An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Showing posts with label New Jersey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Jersey. Show all posts

Saturday, November 20, 2021

1972-09-26 through 9/28 Jersey City, NJ - Dick's Picks Vol. 11

 

09/26/72 - Jersey City, New Jersey

An amazingly laid-back and relaxed time throughout. Highlights include the amazing He's Gone, Cold Rain, EPIC PITB, Bird Song, Cumberland Blues, Around and Around, Greatest Story. In particular, He's Gone is and ALL TIME version and PITB is an epic "late night" jazz fest that's smooth and silky but never boring or sloppy. 35-minute Truckin'>TOO jazzapalooza.


09/27/72 - Jersey City, New Jersey - DP# 11

Very strong throughout. Not as mind blowing as it's given credit for, but certainly as great as any excellent 1972 show. Awesome PITB, Morning Dew, Deal, Bird Song, Dark Star.


09/28/72 - Jersey City, New Jersey **

WOW. That is all one can say. After technical issues ruining Truckin' and Loser, the rest of this show is beyond killer. THE VERSION of Greatest Story Ever Told. Brown Eyed Women. The end of set 1.Bertha. This show fucking kills. Way betterthan the excellent, yet overrated, previous night. LISTEN TO THIS SHOW.


Tuesday, November 16, 2021

2019-06-30 Camden, NJ

 Well, it's an awful rainy day and we are done with work (crawled under a house for 2 hours in the mud to fix a water leak...) and I'm nice and warm and cozy, so that means early listening for today (usually, I listen in the evening)

Onwards to 6/30/19 Camden

Night 1 was awesome. Night 2 sucked in some spots and slayed in others. I heard Night 3 is the "best" though, so I'm excited.


Set 1.

The Curtain With -
Unexpected and choice opener! Awesome 3.0 version that is not loaded with flubs. Absolutely gorgeous and the jam section is nailed.

>Fast Enough For You - Wow, out of TCW, that was a perfect song choice. They just slid right into it....Maybe not the song you want as 2nd of the first set, but who cares about set placement with a well-performed rarity!! Great version, Trey is on point. Beautiful playing from all.

>Buried Alive - A+ for song choice and effort, but holy hell they absolutely murdered the song in the worst way, lol. Top-tier screw up :p Pretty good by the end!

Camel Walk - And the classics keep comin'!!! It's CW, it's Type I and funky as well. Very good version worth checking out. Not highlights worthy, but a good one!

Reba - FLAWLESS! :D A rarity, a 3.0 Reba not butchered and with Trey fully audible!!! AWESOME. Really, really terrific Reba for 2019

Sample in a Jar - Freaking powerful and ROCKING to high heavens. Sick.

Pebbles and Marbles - Nothing special, just a strong straight ahead version. Rarity factor!!! Great stuff.

Tela - YES! TELA! I LOVE TELA!!!

MANGO SONG - YES YES YES YES!!
The crowd roars its approval and we get a great version of this ultra-rarity. AWESOME.

Driver - What is this, rarity set bananza?! Very nice version, but Driver is Driver :)

David Bowie - Wow!!! A 3.0 Bowie that doesn't make me cringe!!!! :D Really awesome Bowie with some great jamming well worth your time. Fantastic close to an A+ first set.



What a freaking phenomenal first set that was. Rarities out the wazoo, great playing, great energy. Everything was excellent and this more than made up for the previous night :p

 
------------------------------------
 
Set 2

Mr. Completely - Completely bonkers!!! The song portion is pretty weak but they jump headfirst into the jam in what, 2 minutes or something?? And its into deep space Type II for 15 glorious dark minutes of awesomeness. Heck. Yes.

>TWENTY YEARS LATER!! - 21 minutes of Type II exploration. The guys roll with it and it's a journey. Mandatory listening. Absolutely one of the best jams of the summer.


>BIG BLACK FURRY CREATURE FROM MARS!!!!

>TWEEZER!!!!!!!!!!! -
Seriously. After all that and then they decide to unleash Tweezer. Mind=blown. AND ITS FRIGGIN AWESOME! 13 MINUTES OF TOP NOTCH RAGING! CAN THIS GIG GET ANY FRIGGIN BETTER?! HOLY HEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>Most Events Aren't Planned - FREAKING SICK. SICK SICK SICK SICK SICK!!!!!!!!!!!! Great to have a Page song this far into the show and this is one of his best, imo. I still remember listening to the Alpharetta 2018 version and being blown away! FANTASTIC!!!!!

