An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Showing posts with label 2020. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2020. Show all posts

Thursday, August 1, 2024

2020-02-23 Quintana Roo, MX - 2024 revisit

 2/23/20 Mexico

Set 1

The show begins with 3 songs that nobody wants to open a show - all in a row. Crowd Control, Farmhouse and Breath and Burning. But ya know what? Ill take em!! They flow together great and there is definitely a "vibe" tonight - a laid back and relaxed one.

Farmhouse is gorgeous and Breath, while not as fiery, is ultimately overall a "smoother" version than 12/8 in Charleston.

A PERFECTLY played Divided Sky keeps the energetic-yet-relaxed feel going perfectly!!! Trey stops in the break to acknowledge the awesomeness of the occasion of Phish in Mexico. Then its back into the song to finish. Great version . Serious heart on this one. Its not the most musically impressive version, it just has a great "warmth" about it...

After a nice Meat, we get probably the most remembered piece of music from Mexio 2020 - the 18 minute Everythings Right. And holy moly what a smokeshow! The X Factor is strong - this is as close to a "perfect" jam as you could get. Just flawless. Mandatory listening!

Surprisingly, Coil (kinda sloppy tonight) is not set closer, but it does go nicely into Wingsuit. An absolutely spectacular version in an era of amazing versions. X FACTOR MAGIC ON THIS ONE! HOLY CRAP!.

Good Bowie to close.

All in all, all you NEED is Everythings Right and maybe Divided Sky and Wingsuit. The rest of the set was positively average, but it was a COHESIVE average which made it strangely enjoyable. Much better set than you think, though it wont win any awards or anything.

Also, its absolutely about the VIBE with this set. Major points for that. You can't help but feel it.... 


Set 2

In amazing fashion, following on the heels of that incredible Everythings Right, they slam us by starting the set with TWO massive and deep workouts!!!!

Simple begins proceedings - 15+ minutes, this one quickly abandons the usual bliss and spends the majority of its time diving into the murky and oh so funky abyss of darkness. Absolutely must hear!!! It gets so ridiculous, they wind up in a full on "In a Gadda Da Vida" heavy metal jam towards the end. Just insane! This actually sounds like a jam out of the late 90s or something!!! X Factor all over this beast! All hail Simple deviation!!!! Complete and total dark-funk type 2 awesomeness!!!

Hot on its heels, they immediately launch into a nearly 18 minute Golden Age! Often times a perfunctory "time killer" late in a fledgling 2nd set, this one is much more in line with the greats of past, ala Hampton 2018. This thing FUNKS with a capital F!! Trey doing great delay work and Gordo annihilating all over... Even better than Simple, this again is X Factor Magic on steroids. Strange, and weird. Flawed, yet incredibly intriguing as well. This jam goes DEEP.
Just utter awesomeness in every way. They freaking CRUSH this!!! Essential listening!!!!

And just as we are being suffocated by the black hole vortex that is the final few minutes of this Golden Age, Page perfectly introducs Fuego and off we go! Fuego ends up being excellent without being essential. Never straying from the "base" type 1 jam, they still burn that sucker to the ground and deliver a version even better than 12/29/19's straightforward rendition. Great stuff!

Fuego concludes and Trey sounds for a split second like hes going to go into Ghost before quickly realizing they already played one and instead opts nicely for Undermind instead. A terrific type 1 reading full of choice delay inserts and even a full blown Manteca jam and Plasma teasing!! Must hear!

As is usual with the 2019 period, the boys are on top of their segue game and Undermind some morphs seamlessly into Back On The Train. Killer. As with Undermind, they stretch the boundaries of the song, toying with Simple, playing around with ambience, doing a bit of this and a bit of that. Somehow the song totally dissolves into several minutes of full blown, pulsing, outer space ambience!!! What the hell is going on! Full blown type 2 BOTT!!!!

BOTT dies down and from the ashes rises....Passing Through as set closer?! Wtf?! Ok just go with it! Sounds great - inspired version!!!

Lengthy encore of Rise, Silent, Fee, Funky B and the obligatory More to close the door on Phish 3.0

All in all, while set 1 was pretty "average" despite 2 or 3 massive highlights, it held together GREAT and played like a dream. Set 2 continued the strange fun of set 2 of 2/22/20. Simple>Golden Age and Undermind>Back On The Train are all MUST HEAR! Simple and Golden Age are both towering titans of jams along with the Everything's Right in set 1.

Maybe not a flawless "complete show experience", but honestly? The damn jams might have been the best of all 4 nights!!! And that is saying A LOT!!!!!


MEXICO 2020 IS A SUPREMELY UNDERRATED RUN LOADED WITH INCREDIBLE MUSIC.

Seriously, this run BLOWS AWAY the 2019 New Years run and its not even funny......

:)

On to casual 2021 relisten! :D

2020-02-22 Quintana Roo, MX - 2024 revisit

 2/22/20 Mexico

Set 1

The show opens with Fishman singing Willin. Good stuff but does nothing for me, lol

The REAL opener is a beautiful 12.5 minute Tube!! This one starts funky but spends the majority of its time in a soaring, heavenly kind of bliss zone. Trey sounds like he is deliberately leaving space and building the jam, picking his spots, slowly building it to a massive peak. Probaby must hear. Stick with it - it gets good, I swear! :)

Unfortunately good will is lost when they ruin the set flow by following that with Evening Song. Look, I love the song, but bad placement is bad placement, ok?

Recognizing the error, Trey launches them into a terrific 11 minute Set Your Soul Free. Uptempo, HIGH ENERGY, rocking and everything you need, it gets the job done, going type "1.5", if you will, into a tropical party zone before concluding and turning into...

