An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Showing posts with label Wisconsin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wisconsin. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 16, 2021

2019-07-14 East Troy, WI - "The Big One"

7/14/19 Alpine #3 - "The Big One" :p

Preface - you guys know I'm gonna go bonkers on this and probably label it the greatest show ever played or something, so just bear with me and get your "Idiot Review" goggles on, ok? :)

Set 1

The Landlady - Starting totally unexpectedly with the first Landlady since 2016 and only the 5th one ever in 3.0 Trey has a hard time on this one, fumbling through it, but his soloing is on key and we get major Rarity Points for this, so I'll allow it. Funny banter afterwards about the failed dance routine. :)
 


 Olivia's Pool - Another shock bustout, this one for the first time since NOVEMBER 1997!!!!!! Jeez!!! And it ROCKS too so why the heck did they wait so long to bust this out!! Keep this in rotation guys - ITS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!! Leo shreds it up on the keys and then Trey Takes over to melt our faces. God I love this band. You NEVER know what you are gonna get!!!! This is seriously terrific - yea its a simple song, hardy har har, but it sounds like theyve been playing it all summer. NAILED!!


The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday Suite - First performance of the trio since 2015. FOURTH ever performance in 3.0! Jeez, just rackin' up them Rarity Points big time!! Very cool and funky. Great effects from Cactus on this one. Pretty tight versions considering the rarity. Sounded great!!!

Meatstick - Is Meatstick. Is great fun. :) Great hearing it early in a set instead of as a late-show "pumper upper". Kinda deflates the specialty of it in a good way.

Vultures - Great version. Gets slightly dark and demented in the jam/solo portion. Trey going all Zappa with his soloing on this one!! Big meltdown on this sucker before they yank up to the sky! Extremely wacky! Must-hear Vultures! Dissonant and screwed up in the best way!!!!!! INCREDIBLE!!!!

Spock's Brain - Just as with Olivia's Pool, WHO THE EFF SAW THIS ONE COMING?! NOBODY! THATS WHO!!! First one since the Mexico run of 2019, but other than that, its only the 10th version ever played. Another A+ for rarity. :p

Pebbles and Marbles - One of my all time favorites that is also a mega rarity. I love Walls Of The Cave but wish they would swap it with P/M sometimes. :) Great version overall.

Glide - Oh no get your blinders on, will this be good or bad :p Yea they butcher it. But rarity points again save the day. I can't put this on the list. Just not good enough. Great to hear though!!!

About to Run - Damn Trey, GET IT BOY!!! Good golly.... 


Strange Design - First since 2016, I believe?? Love this song and still can't believe it didn't make it onto Billy Breathes. Wonderfully beautiful version that was perfect coming out of that ripping About to Run. A+ set placement, yo.

>Timber - Unexpected segue that worked great. Absolutely terrific version. X Factor energy in this one. It's just that good.

I Didn't Know - Nailed those vocals. Vacuum solo. Perfect set closer. :)

Good Times Bad Times - Classic ripper to close the set!

Ok, this was an awesome set. It's not the set you would want at every show and felt a little long in the tooth at times - trying to sequence that many rarities is bound to be a challenge! But when the songs played are that rare and the playing is generally that good, it all works out. Very strong set, but perhaps more "memorable" than "listenable" at times??

Great stuff! Set 2 to come tonight:) 

 

-------------------------------------------------------

Set 2 -

Oh boy here we go.


Mercury - Not the tightest version of the song I've heard. The jam is ok but nothing special. A fine rendition but overall probably only about as good as the one I got later in Charleston. BUT, that segue into Ruby Waves...

Ruby Waves - Just going ahead and posting my original thoughts from 2 days after it happenned. Here we go:

7/14/19

Ruby Waves

Ok, pretty quickly we got dark and nasty until about 8 minutes. Then we went a lot lighter, more of a classic rock vibe for a bit.

Around 12 minutes we hit an awesome, bluesy, "1968 rock" kind of vibe that kicks all kinds of tail.

