An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Thursday, December 30, 2021

2019-12-03 Philadelphia, PA

 Ok, up next is the infamous (and much derided) Sirius exclusive show. I remember all the hubbub about this. I didn't think it was that big of a deal, personally, but we all have our views on that. I know this show is low-ranked and not counted as much of note, so I'm going in with zero expectations. :)

12/3/19 Phildelphia

The Met

Set 1

Hello My Baby - Hello old favorite! :D 3rd time in 3.0, first since 2009 and 3rd ever since 1999!!! Yea, its just an a capella tune but c'mon. :)

Tweezer -
What other way to kick off a show? Awesome. Cool stuff, they waste no time getting down to the funk, with Page and Mike both hitting us good, establishing a dark and moody vibe to begin with. Trey tosses in some very nicely measured and bluesy licks, carefully listening and placing his notes with perfection. Really, check out this section from about 5 minutes onwards - just fantastic. Patience is key! Love this!!! Really shows what the guys can do when they just slow down and think! Absolutely fantastic little Tweezer and talk about a way to kick the show off!!!! Slowly they bring the song to a major key kind of peak. It's clear where they are heading and without literally stopping for a second, the guys do one of the most incredible segues into....

Free - That segue! That friggin' segue!! THAT WAS THE T!T$!!!!!! Rocks hard and Gordo is going totally extra on that bass solo. He is tearing that crap up like it's Brooklyn 2004 (please check that out if you havent!) There is some serious energy, the guys are vibing it big time, and this sucker is RED HOT!!! Freaking awesome.

Moma Dance - The guys rage this sucker hard. Perfect out of Free (didn't they follow it with this in Brooklyn 04 as well?) Trey almost butchers the intro by coming in early but that's ok. This thing FUNKS HARD. The guys absolutely milk this intro jam for several glorious, RAGING minutes that see Trey annihilating his guitar - literal fire on the fretboard. Holy hell this sucker is spectacular. The ENERGY is ELECTRIC tonight - it's got that feel where they could play almost anything and kill it. This Moma Dance is FIRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS A FRIGGIN DANCE PARTY!!!! I CANT STOP RAGING TO THIS!!!!!

>Tweezer Reprise 1 - The Moma jam instantly morphs into Tweezer again with Trey still tossing in Moma licks here and there. Talk about another killer segue!!! This is some 1994-stitching-songs-together stuff. Fight me. And its a strong 3 minute return to the Tweezer jam before Trey pulls the plug on us....

>Blaze On - As much as I hate this song, I gotta admire the segue! AGAIN, CHECK OUT THAT FRIGGIN SEGUE! 2019 IS THE YEAR OF THE FLAWLESS SEGUE!!! DANG!!! Ok, they nailed that. That means it did not feel like a ripcord and I can shut up and enjoy this. :) Absolutely killer key smashing from Leo. This Blaze On is strong as heck. The energy is still top-tier. Let me put it like this - If I liked Blaze On, I'd be raging about this like Moma earlier. The jam rips hardcore Type I action with Trey still throwing in those tasty Moma licks and the whole thing building like an erupting volcano. Hot as a freshly microwaved HotPocket! BLAZE ON!!

With this the first segue-fest comes to a proper conclusion. 36:13 of nearly flawless A+ Phish. Get real people, listen and tell it's not incredibly awesome!

Jesus Just Left Chicago - Always love a tasty Page vocal! He's really giving it his all - funny to hear gruff vocals from him! :D Absolutely CRUSHING blues shredding from Trey to remarkably quiet and precise licking... This is awesome as hell on all fronts. Not much to say. It's just awesome!

Kill Devil Falls - The song is pretty hot but not raging (to start). The jam begins in an unusually quiet and dynamic manner, leaving shredding at the door for the time being. This slowly builds to a very feel-good (but not quite "bliss") and upbeat jam with lots of melodic phrases from Trey and lovely piano from Page. Interesting version!! Very slowly they turn the heat up, note by note. This is still an unusually "blissy" version of KDF though. Very awesome and pretty darn unique, imo. AWESOME!!!

>Tweezer Reprise 2 - Well, just as KDF was approaching total liftoff, they turn it again back into Tweezer! And this returns us to that Moma heat we loved earlier. Again, just fantastically funky and rocking. KILLER. PAGE IS MURDERING HIS KEYS. THOSE SYNTHS ARE DISGUSTING! :D Or is that Mike?! A short minute of excessively NASTY Type II funk leads us into...

>Ya Mar - Great to hear. Not what I would've picked out of Tweezer right then but that's a minor, minor nit pick. The energy is still sky high and its a total party. I can only imagine the crowd were dancing their asses off! Nothing too noteworthy, but a terrific Type I rendition worthy of any highlights list!