Not must hear, but excellent!

...
You Sexy Thing! :D

YST, 46 Days, Waste, Your Pet Cat....all are solid, fine versions, but none are worth a second listen.

Then comes Mr. 17 minute Tweezer to the rescue!!! Hot, funky type 1 for 9 minutes leads into a full blown Manteca jam! And its off to the races we go! Type 2 funk madness morphing into friggin Makisupa.... must hear!! This is sick!!!!

They segue spectacular into You Sexy Makisupa and out again into a terrific Type 1 funk fest Twist to end the set.


All in all, a pretty uneven set. Nothing was bad, but the set flow was all over and the only things you really need are the Tweezer madness and probably that Tube. Definitely an "off" set.

That Tweezer>Mak>Twist was NUTS though!!! :) 


Set 2

Nice, rocking duo of Energy into Soul Planet to start. Guess Trey wanted a retry of the botched pairing back on 12/8!

Energy is fantastic, diving deep into a dark and psychedelic jam for a few glorious minutes before awkwardly coming to an unfortunate close.

Trey starts up Soul Planet and this one has MAJOR funk legs, but as with Energy, it dies just as its really taking off. Still, the 8 minutes that are here are A+++++ . Killer! Id pretty much call this must hear!!! As good or BETTER than the New Years version!!!

Even better, they segue into a 19 friggin minute Waves!!!! Waves is spectacular. Pure X Factor Magic, it spends its duration in spastic outer space psycho jazz land, ultimately peaking hard before crashing ashore....Total magic! MUST HEAR!!

The following Carini might even top that!!! 13 minutes and not a second wasted. It goes extremely dark and GRIMY turning into some kind of space funk soup...This one is NEXT LEVEL. Put this in the pantheon of all time greats. This is not an exaggeration. Complete X Factor Godzilla Stomp Magic!!! DESTRUCTION!!!!

A tasty Chalkdust is the bow on top. Slightly unhinged ala the SPAC 2023 version, this one quickly dives into a tropical kind of type 2 before melting into Have Mercy! Another must hear! Fantastic!!

After a standard, but appropriately placed Life Beyond, we get a great Hood. Ham Hands Anastasio totally botches the composed parts, but the band pulls it together and the jam is a powerhouse!!! Not quite 12/29/19, itll still suffice. Solid enough!

Awesome Sweet Jane into Tweeprize encore


Man oh man where did they pull this friggin set from?!?!? Couple set 1 of 2/21/20 with set 2 of 2/22/20 and youd have a legit all-time 3.0 show!!!!! The Soul Planet, Waves>Carini and Chalkdust were all spectacular and must hear! I give this set 10 thumbs up!!

If only set 1 were this good!!! 

PLEASE GO REVISIT THAT CARINI! ALL OF YOU!! :)

2020-02-21 Quintana Roo, MX - 2024 revisit

 Mexico 2020 moves onwards with night #2!

SHAFTY!

2/21/20

Set 1

The show gets off to a partytastic start with a stomping Turtle. Awesome as always and a prfect mood setter.

Immediately we dive headfirst into "wtf?! X Factor Land when they follow that up with.....Shafty?!?!? And not just a jam - they actually play the song properly, jam it into Plasma back into Shafty again and back out AGAIN into Plasma once more!

Dude!! MUST HEAR! FREAKIN AMAZEBALLS!!! SHAFTY-PLASMA SANDWICH!!!! :D

As if on cue, The Lizards rises beautifully from that funky wasteland to bring us back to the beach. Oh man, does the tropical vibe of The Lizards fit so perfect or WHAT?! Its honestly an excellent version, as good as Charleston or better. Very well played and the set placement was super fresh and felt so perfect outta that Shafty bizness.

Killer.

As if all of that wasnt enough, next we get a friggin 19 gosh darn minute Gin-Shafty-Gin sandwich! Welcome to the Phish deli I guess! Gin is absolutely INCREDIBLE!! X FACTOR MAGIC! MUST HEAR!!! Honestly, this Gin might be better than every version played in 2019 - its THAT good. If you dont have "Stevie Ray Vaughan guitar scrunched up stank face" at some point during this jam, something is wrong with you!

So Gin begins quietly and patiently, Page eventually taking charge, the band slowly funking it up yet getting more and more powerful by the second until its some kind of dark, funky runaway freight train in outer space. Or something like that. Absolutely insane Gin....

And the hits keep coming with wonderful 13 minute Blaze On. No ordinary version, this one goes true, dark type 2. If you are looking for a genuine out-there reading, look no further! Right from the outset the jam has a dark feel, and they just lay more and more into it, giving us a solid 8 or so minutes of primo funky jamming that just slowly kind of deconstructs itself bit by bit as it goes along, winding up in ultra funky outer space. Eventually in the end section, Fishman and Gordo perfectly set up a Plasma reprise, but Trey unfortunately denies their request and we get....

Another truly remarkable jam, please dont overlook this. X Factor Magic strikes again, baby!

...the first Sea and Sand since friggin Ventura 1998!!!!!! YAY!! And it is awesome! Not much to say!

Possum shreds this perfect set to a close. Fantastic version that is as pedal to the medal as any classic modern take. Killer.

