Moma and Ghost are both funky, but both are very, very chill tonight.
Ghost reminds me of the Alpine '97 version or something. Just super
relaxed.
Very nice though.
Still got 8 minutes left in Ghost though so we'll see where it goes from here!
Ok, maybe it's just me zoning out or something, but the Moma>Ghost didn't live up to expectations unfortunately.
As I just mentioned they were both very nice, but Ghost just kept
drifting and never really went anywhere. It literally just kind of
petered out.
It was a lovely 16 minute lazy river ride, let's put it like that. Darn, lol. 
Now we are in a rocking Funky B, but that chill vibe is continuing so
maybe just a nice relaxed air is the feeling for this show. Cuz this is
the first time I can say I've heard a relaxed Funky B!
Stash seems pretty good for a bit, but when it comes time for "takeoff",
it's like the guys can't figure out how to pull back on the throttle
and lift the landing gear.
Hmm.
Am I expecting too much or is this just a not a hot show so far?
Character Zero
At this point in my short fandom, I'm pretty sick of this song. A good
version is a good version and you guys know I love anything that rocks,
so I gotta give props to this one for dragging this dying horse of a set
across the finish line with a bang and a snarl. Good stuff!
The set 2 opening NMINML already sounds way more alive than all of set 1. That's a good sign
NMINML
This is miles better than anything in the first set. It's actually deserving of its 17 minute length.
I'm not gonna say it's the greatest thing of all time, but there is
loads of energy, Mike and Fish are both tearing it up, and Trey has
busted out the wah for some neck wrangling, so, at least they are trying

WOW THAT WAS KILLER! 
Thankfully this continues straight into a nasty Carini. Tons of wah all over this beast. Very dark!
SICK
Carini segued masterfully into Slave. Totally didn't see that coming if I didn't have the setlist in front of me. Great version too! Slave is not a song I look forward too usually, but this one was very enjoyable.
After that lovely Slave, we got a very nice BATR as a breather.
Like CZero, BATR is another song I enjoy but am glad when it's over.
After BATR we segue into a freaking ROCKING Soul Planet!!!
I don't give a crap how cringey everyone thinks the lyrics are - who cares when the song rocks so much?!
All I can do is sit and headbang and tap my feet. Wish I was in the crowd going nuts when they played this.
Yea, it's a an easy, simple song, but for only it's second performance this was dang tight. This was KILLER!!!!!!
This Soul Planet was sick - goin' all Type II darkness into Steam now....
After a hot Steam and slightly extended Hood, Contact and Julius send us on their way.
Overall a good show but not a classic or worthy of my "****" ratings :P
Fine start to the summer but definitely had a relaxed vibe to it that I wish was a little hotter.