Around 15 minutes this subsides and some 2000-esque ambience begins to creep in. The boys are in total control of their dynamics and fade things down quite a bit.
Lots of organ sounds and "bliss".
Eventually it slowly gains steam again and the jam reaches a point where it screams Light (imo, anyways).

Then at 20 minutes exactly - OUT OF FRIGGIN NOWHERE - we are into funky reggae land.
The changeover happenned in like 5 seconds flat. What. There was almost no transition. It's like they flipped a lightswitch or something.
Kinda jarring but pretty dang sick that they just changed on a dime like that. And Trey is making love to his volume pedal, so there's that :)

Quickly though, around 21:30, some dark and nasty Carini-type riffing comes into play. It's Octave-Fuzz pedal time!!!
Yea, now it sounds like a Carini jam.
By 23:00 we have reached the dark side of the moon. The crowd roars their massive - and totally justified - approval.

THIS JAMMING IS THE T!T$!!!!

By 24 minutes the Carini riffing mutates into a more mellow and spacey sound while still remaining very funky and dark. This is Moon-Rock. :)

24:44 - The Feedback Squalls Of Hell!

We are in dark-ambience mode now. Trey is letting it absolutely FREAKING RIP!
Fishman and Gordo are keeping that dang funky beat going like it's Fall '97 or something. This is magical. Pure magic.

Then at 27:00 on the dot, the jamming screeches to another transition point.
The beat stops and we enter full on into 2000 Ambience Turbo Deluxe mode. Trey and Page leaking noise - both archaic and and beautiful - into our ears like the sounds of a thousand dying angels crying.

Or something like that. Woah.

This is HEAVY.

But then just as we've ascended beyond the astral plane of the 96th dimension, we are grounded by a new jazzy groove.
The boys are just urinating magic at this point but it's like they can't decide what style they want to jam in - we are getting The Grand Smorgasbord

So by this point we are 32 minutes in and Ruby Waves is far gone. It's in the trash by now. We are in charted, yet rarely traveled territory.

By this point (roughly 34 minutes in) the guys have kept the latest groove going and are just letting Trey (and later Page) rip it all kinds of up. Someone needs to call the cops on Trey because this is felony-level instrument abuse right here.

Good lord.

And basically, they just keep ripping it up all the way to the finish line.

I'm too inexperienced to say if this was the greatest jam of all time, but I'm sure it was easily in the top 5 or 10 of 3.0 and probably in the top 30 of all of Phish.
By 2019 I'd call that an accomplishment. 


 We now resume your regularly scheduled program....

Twist - That's it, the show's over, right? :p Truly wonderful Twist though!!! Short and sweet - any other show would kill for one this well played. Smooth in the extreme, Trey just pours golden nectar in our auditory canals for 6 minutes. Thoughtful heat, excellent phrasing and playing...Takanaka would be proud!! :)

>Swept Away/Steep - Oh my sweet goodness, I'm not crying, are you crying? Holy hell talk about tugging at the heartstrings. Absolutely gorgeous and beautiful and perfect in every way. Jeezus Krist.....

>Death Don't Hurt Very Long - From the quiet beauty of the SA/Steep to the absolute fury and hellstorm that is this HEAVY DDHVL!!!! Funky wah pedal and clavinet abuse!!!! Guitar murder!! INSANELY AWESOME!!!! THIS IS A FREAKING MELTDOWN OF EPIC PROPORTIONS!!!!!!!
 


>ICCULUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - The ultimate rarity, maybe rarer than Harpua? Gosh dang, son!!! READ THE BOOK! 
 

 
Buffalo Bill - Is Buffalo Bill, but mega rarity points and it was performed excellently. :D Icculus reprise, lol. Just read the book, ok??

You Enjoy Myself/Catapult/Marriage proposal banter - This is very fun. YEM itself is rusty from Trey, but the energy is there and the fun the guys are having is palpable. They seamlessly bust into a flawless Catapult, and then Trey tells how he met a couple in the lobby who said they would get married if they did Contact. Very cool.