All in all ...HOLY CRAP THIS SET WAS AMAZING!!!! No, seriously, it was next-level Phish for sure. Massive bustouts, several must hear jams, perfect flow and song selection (imo)....Seriously. This is honestly a damn flawless set to me and I dont say that lightly. The ONLY bad part was Trey killing the jams in Gin and Blaze a bit early it felt like, but other than that...holy moly they came out to KILL!! The Shafty-Plasma sandwich, the Bathtub Gin, the dark space Blaze On. All must hear, full of that extra x factor. If we were to count this as a a 2019 show, I would honestly call that Blaze On the version of the year and that Gin probably the version of the year.

WOW!   


Set 2

The still-new Sigma Oasis opens the set. This is probably the tightest one yet. Still no sign of the jam beast to come (who the hell could have predicted that?!) but its a great version, honestly!!! This version smokes and Trey delivers an outstanding solo. Sick.

Sigma concludes and we get a perfect segue into a 12 minute 2001!!! Im really loving the extended 2001s of late 2019 era! The initial jam on this is excellent. Trey is digging hard into the wah and the squiggles if you will. Page is echoing him on the synth. Great stuff. First chorus around 4.5 minutes! Following that a super sick "motif" jam appears that they all latch on to and jam the F out of. This sucker is NASTY! This sucker is HEAVY!! MUST HEAR 2001!! THEY TAKE IT FOR A RIDE!!!! :D SPECTACULAR!!!!!!

And they follow that with??? Drift?? Ok, bad song call, but honestly, the slow build out of 2001 is dynamic and actually kinda works, setlist wise. And its a strong version as well - the finale is rocking as ever. Bad song call, but good stuff (??) :)

Continuing the enjoyable bad set placements is an excellent Lifeboy followed by a friggin MUST HEAR IAWITW. This version SMOKES! Not the super jam of Mexico 2019, this is a blazing type 1 rock and roll FACE MELTER.

Best part, it segues flawlessly into No Men! Nice! No Men rages like fire and goes full on Shafty type 2.

Must hear!! That IAWITW>No Men was spectacular!!!

Piper continues the type 2 outer space microjam fun of No Men to greatly diminished results before a typically hot Good Times Bad Times closes the set.

Inspired encore of Sand into a standalone Weekapaug into another Shafty reprisenand we are out...

All in all, set 1 was magnificent. Set 2 was perfectly fine but nowhere near the excellence of set 1. It felt like they blew their wad in set 1 and didn't know how to top it going in to set 2.

Still, for set 2, that 2001 and the IAWITW/No Men are both must hear.

Another killer show with higher heights than night 1, but overall more imbalance between the 2 sets for sure.

2020-02-20 Quintana Roo, MX - 2024 revisit

 Finally we get to Mexico 2020!! Ive been dying to replay this run forever - I always remembered enjoying it immensely.

First off with the one setter, 2/20/20.
I watched the webcast for this one and absolutely LOVED it! Of course, my original review....you'd think it was the Great Went or something... :p

Wolfy's Idiot Reviews: 2020-02-20 Quintana Roo, MX

Lets play this with a fresh view, shall we? :) Fun to see how my opinion might change from 4 years ago!

So, 2/20/20 gets off to an unexpected start with a rare bustout of the Stones classic Torn and Frayed. Not my cup for opener, but I love the song and love hearing it, so...

A very nice Ghost follows. About 11 minutes, this one gets going nicely into a pretty hot bliss -rock zone. Kinda type 1.5-ish. My original review raved about it but I just dont hear it today. Its pleasant enough but not very impressive, imo. Good stuff, but I wouldnt call it must hear.

The following Free, however....whoah boy...hold on to your water wings, X Factor Magic approaching!!!! Ala the Hampton 2018 sample-ridden Golden Age, this Free goes DARK! Diving deep into the abyss they pull out Shipwreck and explore for sunken treasure before returning for air.

An absolutely incredible piece of music. Just insane!!!!

Shake Your Coconuts is stupid as hell but SUPER fun! I love love love it and Victim sounds petty darn good - much better than the Fall tour version. Too bad its the final rendition, this one got going!

Moma was a perfect choice to keep the grooving going out of Victim. A good Moma that does what its supposed to but nothing special.

Gotta Jibboo seems to have extra sauce tonight though. A wonderful reading, just full of that extra something. Excellent version!!!!

A triple header of rarities ensues with an absolutely gorgeous Shade followed by The Landlady and Destiny Unbound.

Shade really fit perfectly in that spot after Jibboo, I swear....Shade is Shade, but that was a great version.

They pick us up quickly with the shockingly potent duo of Landlay into Destiny. Landlady sounded flawless to me and had me going "why wasnt THIS the show opener?!". Destiny was top tier as well - not as exploratory as Charleston, it was still EXTREMELY FUNKY and more than delivered the goods. An absolute highlight!

Sick!

Continuing the groovy flow of fhe set, we move nicely into an excellent Steam. Steam turns in an absolute spectacular rendition - perfectly patient and hot and melty and, well...steamy!!!!! This sucker is hazy!!! Like a steaming hot sauna. Absolutely fantastic!!!!!! They KILL this one! Extra mustard all over!!! Dare I say X Factor Magic!!!!!!! WOW!!! ALL TIMER STEAM. SERIOUSLY.

They pick the tempo up perfectly now with a sick Crosseyed and Painless!!! Talk about yer perfect setlist call! 10 minutes on this one. Nice jamming!

Unfortunately Antelope is rather weak tonight (it has the energy but feels sloppy) and Cavern is Cavern, but Sea of Stars is just MAGICAL!!!! Holy moly yet another X Factor winner over here.....

Great SANTOS and YEM close us perfectly.