Drift While You're Sleeping - I love this, I don't care. It's a perfect set closer with the good vibes and all. Perfect choice (ok, maybe not PERFECT but a good one).



Holy crap this set blew me away!!! I was honestly going in with no expectations (but still expecting a letdown), and it was the total opposite. No it's not loaded with 20 minute Type II Mega Monsters or rarities, but the guys weave together an EXTREMELY hot set loaded with A+ playing from all involved. The energy and the X Factor are in it. The segues are FLAWLESS. If more people got rid of their expectations for this being a "special" show, this would be rated way higher, I'm sure. Please listen to this set and tell me it wasn't a fantastic party!!! Wow!!!

Dang....   


Set 2

Chalkdust Torture - A bit of a chill vibe kicking this one off. Oddly dynamic - something happens with Fishman losing the beat (stick loss or something?) that causes him to stop for a second, which in turn causes Page to reduce his volume making the whole band do a quick "drop out > crescendo". It's only a few seconds but interesting to note. I'm on the fence whether I think the song portion is good tonight or sloppy - it's in that grey area where can kinda go "oh they were just trying it differently". Thankfully the playing is still top notch and Trey is shredding it up with ease. No sticky fingers here!!! The jam is pretty cool. Very blissful with some middle eastern sounding themes from Trey and Page. The jam then quickly achieves liftoff and heads for the sky with Trey channeling some 1999 Chalkdust histrionics!!! FREAKIN AWESOME!!!! GET IT TREY!!!! After the sky-peak, things take a more funky turn with a focus on Page and rhythms. This was a great little Type II CDT!!!

>Tweezer Reprise 3 - Just a mere 90 seconds this time but they go into it so smoothly and, again, just completely DROP into the jam like they never left it before. AWESOME.

>Mike's Song - And the seguefest continues into Mike's Song!!! I wish Fishman didn't stop the beat and just adjusted mid-stream, but that's ok and the segue still comes off great. The jamming gets funky and nasty like Moma. Raging it up, almost bringing back memories of 1993. In other words, standard Mike's fare. :) There's a great part near the end where Trey stumbles into a sustained note for like 20 seconds and just holds it there, milking it, and the band come together beneath it. Great stuff. Then they leave MS for....

>Sparkle - No highlight for you. Sparkle is Sparkle and Sparkle will always be annoying, lol. Definitely not what I would've picked and it kills the vibe, imo. It's an ok Sparkle. I mean, Sparkle is Sparkle and not much else. What do you want, a Type II Sparkle? Would that be too Sparkle-y for you?! Am I getting my point across?! :p

>Ass Handed - See Sparkle.....I'm sure it was fun in person though!

>Weekapaug Groove - Gets EXTREMELY funky real quick and loaded with Ass Handed quotes. This sucker SMOKES!!!!! From there we explore other ground, some melodic bliss and uptempo rock stuff. Your typically raging hot 'Paug. Fantastic, really.

Miss You - Just beautiful. I know everyone hates Big Boat and Trey ballads, but I genuinely think this is a great tune and this one is just gorgeous. Beautifully emotive and sensitive playing throughout. If this was 1996 people would be talking about Miss You instead of Waste.

Waves - Again, just gorgeous. Trey is really, really on point tonight, just slaying it left and right.

>Twist - As with Waves, short but incredibly sweet. Just 7 minutes of sweet, latin-tinged, primo Type I Excellent!!!

A Day in the Life - Not my favorite Beatles song and not one I'm ever looking forward to in a Phish set. Good for what it is, but NEXT!

>2001 - It ain't the Great Went, but it is a terrific 11-minute dance party extreme. Killer. Halfway through we go full-tilt delay-jam, psycho space. No drums, just pure ambience of the dark and unsettling kind. Pretty incredible meltdown, actually!!!! Oh my god this is terrifying!!!! Sounds like a horror movie score or something. Oh my god, can I have a hug? Please?! Back to the funky theme, thank goodness. What in the ever-living hell was that?!?!?!?

More - Is More. Is good as always but nothing special.

Waste - Very good but nothing special. See More :)

Tweeprise Finale - A raging 3 minute send off to a wonderfully underrated (and overexpected!) show.



All in all, I'd give this show a solid 3.8 or so. It was absolutely better than most of the reviews and 2/3 of the show was pure heat. Set 1 was almost flawlessly in terms of execution, playing and energy. Set 2 had its ups and downs but that 2001 was a MONSTER. Now, I think it also helps not to judge this along-side the typical arena gigs on the tour - I viewed it as a "special" gig and something different. Basically, go in with zero expectations and you will have your nodding and rocking along from start to finish. A great little show and probably an absolute blast to attend. :)

 

2019-12-01 Uniondale, NY

12/1/19 Uniondale

Ghost opener and interesting looking first set! On paper, set 2 looks like a beast as well. Let's go!