>Contact - Oh yes Leo, fill me with the sonic glory that is your piano playing. BEAUTIFUL STUFF!!!

>YEM Conclusion - The sandwich finishes pretty awesomely with the guys jumping right back into the funk groove of YEM and then finishing with the vocal jam. A+!!

>More - Is More. Nothing special, but obligatory.

>Tweeprise - Spectacular. Capping off not just one of the greatest shows Phish ever played but a terrific summer tour as well. Listen to Cactus dropping bombs that Phil would be proud of!! Incredible peak and raging. Just what the doctor ordered and the absolute perfect choice for closer.
 
-------------------------------------------
 
Ok guys, I'm really sorry for all that. :p

In conclusion, Alpine #3 was, well, incredible and the 4.6 rating on .NET isn't high enough!!! What can be said that hasn't already been said? This show is the definition of MUST-HEAR.

It felt very special and not like any other "Joe Regular Summer Show". Felt like a special Festival gig or something.

Spectacular.
 

2019-07-13 East Troy, WI

7/13/19 Alpine #2

Great setlist tonight.

AC/DC Bag - Feel like it's been a while since the last one. Very welcome opener :) Nice and hot but nothing special. Just a good opener!

>NICU - Fun but nothing special

Shade - Very nice but nothing special

Funky B - Hot as always. Great solo from Page. Great vocal wailing from Cactus! Absolute guitar murder from Trey.

Blaze On - The song portion is excellent. Simple song, yes, but this one seemed to have extra oomph to it. Really great reading of the song itself. Very cool "watery" Type II excursion. Great stuff!!

Ya Mar - Great playing from Trey.

Frost - Rare and beautiful. Just achingly gorgeous and tender.

The Sloth - Brings some rocking energy back to this slightly light-weight leaning set. Good version overall.

F Your Face - Totally unexpected and also unexpectedly awesome!! Trey really rips it up big time just melting faces. And Cactus' vocals are on point. This is close to flawless. Fantastic!!!

My Friend My Friend - Red hot and scorching as expected, but nothing special.

The Final Hurrah - Strong version with loads of vocals from everyone. Dance party, yo!

Character Zero - Is CZ :)


All in all, set 1 was fine. Everything was baseline excellent, but the highs still felt lower than usual. Felt like an excessively "average" set, just in that we've heard so much better. Great song selection and energy throughout!

------------------------------------------------

Set 2

Halley's Comet - Fun start, but as with AC/DC Bag, nothing special. Always a favorite of mine to hear :)

>A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing
-
This song seems like it would be a monster, but to this day I don't think I've ever heard a version that actually proceeds to do anything special (can you guys point me in the direction of one?). Again, a song I always love to hear on the setlist! This one tries pretty hard and goes for the deep sea vibes real quick. Trey takes the spotlight at first before Page eventually entering the fray with his watery synths. Trey busts out some extended sustains and we head for ambience. It sounds pretty good on paper and any other night this would take off and be incredible, but tonight it sounds disjointed. Not bad at all, just undercooked. What's here is very good and highlights-list worthy, it's just totally does not reach maximum potential. Good but disappointing in the end!

>Runaway Jim -
The guys can tell the previous jam is fizzling out and quickly launch smoothly into Jim to rekindle the energy. Almost immediately (well, 5 min in) the jam dives straight into Type II Space Funk. Things get pretty dark and weird. Fishman keeps the Jim beat going, but Page and Trey are playing with delays and effects and all kinds of weird sounds. This is totally outer space. Very cool and very much worth your time. Trey returns to regular sounds but Page keeps those dark synths going. Fishman is still killin' that Jim beat and this whole thing is leaning to major key bliss now. Only a minute to go, but this sucker was pretty great. Awesome micro-jam indeed!!! :p