All in all, for a Mexico one setter I still think this is a GREAT listen! It really feels like a proper, cohesive "full show" rather than some short warmup, ya know? Obviously the Shipwreck Free is must hear as is probably Destiny, that ridiculous meltdown Steam and Sea of Stars (for sure on that one!!!). Crosseyed is great as well!


I will absolutely go to bat for this as one of the great overlooked shows that everyone should hear.

I would put this at the lower rungs of the upper tier of 2019 shows, honestly. The flow is great for the most part, the song choices are great, there are several must hear jams.....

No its not an all timer but....its just....look, ok, THIS IS AN AWESOME SHOW! :)

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Mexico 2020 Recap

 Ok, final thoughts on Mexico 2020:

Favorite show:
2/20

This one had it all - the flow, the "here we are!!" energy, an insane setlist, magical X Factor jamming from the start to the finish, etc. I can see why others prefer the other shows but this one connected with me more than any show in a good while. A terrific, terrific show!!!!

"Strongest" show in terms of jamming:
2/22
This show was an absolute BEAST. The first set sounded promising but lukewarm for most of it, but than that Tweezer hit and we were off to the races. This continued straight into set 2 which started with insanity and didn't let off until the encores were finished. Set 2 of this show is probably the strongest full set, start to finish, of the whole run but the first set was middling until Tweezer, so points redacted for that.

"worst" (there is no bad show in the 4) show by a wide margin:
2/21
2001 is great in the 2nd set and there's other greatness there as well, but they came out of the gate with a BANG on this show. One of the strongest first sets in recent memory - if you combined set 1 of this show with set 2 of 2/22, you would have a full-on classic that everyone would be talking about on .NET for decades to come!!!

A+ for effort show:
2/23
The setlist looks rather weak in spots on paper, but this show was ALL about vibe. The first set was SO much fun and the playing was at such a high level (for this point in time!). If you can look past the songs picked this show is loaded with goodness, though this might be another where the first set outshines the 2nd. There is a load of epic-length Type II in set 2, but a lot of it sounds rather "stale", for lack of a better word. Great dance music but not much memorable, ya dig? Still, the 2nd set tries its hardest and still comes out great in the end. I would rank this the 3rd show for overall quality of the four. :)


So basically, in my opinion from strongest to weakest:

1. 2/22
2. 2/20 (My preferred favorite of the 4!)
3. 2/23
4. 2/21

All four shows had jaw dropping moments and jams and you could make an outstanding compilation of the 4 if you wanted!!! Don't skip on these gigs - they are fantastic!!!! :)

2020-02-23 Quintana Roo, MX

 2/23/20 Quintana Roo #4

Set 1

Crowd Control - Not my favorite song (always sounds like a Who knockoff to me or something) but I will still take it. Great high energy version! Trey seems to have ridden himself of the occasional sticky-fingered slop that drenched his playing on 2/22. Nicely fluid solos - still more ever-sustained notes - and a rousing energy from the whole band! Not my favorite song but a great opener for night 4!! :)

Farmhouse - IN SPOT #2?! REALLY?! Ok, exaggeration aside I can get down with this. If this was an indoors arena gig or something....that's one thing. This is on the beach in friggin' Mexico with the moon and the stars and the sand and the water! I'm sure it was just gorgeous in person and in all honestly, it flowed great out of Crowd Control! Who woulda thought, eh? Great Farmhouse as always (find me one that isn't beautiful!). Good stuff!

Breath and Burning
- Yes! I am seemingly the only lover of this song out there, but c'mon, is this not the perfect place for them to play it?! Awesome. Great party-setter! I can just picture dancing my tail off to this on the beach. And this one is simply wonderful - dance in the light of the moon indeed! Such a FANTASTIC feel-good vibe to this one! All hail BaB tonight! The perfect song for the perfect spot. This one just hits. :)

Divided Sky - After Trey and co's "mediocre looking crowd" moment of banter, we get into perfectly played DS! When's the last time Trey NAILED the composition like this?! I mean, I thought the one I got in Charleston '19 was pretty good, but this was perfect!!! Perfectly nuanced and dynamic, just absolutely spectacular. * chef's kiss * During the silence part, around 7 minutes, Trey takes a bit to acknowledge how awesome the crowd and venue are and how lucky they are to be there, etc. Very nice. Then back into DS like nothing ever happenned. Nothing else to say - the song proceeds as expected. It's absolutely loaded with energy and passion tonight and is one (notably!) the best versions heard in recent times. If you are looking for a good late-period DS, look no further!!!! A+

Following DS, some very funny banter ensues between Trey, Fish and the crowd regarding Trey's "mediocre looking crowd" comments :)

Meat - After a lightspeed Ramones "1,2,3,4!" countoff it's into the song :p As with the rest of the set so far, an absolutely wonderful relaxed-yet-energetic (does that make sense?!) vibe carries through. No sleepiness here! It's very short though with no jam and Trey instead opts to lead us into...

Everything's Right - The song is extremely powerful and full-on as expected. Totally imbued with the evening's celebratory energy. This set so far has just been a party! And this is no exception!! The guys waste no time getting down to business, quickly jumping into the jam about 5 minutes in with Trey scatting some vocals. Trey then hits another sustained note with Page doing some cool ascending licks beneath him. By this time at 7 minutes it's just full on Type I FIRE FIRE FIRE!!! This ER is just steamrolling you into the friggin' sand!!! Shortly though this gives way to som ultra-gnarly Type II funk razing. I mean, this beach is on fire. For real. You know we are going deep when Gordo turns on his effects! Trey starts doing some cool ambient playing which Page picks up on, all the while Cactus and Fish are holding down a steady groove funkier than you can imagine. Just outstanding. This gives way to lots of awesome raging before turning into an upbeat kind of Harry Hood-esque bliss-type jam. Lots of sustained notes from Trey while everyone else is just building towards the sky. This is like a Bird Song on steroids or something. THIS IS FREAKING MAGICAL! X FACTOR ABOUND!!! DON'T SKIP THIS!! THIS DESERVES ALL THE PRAISE IT GETS!!!! Slowly it fades out and we go into....