Set 1

Ghost - A first set, 13 minute Ghost to open the show?! Yes please!! This one rocks, but at the same time its got that laid back chill that it sometimes lacks. Man, they waste NO time getting down to business launching smoothly into the jam! It stays pretty Ghost-ish for a long while, working on that funk before slowly moving towards more uplifting, peaky, 3.0 fair. Around the 9 minute mark or so things start to build towards the sky, everyone riding a wave together taking it where it leads them. By 11 minutes in the fire is bubbling, but the guys hold back the sauce and return to the Ghost theme pretty easily. I think the sexually aware among us call this "edging" :p And with that they ride this sucker to the finish line with a proper conclusion that then launches into Rift. A+ OPENER!!! C'mon, it don't get that much better than this!

Rift - Trey nails it!! He's doing that "playing too softly" thing again, BUT, in this instance it works. It provides dynamic tension with the other players and really grabs your attention. Finally a Rift that sounds practiced and not butchered!!! :D Holy crap, GET IT PAGE! Page is just slaying the piano on this sucker. Hardcore. Then Trey pops in with some shredding for us. Fantastic. This Rift was excellent! This was as close to "NAILED IT" as it gets these days. Great!

TMWSIY-Alvenu Malcanu-TMWSIY - "NAILED IT!" Yup, PRACTICE CONFIRMED!!! Also, who expected them to play this again only 6 or 7 shows after Alpine?! Fantastic.

The Wedge - Great song choice to pick the mood back up. Great set flow so far! Really great playing from Trey. Another one of those "Grateful Dead" versions of The Wedge that I am so fond of. Awesome. :)

Martian Monster - A short 5 minute instrumental jam interlude. I bolded it because I do think it's excellent though! Great playing from all, definitely interacting to each other. CHECK OUT GORDO DROPPIN THEM FUNK BOMBS!!!

>Timber - Ah yes, here we go! It goes quasi-Type II and Trey ABSOLUTELY FRIGGIN RIPS THIS SUCKER TO SHREDS!! Short but oh so incredibly sweet!!

COOL IT DOWN! - Bust out! Yee haw! Wait, didn't they play this in Mexico? I don't remember. Who cares - it's fantastic. 'Nuff said.

Roggae - Look, it's just one of those sets. The X Factor is upon us this night and I can already tell the whole dang thing is gonna get highlighted. Deal with it :p Anyways, this Roggae is gorgeous. Trey and Page both are just going for that Bird Song beauty....Really fantastic.

Poor Heart - RAGE IT PAGE! HOLY CRAP!

>Tube - 11 minute, peak-laden, disco party insanity. Must-hear Tube! Just outstanding! A+

Character Zero -
Is CZ. It closes the set. But c'mon, I'm obligated to highlight this too. :)


Absolutely outstanding first set that completely destroyed all 4 sets played in Providence. By a noticeable mile. Yes, this one set was better than all 4 previous ones (and those were pretty good too!). A++++++++++++++++ first set!!! Fantastic song choices, energy out the wazoo, "practiced" playing, Machine gun Trey, funk histrionics, a friggin' Ghost opener.... A total "complete package" set where everything felt perfect in its place. DONT SKIP THIS SET WHATEVER YOU DO!!!! Holy crap... 

 

 

 

Set 2

Everything's Right - Fantastic 14 minutes of Type II funk. I'll let .NET review speak for itself as it sums it up perfectly: "we get another deep spacey cosmic version. It's dark and gyrating, and unique without any traditional peaks. Mildly reminiscent of 12/30/18's ER at times. Mike hits some bass bombs and Trey and Mike exchange words and a drone begins before Mike slams the intro to DWD. It's a feverish version with no wandering around. Peaks are hit high and fast and a deep groove is landed on". Let's put it like this, it sounds like the stage is a UFO about to lift off. We get out there!! WOW!!!

>Down With Disease - From literal outer space Mike SLAMS us into DWD. He's just like "yo guys check this out" and BAM! we are in Disease :) This sucker BANGS!!! For the first 8 minutes it's the definition of "Type I RAGER" and then at the end they suddenly dive into funky town Type II!!! This only lasts about a minute - Trey quickly introduces Cities and the band slip right into it. Terrific segue!