>Makisupa Policeman - A surprisingly lengthy/jammed out version that is most dank.

Chalkdust Torture - LETS FRIGGIN GO!!!!!!!!!

Suzy Greenberg - There had to be a breather at some point, eh? :) Good hot Suzy but nothing special.


Punch You In the Eye - Sick. Proper tempo!!! Ripping it up from the start! None of that usual 3.0 PYITE awfulness :D As my favorite Phish song (and the one that made me a fan!) I take my Punch's VERY seriously. :p Ok, this one isn't perfect, but for a 2019 rendition, it's DARN GOOD!!!! Not list worthy, mind you, but strong enough to keep me from completely cringing :)

>What's The Use - Wow! Talk about a segue noone saw coming! Man oh man, this is astonishingly beautiful. Very Pink Floyd-esque tonight.

Julius - Is Julius. It rocks. It closes this unbelievable show. Great stuff.
--------------------------------------------
 
6/30/19 Camden #3 in review:

Monster effin' show.

Easily the best of the tour so far (and this tour has had several outright classics already!).

This was one of those "X Factor" shows where the stars align and you just keep saying to yourself "it can't possibly get any better".

And then it does. Over and over again.

Tied with 6/22 and 6/25 as best of tour so far, but this evern surpasses those by a wide margin. Truly exceptional show, no hyperbole.

.NET rated this a 4.5 if I'm not mistaken, and for once I actually totally agree with "them".

Until we get to Alpine, this is THE show of the tour so far. No question.

If this was the year 2000, they would've picked this to be on the Live Phish CD series, let's put it like that.  

2019-06-29 Camden, NJ

6/29/19 Camden

As others have stated, this looks - on paper - to be a pretty straightforward "Rock Show" kind of gig. Fine by me as long as the musics good!!

Off to a great start with a 20 minute Mike's Groove!!


Set 1

Mike's Song - Opening number so I will excuse the rust. Not the most powerful or hot version. Pretty sleepy, if I'm being honest. But big points for being opening number. It gets a pass for that! :) Also, the tune does eventually build up to a head of steam that's pretty tasty, but nothing special at all.

I Am Hydrogen - Hydro is Hydro! :)

Weekapaug Groove - Holy hell this is not good. The guys sound like they are falling asleep! :( One of the most lifeless Paug's ever!!! BUT, towards the end the fire beneath rises to the surface and we get that ENERGY for a few FREAKIN HOT minutes!!! Too little too late as far as being a highlight, but it has its moment!

Divided Sky - Boy oh boy this set is not going good. A fine Divided Sky, but there are a number of sticky moments from Trey and on the whole you are most likely never going to point to this as a great version. Also, the guys once again sound EXHAUSTED! Did someone spike their drinks with Benadryl or something?!!! What is going on tonight....


Everything's Right - After the pure lethargy of the first 36 minutes of show, ER comes out swinging!! It's pretty short, but the jam we get for several minutes is downright funktastic. At this point I'll take whatever they want to throw my way (the beginning of the set really was that bad...) and this I WILL GLADLY TAKE! :D


Guelah Papyrus - Just when things were looking up we get another not-great rendition, this time of a rarity, unfortunately. Trey sounds lost half the time and it's begging to be put out of its misery. Darn it!!  

Sparkle - Is Sparkle

Roggae - Wonderful Type I beast that sees the guys climbing for the sky. Fantastic Roggae

46 Days - NEXT LEVEL ALERT! NEXT LEVEL ALERT! THIS IS MANDATORY LISTENING! X FACTOR AWESOMENESS! GO GRAB THIS NOW AND BE AMAZED!!!!!!!!!!!!

Overall, a pretty poor set in the grand scheme of things, but grab those 3 highlights, ESPECIALLY 46 FRIGGIN DAYS!!!!

---------------------------------------------------------------

Set 2

Blaze On - A short but strong version opens the set like a party. Good jam that delivers what you expect and the energy carried over from 46 Days (Thank god!)
Very nice transition into NICU!!!