The Squirming Coil - Hitchike to the beach. Oh yea. :) It's fantastic. It's Squirming Coil. What else can I say?

Wingsuit - After Coil, maybe not the best set choice?? But I'm sure it'll be great - hey, they made Farmhouse work in the 2nd slot. It's all about tonight's vibe, baby! This one is a bit on the sloppy side, BUT it is loaded with that insane energy we know and love come the peak. Get it Trey! It's Wingsuit - Trey kills. What more do you want?!

David Bowie - Bowie has disappointed me a lot over 2019 but this one reclaims the mantle of greatness! An absolutely wonderful rendition that is tight as a nail and has a terrific multi-flavored old-school sounding jam to it that keeps you on edge until the end. I'm tired of it as set closer but gosh darn if every new version was this good I would never complain! Spectacular!!



Night 4 in Mexico gets an A+ for the first set!!!! Sure, on paper the set may look odd at times, but you have to remember the venue and the VIBE and all that jazz. This is definitely a "set fits the mood" kind of gig. The playing is top notch. Divided Sky is among the best in recent times as is the epic Everything's Right and David Bowie that both deserve jam chart/hall of fame entries, in my book!! A terrific, terrific set!!! 

 

Set 2

Simple - Oh, yes, you know it's gonna be good when they open the 2nd set with a 16 minute Simple! The song portion is surprisingly rough but it's all in good fun tonight. 6 minutes in and we leave the song, immediately heading into spacey jam land. Don't feel like commentating the whole thing, but it's an epic Type II space funk extravaganza that is just fantastic. IN A GADDA DA VIDDA JAM, YO!

>Golden Age - Literally the perfect (and only acceptable) choice out of that beastly Simple. Basically Simple Part 2, it keeps the party absolutely raging for another glorious 18 minutes of magic. Fantastic. Around 13 minutes the dancing stops and we go into black-hole outer space with delays and reverbs etc. GNARLY. 15 minutes in and we are just out there! Again, go listen - don't listen to my lackluster "reviewing". This is pretty must-hear, imo. Awesome stuff. :)

Fuego - After 5 minutes of Deep Space Black Hole Vortex Meltdown we arrive at our destination. It's Fuego with Simple teases. It's great. It keeps the party rolling. What more do you want? The final few minutes see the song burn out again into another worm hole, but fortunately they ride it PERFECTLY and execute a flawless transition into...

Undermind - Raging Page on this sucker! Fantastic playing from all and choice use of effects from Trey. This is as good as Type I gets (as good for sure as my beloved Charleston rendition :) ). Can't ignore Manteca jamming either! Plasma teases too! This thing is a beast!

Back On The Train - THAT SEGUE! WHO SAW THAT COMING! THAT WAS SICK!! As good as the previous Undermind. Teases abound (Simple!) and just packed with pizazz. Somehow they morph this into 1999 Ambient Black Hole Space!!!! Shades of Fukuoka 2000 :) A full-on black hole BOTT. NICE!!!! Must-hear!!!!

>Passing Through - My least favorite KV song besides maybe Play By Play, but ok, whatever. BUT THIS IS AWESOME! Everyone rages hard and this sucker just kills. Beautiful and upbeat, this would have be bobbing on the sand for sure. Terrific Type I "Grateful Dead" style jamming on this. Jeez this is so good that its STUPID! Don't skip this!!!!

Rise Come/Together
- 4 minutes but a total banger! Don't miss - A+ version! Fire!!!

The Horse/Silent In The Morning - All are identical. Next! :)

Fee - Who doesn't love Fee, even if Trey forgets most of the lyrics? :)

Funky B - It's Funky B, it's hot as always. Nothing special. Feels really out of place though for some reason.

More - Of course this is the closer for the run, lol. What else did we expect?! :D A terrific version that closes it all in a neat little package.



All in all, set 2 of night 4 was very strong, but Simple>Golden Age didn't do THAT much considering the run time. It was terrific, don't get me wrong, but kinda stayed in one zone throughout. The rest of the set was killer as well though, even if it was in smaller packages. The Undermind>BOTT>Passing Through is MUST HEAR! After that, the set kinda falters a little bit with a string of short songs that are nice to hear but don't do anything special for the most part.

Still, if this were a standard 2019 show it would definitely deserve some props. Another great gig all around!

2020-02-22 Quintana Roo, MX

 2/22/20 Quintana Roo #3

Willin - Bustout! First since the Waiting For Columbus gag on 10/31/10 :) Starting this, how many thought it was Velvet Sea, eh? :p Great choice for an opener to set the low-key party vibe with the Mexico references and a Fishman vocal. Great stuff! :)

Tube - After the "warmup" of Willin, we get the perfect choice for PROPER opener! Trey seems to be having guitar problems, but once those are fixed, we get an awesome 12+ minute party fest. Oh yes. Perfect beach-dancing music! Goes Type II quickly around 4 minutes. A blissful jam appears and it's off to feel-good paradise. Cool backwards delay from Trey. From here on out they pretty much just give us a strong and blissful peak-laden ride to the sky. Not the most amazing Tube ever, but a damn great way to kick off a beach party! Awesome stuff!!