>Cities - Incredibly cool!!! That segue!!! The boys keep the uptempo rage of Disease going for a bit but latch onto Cities, giving this one a totally different vibe!!! Slowly they match beats and tempos and slide into the proper tempo with a reggae-funk infused kind of vibe. The crowd is going nuts. NOW THIS RIGHT HERE IS SOME UNIQUE AND MUST-HEAR STUFF!!!! FANTASTICALLY COOL!!!

>Carini - Perfectly placed out of Cities!!!
Guys I can't get enough of this show! It's practically flawless (for 2019) so far!!! As with Timber, this one doesn't last that long (only 8 glorious minutes) but what's here is beautiful. The spaceship launched and now we are chilling out cruising the cosmos in style, baby. Heck yes. Don't sleep on this Carini - short but fantastic.

>Ruby Waves - Without looking at the setlist, this took me totally by surprise. Always love to hear it though - new MVP song? :) Once the jam begins, the guys play with several different styles for a few minutes before hitting on a spooky organ-led segment by Page. Trey starts playing with his wah, Fishman is keeping the tempo frantic, and it sounds like an aural panic attack :p And we still have 6+ minutes left! :) Page and Trey are both tearing it up, seemingly reacting to each other with every note they play. Fishman is just crushing his kit....THIS THING FRIGGIN ROCKS. Then somehow they shift gears again to a more uplifting and blissful kind of sound. The sun has come out and it sounds like they could break into an NICU if they wanted to. Very cool. This somehow turns into the guys going up a slow rollercoaster, dragging the jam literally upwards, beat by beat, vertically. Sounds like Trey is dragging a rusty chain on some gravel while the synths push him upwards as well. Then they reach the plateau and return to the Ruby Waves them fantastically, rocking this sucker to a perfect conclusion! HOW DO THEY DO THIS?!?!??! This was astounding....

Twenty Years Later - With some bliss you gotta get some darkness to counter, eh? This thing is hulking behemoth stomping through the arena, just smashing everything in sight. Bluesy psychedelia like it's 1974 or something. Fantastic (saying that a lot - what else should I say?!). There isn't much to say - it just CRUSHES. HARD. LIKE REAL HARD, YO. Now I'm waiting for a 20 Years Later>Egg in a Hole combo!!! But then around 7 minutes the beast takes a break and the light returns, Trey squiggling away and Page doing his church organ. This slowly returns to a grinding, stop-and-start stuttering kind of rhythmic jam with darker overtones. This is incredibly dark and weird. Sounds like some stuff from a 1993 Bowie or something, haha.

>Number Line - Just as we are about to die of fright, 20YL dissolves and the shattered pieces of our psyche are pieced back together with this relaxing drink of cool water. Ah yes, that's the ticket. Absolute 10/10 Type I RAGER of a Number Line!!!

>SANTOS - Yes, the new Character Zero of second sets :D AND ITS AWESOME! WHAT DO YOU WANT?!

Roses are Free - Is a great little RAF :)

Slave to the Traffic Light - Wow, talk about a killer way to end a killer show!



THIS SHOW WAS FREAKING FANTASTIC! ABSOLUTELY TOP TIER FOR THE YEAR! THE WHOLE SECOND SET WAS AMAZING AND THE FIRST SET KILLED IT TOO! THIS SHOW DESTROYS! SKIP AT YOUR OWN PERIL! A++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++



2019-11-30 Providence, RI

 2019-11-30 Providence

Set 1

Turtle In the Clouds - I remember at the time that I did sample this show due to slow Llama and whatnot and this stuck out as a strong Turtle. How does it stack up for me now? Well, first off, I love this as an opener. It's great. The synths sound nice and textured, Fishman blasts it out in the verses and this thing has awesome energy. They absolutely nail it - it's tight as heck - and Trey's soloing to close it out is perfect. Great opener!!!

Punch You in the Eye
- Ok, everyone knows this is my favorite Phish song (definitely the one that converted me!!!) and I'm always extra picky about them. The tempo sounds good on this - not too sluggish, but of course not as zippy as I'd prefer. Trey has some flubs in the easy part of the intro (c'mon, man!) but they get a great groove goin' so i'll forgive it. Check out Page sprinkling in those synths, ala that 7/23/99 version!!! They milk this intro nicely, finally beginning proper around 3.30 in. Compositionally Trey plays fine. Occasionally we get a tiny "squeaky" kind of flub, but once again, I forgive him. This is pretty much as good as you can expect Punch to be at this point in time, so I'll totally take it. Sounds practiced!!! And he isn't doing that "playing too quietly" thing! :D :D :D Yay! Great Punch!!!