>Undermind -
Jim melts away turning into a funky groove, but Trey grabs it by the reigns, ups the tempo and leads us perfectly into Undermind. Now that was a true segue. :) Page absolutely tears it up on the keys. Trey lays back and just lets Leo go to friggin' town. Fantastic. Trey then picks up the torch and just unloads on us. Excellent and bluesy and funky. This is just a Type I Party Beast of the highest order. A+

>Ghost -
Another great segue into a perfect song choice! This Ghost takes its time deciding on a direction, but they end up keeping it chill and mellow for a bit. Things end up in a pretty mysterious-yet-blissful kind of ambient space. Trey sounds unsure of what to play, but the jam sounds great regardless. Directionless, perhaps, but the actual playing is still great. Towards the end it all congeals into a magical miasma of blissful, peaky, 1.0-type beauty. They hit upon the goods and rode it out. AWESOME. You gotta hear it - I can't describe it. :)

>Golden Age
-
As Ghost is fading out, Page starts some rhythmic patterns on the keys which prompts Trey to start the GA theme. Not a perfect segue, but a cool transition, let's say :) . Keeping the microjams going, the guys bust out the funk again and let it rip for a solid 5 or so minutes of Type II goodness. Dance party awesomeness. At one point Fishman stops the beat and just plays with the cymbals. The rest of the band stops and then they all kind of fade back into the jam slowly. Pretty cool. Sounded like they were lost for a split second, but they quickly caught on and launched back in with a darker tone. As with Ghost though, they realise its coming to an end and immediately segue into Back On the Train. Could not have seen that coming!!!

>Back On the Train -
Trey totally butchers the lyrics and the guys save his tail, lol. Pretty funny moment :) Trey recovers with some tasteful and quiet (TOO QUIET!!!) soloing. He drops in a delay here and there at times but decides to just lay it out there kosher. Page picks up on the piano and Trey tries to play with some sustain and ambient textures. The jam eventually builds a BIG head of steam and the guys just absolutely tear the Type I roof off the friggin' place. Awesome -but normal - BOTT.

Harry Hood - The crowd is into it but the band sounds tired and the tempo is sluggish. But again I'm not really a Hood fan so take that for what you will. Nice piano from Page and the whole thing is very nice, but I tend to tune out during Hood so I'll let you guys decide how good it was :)

Say It to Me SANTOS -
Save me from Hood! Yes! Let's GO!! Closes the show in ripping fashion


All in all, set 2 was pretty dang sweet!! The guys had trouble at times deciding where to go - things felt uneven quite a bit. But they always steered the ship quickly back on course with never so much as a hint of any trainwreck. Each song had excellent jamming, even if it all was in the 5-7 minute range. Not my favorite show but not the worst either. If 100 percent is peak Phish, it felt like they were at 90% or something. They weren't tired sounding, but there was an indescribable lack of "x factor" going on. Just a very well played show with a very nice setlist in a very nice order with lots of very nice jamming. Nothing more nothing less. Hard to explain!!

I'd give this show a 3.8 or so. Strong A for effort! 

2019-07-12 East Troy, WI

7/12/19 Alpine Valley #1

Set 1

Great looking set tonight with a very rare Sand opener. Cool beans....

Sand - It starts off pretty tentatively, Trey doing that "playing too quietly" thing. It slowly builds steam and eventually builds to the highest, hottest peak you've ever heard in your life. Talk about a show opener! Jaw firmly planted in the floor....

Tweezer - Who expected this in slot 2? Noone! :p Pretty cool jamming on this that ends up focusing on a feel-good, major-key vibe. This leads us into a darker, funkier area for a bit. All in all this Tweezer isn't anything ultra-special that you haven't heard before, but it is a great little abbreviated slice of jamming that works wonderfully in the 2nd slot tonight.

>Free - They nailed the segue for once in the freaking world! Tweezer was winding down and you could tell they were "looking for a way out", so to speak. Trey stumbled into that opening D chord and then quickly everyone jumped on and they slammed into it. Absolutely terrific segue!!! Trey is rocking the Leslie sound on this one. Very well performed - this is one of those "album-ready" renditions. Just a full-on excellent straight ahead Type I Free.