>NICU - Trey set up a flawless transition, slowly working towards NICU for a minute or so. But then instead of allowing the other guys to catch up he ripcords directly into it, like yanking the slack out of a rope. Yuck. Pretty nice version on the whole but it feels like it never totally catches back up to itself.

>Golden Age - The lethargy returns, but a pretty nice choice of song to go into, eh? Blaze>NICU>GA seem like a trio made in heaven :) Eventually the song picks up and gets some strong jamming going. They run out of steam though and segue into Ruby Waves pretty darn perfectly - more than made up for that NICU ripcord!!!

>Ruby Waves - JAM OF THE SHOW BY FAR. THE ONLY THING EVEN APPROACHING THIS IS 46 DAYS!!!! This is 14 outstanding minutes of group improvisation. You hear this, and then its no surprise how they were able to stretch it so good at Alpine!!! Really, really exceptional stuff here. Mandatory listening. Dark and evil Type II that morphs flawlessly into...

>Death Don't Hurt Very Long - Jeez, that's the kinda segue we love!!! :D This version is almost exactly 3 minutes long - kinda more of a KV segue than a true performance, lol. What's here is great though but there's just not enough of it! Trey eventually breaks in with his wah pedal and does probably the only Rift intro on wah!!!!

>Rift - Talk about unexpected!! Wah riff intro. :) Pretty good Rift (we all know how hit-or-miss it is these days!). This would be even better IF WE COULD HEAR TREY PLAYING INSTEAD OF HIM BARELY PICKING THE DANG NOTES!!! :( :( :( When all is said and done I think this is highlight worthy, but it could've been even better!

>Beneath a Sea of Stars - Absolutely wonderful!!! Oh man this is gorgeous. Big Terrapin Station vibes too!!! This sequence since Ruby Waves is just primo. This is freaking gorgeous. A+ playing all around. Id call this mandatory too. STUNNING Type II ambient outro!! X FACTOR!! X FACTOR!! X FACTOR!!!


>Waiting All Night - Oh my freaking god this is smoother than having sex in an oil vat filled with melted butter.


>Ghost - A short but WELL WORTH YOUR TIME Ghost brings things back to a funky, hot fever pitch!! Awesome funk workout. Fantastic little Ghost. :)

>SAY IT TO ME SANTOS!

You Enjoy Myself - Top notch 3.0 version. Totally nailed. Absolutely perfect ending to the show. Fantastic

Grind - Is Grind :p


All in all, I'd give this show a 3.3 to 3.5, personally. The highlights were MAGICAL but there was so much that was, well, not magical as well. Definitely a show to grab the highlights and steer clear of the rest. Set 1 was easily the WORST set of the year so far by a WIDE margin. Set 2 was up and down, but once they hit Ruby Waves it was magic from there.


2019-06-28 Camden, NJ

6/28/19 Camden

Spent the first half hour listening while cleaning my room, so the notes on the awesome first half hour will be brief :)

Set Your Soul Free - Absolutely FANTASTIC opener tonight! Rocks hard, gets you moving, and the jam was sick. Great start!!

Strawberry Letter 23 - Third time played at this point (I got number 4 in Charleston! :) ) and it rocks. Wonderful addition to the repetoire and this is a great version.

My Friend My Friend - A fine version, nothing special (always welcome!) but it does have the Myfe ending.

Halfway to the Moon - I remember when they played this in Charleston it took me a minute to figure out what it was as I wasn't ultra-into the Fuego album yet. I kinda couldn't believe I had been stumped!! :) That one was pretty good, but this one I think slays it. Unexpectedly fantastic and great jamming from all. Really worth checking out!

Old Home Place - Was this a bustout? Nothing to be said - the fun bluegrass diversion for the set.

Train Song - Not great, flub-wise, but a pretty fun version with some crowd approval of the wine lyrics. :)

>Horn - Fantastic, unexpected and pretty flawless segue into Horn!!!! A stomping and powerful rendition. Unless it's Portland '98, Horn is Horn, but this one is still well worth a few minutes of your time.