Evening Song - Love the song and glad to get the 2nd version of it, but I really think they should've waited until later to play it. A slow opener, a raging tube, and then a pop-ballad in spot #3? C'mon, guys. But I digress, this is a fine version and I love the song anyways so I'll take it. Not list-worthy but good stuff. :)

EDIT - After this I got called in to work unexpectedly. Then got home at 7pm only to be told I need to be awake at 430 so I can be back on the job as 7 am, lol.

Point is, I will restart this tomorrow but I ain't retyping it so you get a mini review of the first 3 songs

:p 


Restarting my listen of 2/22/20, but I'll pick up the review where I left off :)

2/22/20 Quintana Roo #3

Set 1 (cntd)

Set Your Soul Free - Gonna be harsh on this because I love this song/jam vehicle so much. This is list worthy but it pretty much stays in Type I rager mode for 3/4 of it. In the last couple minutes they round the corner into some cool Type II delay jamming but nothing really comes of it and the song ends. A pretty good little taster kind of version but disappointing when you expect so much more from it :p

You Sexy Thing - Fantastic. I believe in miracles indeed! Exactly what the doctor ordered for a beach party! :D

46 Days - RED FRIGGIN HOT! Return Of The Son Of The Longest Sustained Note Ever. Gnarly guitar wrangling from Trey. Short but oh so sweet :D

Waste - After a couple barn burner party tracks, NOW is an appropriate spot for a cool down (do you hear me, Trey?). I love Waste. It is my favorite Phish ballad. I will take any version they want to throw at me. On the list it goes :p

Your Pet Cat - It's YPC. It's short. Too many samples etc. It's fun as always but....NEXT!

Tweezer>Manteca - Oh yes, bring on the Manteca! Ever since the 11/14/95 Stash with that crazy Manteca jam I have been going nuts over this ditty :p I'm pretty tired tonight so I won't wax poetic, but this is pretty dang sweet. 20 minutes of a raging party. Must-hear, imo!!

>Makisupa-You Sexy Thing-Policeman - Exactly as it says :D

>Twist - ABSOLUTELY FRIGGIN OUTSTANDING!!! DO NOT SKIP!!!


All in all, 2/20/22 is still king for me, but this set had some highlights as big as anything else. The final half hour Tweezer through Twist is MANDATORY listening. A very strong set overall and on a different day I would probably be going nuts over it!

 

 Set 2

Energy - Great choice for set opener! A fun pop-rocker that's also kinda still a rarity. A tad sloppy from Trey. Immediately though we dive headfirst into Type II dark space! OUTTA NOWHERE! Not completely into the wormhole though, we go for more of a 1997 Great Went "2001" funky kind of vibe. A steady and frantic beat coupled with funky keys and some thoughtfully placed notes from Trey. Very cool. Dark but not evil. This jam is freaking awesome, but it doesn't evolve out of this, Trey instead opting to ripcord us into Soul Planet....

Soul Planet - I'll take it! I love SP - it always rocks and is dumb fun - come at me, haters! This one kicks ass! Absolutely loaded with all the ENERGY the ACTUAL song "Energy" was slightly lacking!!!! FANTASTIC!!! THIS SUCKER IS NASTY! THIS IS THE BEST TREY HAS PLAYED ALL NIGHT! THIS SP IS SHORT BUT FREAKING DESTROYS!!! DONT SKIP ON THIS!!!! THIS IS SOME X FACTOR MAGIC RIGHT HERE!!!! OUTSTANDING!!!!

Waves - One of the absolute NASTIEST jams of 2019 (look, it might as well be) gets ripcorded/segued into Waves. Ok, Fishman dropped the ball on that transition - I'll concede that. FINALLY the MicroJam is laid to rest and we get a lengthy (damn near 20 minutes!!!) Waves that is all kinds of awesome. Around 7 minutes the Type I slowly dissolves into some more DARK Type II. Well, not really, but things definitely get a hell of a lot more interesting in a "turn the lights down low" kind of way. Fantastically dynamic playing from all at this point. This continues for a wonderful 6 or 7 minutes. Lots of spastic drumming and gnarly Trey, including full-blown Birds Of a Feather teases (how did .NET miss that?!). Around 13:30 things turn another corner and start to slightly cool down a little bit. Page, Mike and Trey all latch onto a descending pattern and ride the same thing together. Very cool. This slowly morphs yet again into a slow-building ascending pattern for a good long while. A very long peak takes its time to build, Trey layering delays on top of each other. THIS IS FRIGGIN PURE X FACTOR MAGIC RIGHT HERE!!!!!!!!!!! DO NOT SKIP!!!! He leaves all the delays repeating and then starts a reprise of the "Ocean is Love" from Soul Planet bringing this duo full circle. Keep in mind at this point we are still in Multi-Delay-Layer-Hell :) This is one of the FRIGGIN COOLEST JAMS IVE HEARD OUTTA 2019!!!! HOLY CRAP!!!! This slowly returns to more calm and jazzy waters paving that way for....

>Carini - AND INTO CARINI WE FRIGGIN GO!!!! CARINI HAD A MOTHERFRIGGIN LUMPY HEAD YO!!!! THIS THING IS A GNARLY X FACTOR BEAST! HEAVY AND FACE MELTING AND SOUL DESTROYING!!! FREAKING SPECTACULAR!!! 1.0 WORTHY!!! DO NOT SKIP!!! GUITAR HISTRIONICS! OUTER SPACE SYNTHESIZERS! 1999-TYPE WEIRDO AMBIENT FUNK! 13 MINUTES OF PURE FRIGGIN MAGIC!!!!! MUST-HEAR!!!