Turtle In the Clouds - Absolutely on fire. The crowd has been audibly loud the whole set so far and this is no exception. Awesome version with everyone tearing it up on their respective instruments. Lots of extra OOMPH to this one it seems! Really, this one is just BANGIN! FOR REAL THIS IS BANGING!!!!

Set Your Soul Free - Hotter than the sun.
This is maybe in the ballpark of what SYSF might've sounded like on an average night in 1.0. Meaning Trey is shredding it up, Page is smashing those keys, and everyone is just hammering this home like their souls depend on it. Terrific, short, Type I beast. Really, really full of p!ss and vinegar!!!!

Lawn Boy - Is Lawn Boy. You know exactly what you are getting. :)

Camel Walk - Unexpected and totally welcome. Gordo shines big time on this, following up from his great solo in Lawn Boy. Flawless rendition with everyone on their A-game. Trey's licks are tasty and perfectly placed/phrased. Fishman is doing loads of fills and Cactus is tearing it up. Fantastic Camel Walk!!!

Theme From the Bottom - OUTSTANDING!!! You say you've heard the best Theme ever played?! WRONG!! HAVE YOU HEARD THIS SUCKER?!?!??! HOLY CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!!

>Rift - Great segue. Very dynamic version. Trey is again doing his "playing too quietly" thing, but it works in the context of this version. A pretty strong 3.0 rendition all things (re)considered, except that Trey completely drops the ball on this one. Ok, actually, yea not a great Rift, lol

Wolfman's Brother - When in doubt, toss in the Wolfman! :) A solid 5 or so minutes of tasty funk workout in this one, Trey laying heavily into his wah. Pretty dang hot and makes up for that awful Rift, but at the end of the day this is just a solid, red-hot Type I Wolfman. Raging peak but nothing special. See Free^^^


All in all, a pretty strong first set. Discounting Rift, nothing was below "excellent", imo. Everything was AT LEAST excellent on a base level!
BUT, the highlights did stand out. This was a set where everything was terrific, just some stuff was MORE terrific than others, capiche?

:)   

-----------------------------------------------


Set 2

No Men In No Man's Land - Pretty fantastic. It's only 10 minutes but feels like 20. They go hard Type II raging space funk on this one, but then Trey ripcords us into Prince Caspian. Wtf mate! :(

Prince Caspian - I forgive you Trey. This Caspian is spectacular. Seriously, this is an A+ Caspian with inspired playing from all. Fantastic. Goes Spanish Jam type II for a minute!

>Everything's Right - See the last two! This one is even BETTER!!! Hardcore raging deep space groovy funk explosion. MUST HEAR VERSION!!!

Roses Are Free - Good version, but it aint Big Cypress ;)

2001 - See Roses Are Free :)

The Wedge - Absolutely ON FIRE version! This aint no chill GD rendition, Machine Gun Trey is here, babay!! Absolutely red hot and totally worth your time!!

Light>Plasma>Light - Spectacular!!! Light and Plasma both have great self-contained jams and then the segue back into Light is just icing on the cake! Short but sweet!

46 Days - Fantastic

The Squirming Coil - Sounds as good as any other great version, but nothing to distinguish it. :)

A Life Beyond the Dream - Playing wise, it's ever-so-slightly rusty at times, BUT, Trey pours his friggin' heart and soul into this performance. So much emotion and energy. The guitar shredding at the end is terrific. A perfect emotional climax warmed up by Coil!!! :)

Tube - Encore Tube?! What!? Outstanding version that brings it like you expect. Terrific!  

--------------------------------------------

Terrific show overall. Looking at the setlist, I'm sure lots of people were taken by surprise!!
Set 1 was excellent from start to finish, thought there were obvious highlights.
Set 2 was like one continuous album sequence or something. It just flowed and flowed and flowed. The playing was great throughout and several of the jams were must-hear, imo.

I wouldn't put this near Uncasville, but it was maybe in the Top 10 of the summer so far. Killer show!