Birds of a Feather - Fakeout time with that CTSOTHH intro! Trey counts in and the boys are OFF!!! Page plays around with the samples a bit and hits a wrong Kasvot Vaxt patch a few times. Pretty funny and in good nature and it makes the guys laugh so I'll take it. :) Loaded with energy, this is a strong and "concise" 10 minute exercise in ripping your head off. Listening to Trey try not to bust his gut while Page goes bonkers with samples is pretty amusing. Wonderful version that goes to some great Type II ripping space funk soundscapes. Essential listening! THIS BIRDS IS FANTASTIC!!!!!!!!! It's not just "HOT" - it's "HOT" WITH A PURPOSE! Eventually the maelstrom subsides and we are bathed in blissful light to soothe our battered souls. And then BAM back into the main theme with a "THEY ATTACK!" sample to close it all out. Holy hell....

Wolfman's Brother - A+ Wolf!!!! This one FUNKS harder than you can believe. They just dig right into that filthy, nasty, groovy murk and ride it all the way home. This is some hardcore funk, brothers and sisters. Jeez...Slowly and patiently they work the jam into some spacy bliss-funk or something. Ambient synths washing in and out, piano pounding away. Extremely cool. Then they groove on into some more straightforward Type I country rock styles returning to the WB area. From here they just build it and build it to a great peak, blowing the roof off. Absolute outstanding Wolfman!!!

Wombat - Love Wombat but this isn't the greatest. A few lyrical flubs and Trey ripcords full-stop into Timber before the song has a moment to do ANYTHING. WHY HAS WOMBAT NOT BECOME A JAM BEAST?! THEY RARELY PLAY IT AND YOUD THINK IT WOULD BE KILLING IT ALL THE TIME!!!! :(

>Timber - Getting the ripcord out of the way, this is pretty nice. As with Wombat, it doesn't do much of note, but its always great to hear and the playing is very nice. Just 5 minutes of pretty darn good Type I :)

Drift While You're Sleeping - Really excellent version to finish the set. I really love this song more each time I hear it. This was great version with everyone dialed in - sounded rehearsed :) Fishman going bonkers with them fills!!! A wonderfully upbeat closing to a monster of a set!!


A very, very strong first set, imo. Some MASSIVE highlights in that SYSF, BOAF and Wolfman. If you do anything, at least grab those three.  

----------------------------------------------------------

Set 2

Mercury - YES!!! I went nuts when I got this in Charleston. Still probably my favorite post-2015 song and maybe the song I wanted to hear more than any other. My version was not one of the best, but hey, I got Mercury, so I don't care :p This one is 21 minutes long and freaking awesome. No use trying to describe it - it's nothing out of the ordinary for a Mercury jam (high quality Phish phunk) but its still really great and flows terrifically. Everyone is contributing strongly (hell, I'm even zeroed in on Mike this time!!!) and the whole thing just congeals super nicely. Awesome jam.

>No Men In No Man's Land - Great segue out of Mercury. They are about to close the song, Trey starts signaling the No Men riff and everyone just jumps straight on board almost without missing a beat. Great bit of whole-band playing. :) This version of the song is "as you would expect". Great funky Type II jamming that covers the ground you'd expect it to. No surprises, just another really wonderful jam and playing by the guys!! ABSOLUTELY SMASHING PEAK THOUGH!!!!!!!! Really awesome when the jam slows right down at its conclusion and slowly morphs seamlessly into WACTOOB. Well, almost seamlessly - There was a strong attempt, ok? :p

We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains - A strong version, but nothing overly special. Just some very well played Type I. If you like the song you should love this funky version. :)

About to Run - Yet another tune I got in Charleston. I have vivid memories of that particular performance. I rocked out to that so hard. :p This one is great - love having a heavier rock tune for the guys to bang out!! About To Run feels like Neil Young-meets-Pink Floyd to me or something. Can you imagine Uncle Neil shredding this up with Crazy Horse?! Total Sleeps With Angels vibes!! :) End of story, Trey rips this up as expected.

Light - Holy crap, a standalone version! :p Freaking great jamming on this. No need to narrate, just 11 minutes of pure, awesome, funky blissful peaking and shredding and rocking with a great WACTOOB reprise!!!!!!!

Run Like An Antelope - Antelope is Antelope: cue the face melting. Holy hell. Sonic death!

Sleeping Monkey - Is Sleeping Monkey :)

Quinn The Eskimo - Nice to hear! Good version and a good closer.



All in all, I think set 1 is the winner (that trio of SYSF, BOAF and Wolfman were all next-level). Set 2 was pretty terrific playing-wise, BUT it definitely felt like a set I might've heard 10 times before, you know what I mean? Nothing really new or super amazing - lots of great playing and most of it is worth your time, it just wasn't especially UNIQUE, I guess.