[​IMG]



I NEED A BREATHER. SOMEBODY GIVE ME SOME OXYGEN. HOLY FREAKING CRAP.

Ok, I haven't calmed down, but let's keep this freak train moving!!!





>Chalkdust Torture -
Great choice, thank Icculus!! None of this ballad jibberjabber! Give us the heat! :) And right away we return to Carini Freak Zone with Page and Trey both going nuts simultaneously. This is total 1995 Chalkdust peak freakout meltdown territory. HOT AS THE CLIFFORD BALL YO!!! WOWZERS!! Towards the end things start getting funky and the reggae starts to sink in, leading us to...

Have Mercy - EVEN THIS IS JAMMED OUT WTF!? THIS IS SICK!!!

Holy freaking crap - 54 minutes of X Factor Magic. Do NOT skip Soul Planet through Have Mercy! That is next-level stuff!!!!

A Life Beyond the Dream - Ugh, just disgustingly beautiful. Guys I'm so spent right now they could crap on a plate and I'd lap it up.

>Harry Hood - The composed section is pretty weak, but they quickly shift into Type II eskewing your typical Hood stylings for some awesome funk workouts. After about 6 or 7 minutes of primo jamming they introduce the "You Can Feel Good" theme, but in a gnarly and spastic, energy explosion, Chalkdust Torture, fire from hell type of way! This is one of the HOTTEST Hoods I've ever heard! This thing is DEMENTED!! HOLY CRAP!!!

Sweet Jane - SPECTACULAR! TALK ABOUT A PERFECT CHOICE AND IT IS FREAKING GREAT OMG I CANT SAY MORE KILL ME NOW

Tweeprise - Who cares?!



All in all, I had some small doubts but set 1 ended up blowing me away. Set 2 absolutely DESTROYED me! This is MUST-HEAR show! I wouldn't hesitate to give this a 4.4 or 4.5 on .NET! FREAKING GO LISTEN TO THIS NOW HOLY CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

Ok, to overanalyze and sum it up, lol:

Mexico 2020 (so far)

2/20 - Incredible show. Absolutely underrated. 2/22 might officially, imo, be "stronger", but this is terrific all around listening experience, does that make sense? Also, overall I prefer the songs played at this gig for the most part :) YMMV

2/21 - The 2001 and the Piper are probably the 2nd set highlights, but the majority of the first set is a tour de force: That whole Shafty/Plasma deal and the incredible Bathtub Gin...a much more mixed bag show for me but one can't deny the goods!!! :)

2/22 - Ok, as I mentioned, I concede this is probably a much stronger show if we are going for jam quality than 2/20, but I will die on my hill that 2/20 is the better overall show. Still, I absolutely was BLOWN away by this gig for much of it. It struggled at times but there was a solid hour + of PRIMO X Factor goodness in that second set AND that whole Tweezer>Manteca>You Sexy Policeman>Twist was of that level as well. that was stronger perhaps than anything on 2/20. It's apples and oranges and I can totally get if you pick this show's apples over 2/20's oranges :) An incredibly strong outing!!!!

2/23 - Excited to play this tomorrow. I'm looking forward to that Everything's Right that I've been aware of ever since it dropped. And that setlist looks bonkers (I know setlist isn't everything, but c'mon - look at that!)

:)

2020-02-21 Quintana Roo, MX

 Been on my mind for a week since 2/20/20 absolutely smashed my little head to pieces - onward to 2/21/20!!

2/21/20 Quintana Roo #2

Set 1

Turtle In the Clouds - Still my favorite KV song probably and I swear this one just keeps getting better each and every time they play it. Best one yet? Maybe! :p Just a spectacular opener that rips and is loaded with more energy than a firecracker.

SHAFTY - YES!!!! First since 2012, second since 2003! Talk about a bustout! Absolutely wonderful playing on this. My legs are shufflin' and my head's a-bobbin'!! This is fantastic!!!! DON'T SKIP THIS SUCKER!!!!!!! Unfortunately, instead of riding the jam to nice segue point, the guys kill it and end it....

Plasma - Why couldn't they have worked a segue into this?! C'mon guys...Great set placement though, coming out of Shafty like that. I'd reckon this goes Type II - it starts as Plasma but slowly builds into a fiery and dark kind of behemoth, skulking across the beach and punching you into the sand. Incredibly hot, red hot RAGING!!! For only 7 minutes, it packs a WHOLLOP!!!!

>Shafty Reprise 1/Plasma Ending



That Shafty/Plasma was downright must-hear. That was as great as anything from night 1 (which was bonkers!). This was 10 of the best minutes of Phish I've ever heard. Fantastic!!!

>The Lizards -
Great song choice, yet again, and they even segued into it! Can you imagine dancing to this on the beach? Woulda been awesome. Lovely Page soloing on this. Great little Lizards!

Bathtub Gin - 19 minutes. Killer. Really terrific interplay from all, everyone listening and responding to each other. Fishman in particular is going nuts with "reactionary" fills. The jam starts pretty chill and slowly takes its time building. This reaches some hotter peaks before morphing into funkier territory with lots of synth goodness and Soul Planet delay pedaling. By 12 minutes we are in some dang funky weirdo paradise. By 14 minutes the guys latch onto an ascending figure and slowly work upwards towards some 70's sounding blaxploitation kind of funk heat!!!! HOLY CRAP CHECK THAT PEAK AT 15 MIN!!!!! WE ARE GOING TO EXPLODE!!!!!!!! HOLY CRAP!!!! All in all this wasn't the most amazing Gin of all time, but top 30?? Possibly!!!! This was pure FIRE!!! Outstanding!!!!!!! Around 17 minutes we go seamlessly back into Shafty! Vocals and all! This is amazeballs!!!!!!!!!!!!! From here Trey slowly reintroduces the Gin theme and we ripcord this amazing jam to an end.....