Very small "first world Phish nut" gripe :)

In conclusion, another very strong summer 2019 gig!!! I'd probably give it a 3.8 to 4.0 rating if I had to. Great stuff on the whole!

Monday, November 15, 2021

2011-06-10 Camden, NJ

Awesome 1.0 looking setlist tonight! Someone on .NET said, aside from Joy, this setlist coulda come out of 1996 :)

Raging Rock Top to start :p

But then the guys immediately get down to business with a great Mike's>Hydrogen>Groove

Noteworthy, this is the second show in a row that featured Mike's Groove!!! Only it's Hydro tonight instead of FEFY  

------------------------------

Alright, I'll spare y'all the play-by-play (no pun intended...) of 6/10/11 Camden

Ok, set 1 -
Up and down, but everything baseline "excellent". The highlights are awesome.

Set 2 -

HOLY FRIGGIN CRAP THAT WAS INCREDIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nothing in the way of jamming beyond the DWD, really, but the whole set was a FIRESTORM. The composed pieces SLAYED and the segues and song choice were on point.

Maybe 3rd best 2nd set of the tour so far? Amazing stuff.

--------------------------------

6/10 Camden ** (SET 2 IS ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING! SET 2 IS INCREDIBLE!!)
Weekapaug Groove
Stash (Dark!)
Guyuute
Guelah Papyrus
Scent of a Mule
The Curtain With (BEST EVER?!?!)
Down With Disease (Dark and NASTY Type II)
>Free (SPECTACULAR SEGUE!)
>Possum (ABSOLUTELY FREAKIN INSANE!)
BBFCFM (METAL PANDEMONIUM!!!)
Swept Away
>Steep
>David Bowie (ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING)
Julius
Fluffhead (FLAWLESS!)
>Joy
Bold As Love

2011-06-01 Holmdel, NJ - RIPCORD HELL

Bad weather this morning. Downloading WSPanic shows and continuing on in 2011

Show #5, Holmdel #2
This looks like a "sleeper" show on paper. Good news is that I very much like the songs being played and that is 90% of the occasional struggle of getting through a show for me :p

First Tube was raging as an opener - I'm not used to it opening!
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - I never would've picked it for slot 2 but IT ACTUALLY WORKED PERFECTLY! WOW!!!

Wow, there's not a single song in this whole show that I "dislike". Let's keep goin  

------------------------------------

Seven Below>Kill Devil Falls

THAT WAS BULL### WHAT THE EFF GUYS YOU START THE JAM THEN FADE IT OUT AS SOON AS IT BEGAN AND LAUNCH INTO ANOTHER SONG BOO BOO BOO BOO BOO !!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm a song guy - jams are the icing on the cake for me - but this was DUMB, yo! The guys start diving into space and within a MINUTE decide instead to end the song and launch into KDF.

I love KDF and this one ROCKS but if this was 1999 that Seven Below would've gone for 20 minutes of amazeballs.

Gah, that was so lame. :p

:D

At least this KDF is AWESOME! 

--------------------------------------------

Man, it's been taking me all day to get through this - halfway through set 1 stuff came up around the house.

Got home a few hours later and am now up to Piper

This show is bipolar as hell. They keep sidling up to the edge of the abyss, ready to launch into a jam (Seven Below, Carini, Ghost....) but then they just....don't.

These are even dreaded ripcord versions! They just...end the song instead of going into jam mode. Extremely odd. You kinda half to hear it.

The energy is sky high and I love the setlist, but they (Trey) have their foot on the brake for some reason tonight. Super weird.

 --------------------------------------------------
 
Carini>Piper>Twist

OW! IT HURTS! NO MORE RIPCORDING PLEASE!!!


:cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry:

:magoo::magoo::magoo::magoo::magoo::magoo:
 
----------------------------------------------------
 
6/1 Holmdel (Strong performance but lots of ripcording)
First Tube
Stealing Time
Gotta Jibboo
Kill Devil Falls (HOTTEST EVER!)
Split Open and Melt (Very dark and disjointed)
Suzy Greenberg
Tweezer>
NO QUARTER (DEBUT!!!)
Twist>
Ghost> RIPCORD
Number Line (DANG!)
Show of Life