Blaze On - GET IT LEO! HOLY CRAP CHECK THAT PIANO SOLO!! They rage the hell outta this sucker - for 12 minutes, they get more use out of it than that 7/25/18 SYSF. Very quickly shifts into blissful Type II around 7 minutes. Absolutely fantastic little Blaze!!!! Gets into ambient deep space and segues into....

Sea and Sand - Is Sea and Sand. Is great to hear :)

Possum - Ripping Possum to close this spectacular set! HOLY CRAP LISTEN TO THAT NOTE TREY SUSTAINS FOR LIKE 2 GOSH DARN MINUTES. HE IS JUST TROLLING TO SEE HOW LONG HE CAN SUSTAIN IT. HOLY CRAP! DIVIDED SKY GOT NOTHING ON THIS! OFFICIAL LONGEST HELD NOTE EVER?!?


All in all, this set burned with a white-hot intensity different from the X Factor of the first night. A different kind of magic! A 20 minute Gin, a 12 minute deep space Blaze On, that Shafty/Plasma debacle.... What more do you realistically want from a set?! This killed!!!

 

Set 2

Sigma Oasis - Very, very fine version!!! You know they only opened it because of the "castle alone on a beach" line :) Great version! Third yet? Getting better with each play - this one is very powerful and rocks hard! A+ Dad Rock!

>2001 - Oh yea, now we are talkin'!! 12 minutes on this one. They keep it within the box as expected (c'mon, when are we gonna get a monster Type II 2001 in 3.0?!) but for staying in the lines they really make use of what they've got. Pretty strong and sturdy little rager of a version with everyone doing their own tricks throughout. Good stuff!

>Drift While You're Sleeping - Another great version, but talk about awful set placement. We just had a heater 2001 and we go into....this?! Dude, c'mon now. Very powerful and STRONG rendition! But again, the set placement, man. C'mon now....

Lifeboy - Yes it's rare, yes it's great, BUT C'MON WITH THIS CRAP SET PLACEMENT TONIGHT!!! THIS IS NIGHT 2 IN MEXICO! GIVE US THE GOODS NOT A BALLAD FEST!!! Ok, that aside (I couldn't help it) this is extremely delicate and great to hear. Just awesome as always! :)

I Always Wanted It This Way - Far from the Type II must-hear behemoth of Mexico 2019, this version at least gets us back on our feet after falling asleep. They get pretty heavy with this, going proto-metal in spots. Trey is using his gnarliest Neil Young guitar sounds on this. This sucker rocks with gusto! A total Type I workout like a hot KDF or something! Very interesting for this song!!!! Worth a listen!!! Trey is letting it rip!

>No Men In No Man's Land - Awesome segue!!!! As soon as IAWITW started to stretch, Trey turns the corner perfectly into No Men and immediately begins the lyrics. This version is RED FREAKING HOT!!! This one is only 9 minutes, but as with Blaze On, it makes use of every second of it's runtime, dabbling in Type II at points and leaning into funky bliss at others. A great compact mini-epic!

>Piper - Kinda ripcord, kinda segue...ask me another day how that transition was :p Builds up from slow, quiet bliss. They REALLY take their time building it, and before long Trey is kicking into the "gnarly" section of his pedalboard, sqwonking around the jam like a chicken choking on bird seed while the rest of the band slowly keeps the intensity and build heading skywards. Now THIS is how you Piper!!! Just total guitar strangulation. :) Yo dawg, I heard you like getting your face melted in under 8 minutes. Here you go!! Fully Type II at this point, by 6 minutes in the fire is replaced by 1999-type dark ambience. Storm cloud swirls and delay sounds. THX synthesizer and Whammy pedal fun. :)

>Good Times Bad Times - Didn't see that coming but thankfully that was a natural segue and not a ripcord! :) Also, great set placement this time, coming out of that space to pick us back up and have us partying again. Perfect! Also, points for not being an encore!!! Red hot. It's fantastic. NEXT!

>Sand - Rare in the encore slot but always welcome! It's Sand. It Sands nice and good for a solid 11 minutes of beach funk. Around 6 minutes we turn a distinct corner into more upbeat/blissful areas, ala Breath and Burning. It stays like this to the end - just a great little Type I bliss-rock fest. UNTIL, that is, Trey busts into Weekapaug!!! :D

>Weekapaug Groove/Shafty Reprise - It's a 10 min full WG into a Shafty finale. What more do you want?!


All in all, I DEFINITELY prefer night 1 (2/20/20) to night 2, but I can also definitely see why many people (at least over on .NET) feel this is such a strong show. It IS a killer gig and everything is worth hearing, but totally thought the second set flow and song choice was sub optimal. The good news is that they killed it with what they gave us, but that second set...yea as much as I love all those songs, I don't necessarily need them all in the same set back to back!! :) I think Set 1 was the better of the 2 and the whole Shafty/Plasma bit and the Blaze On and beastly Gin are all mandatory listening.

Great show, but not MY cup of tea probably. :) I think it was 90 percent as good as the first night, but that's just me. There was nothing here that came close the 2/20's Ghost>Free>Shipwreck or Beneath a Sea of (Outer Space) Stars. That s#!t was magical. This was simply "really really good", imo

:)