Llama - Slow Llama!!! Yay!! We all love our red-hot Machine Gun Trey Llamas, but this arrangement grooves so awesome and is funky as hell. Also love the Gordo solo. Fantastic. Awesome. ALL HAIL SLOW LLAMA!

Meat - Gets an intro from Trey and some synths from Page to guide us in! This thing takes the dirty groove of Llama to even deeper depths. This is all about them accents and the extremely funky bass effects. :) All hail Cactus!!

The Old Home Place - Is The Old Home Place

Lawn Boy - Is Lawn Boy. Trey keeps introducing the tunes and Page keeps the "THX Movie Intro" synths blaring :p Pretty funny and the crowd absolutely laps it up. GET IT, GORDO!!!

I Didn't Know>Vacuum Solo - Nothing to say. Very funny and talk about a follow up to Lawn Boy, lol.

Maze - The THX intros continue. As they so often are these days, this Maze is less firey and hot and more jazzy and angular. Things get quite hairy with Page ripping up the keys! But then Trey comes in all quietly and guides on down the river. Hard to explain, but its a pretty great Maze, imo.

Horn - Is Horn

Gotta Jibboo - Very "quiet" sounding, as if the guys are whispering the song. Very, very chill. And this sums of the vibe of it - wonderful soloing from Trey in the back end. Pretty strong Jibboo, imo. Very sweet and smooth as ice. The last few minutes do start to build some nice heat and we close with a good strong peak. Great Jibboo!

Stash - And the THX just keeps on a-comin'!!! This Stash is beautiful. It goes Type II bliss hard, man. It's great but pretty much rides this out to its Plasma-Reprisal-THX conclusion :)

>Golgi Apparatus - Haven't a heard a good recent one in a long time and this is no exception. STOP LAUGHING AND LEARN YOUR PARTS, TREY!!! ITS NOT FUNNY ANYMORE!


All in all, this set sounds like it was a right party to have attended, but listening to it it feels overly amusing to the point of distracting in parts. Surprisingly though it DOES flow very well and nothing sounds out of place. I would even go so far to say that I thought it was better than the first set of 11/29, but I personally was waiting for this one to be over after a certain point. This set gets a "Eh, that was pretty good"/10 rating from me!

 

Set 2 -

 

Bathtub Gin - A great (for 2019) version that makes good use of it's 18 minute run time going Type II early and leading us all over the place on a very enjoyable journey. I'm too tired for proper play by play, but it was excellent and worth your time for sure! Actually, it's downright fantastic - just gets better the longer it goes! Let me put it like this, any other night and I'd be going nutso on this :p

>Alaska - Unexpectedly, it comes to a big close and glides right on into Alaska. Seems odd to get it in a second set as well. Cool beans. Great version that is pretty lengthy and winds out pretty differently than usual....

>What's The Use - OUTTA FRIGGIN NOWHERE! Yea, how the hell did this come out of an ALASKA?! No complaints! This set is awesome so far!! Around 2 minutes in the descend into complete silence. From here we are in the darkest reaches of pure outer space. This lasts a glorious minute or so. Absolutely beautiful stuff as the guys slowly re-enter like this is the world's most gentle I Am Hydrogen or something. This is the type of ambience 1999 dreamt of :D I don't know how they pull this stuff out of their hats so friggin' easily, but gosh darn it this is MUST hear!!!! INCREDIBLE!!!

>Piper - A good old fashioned almost-slow intro on this Piper. And what a perfect song choice out of WTU!!! 11 minutes of wonderfully groovy Type II ensue. As with Gin, it covers much ground in its short-ish run time. Fantastic stuff.

>Golden Age - An ever-so-slight ripcord leads us into GA. Not a total bust but not the greatest segue either. Takes the band a little bit to catch onto the groove at the start but a great song choice, I must say! This one doesn't last long but it does get into some murky, soupy, ultra-funky Type II grooves like it's Fall '97 for the final few minutes. Crazy synths and pseudo-ambience!!! If only this sucker was longer!!! Also, PLASMA REPRIS!

>Harry Hood - Trey gets off to a rough start - the composed portion isn't the best. But the energy is RED HOT on this version and they very quickly start heading for some darker and nastier spaces right off the bat. Trey turns them around though and keeps the energy building. For minutes on end they are just raging, not peaking, slowly letting this sucker boil - one note at a time!!! Around 10 minutes they latch on to each other more substantially and we start heading towards Peaksville, USA, ala the Great Went Gin. What I mean is, it's like one massive rage peak that just goes and goes AND FRIGGIN GOES. The volcano never ERUPTS, but it simmers for ever, teetering right on the edge of explosion. Around 11 minutes - still ripping it up - they begin to introduce the "you can feel good" section. This is ensemble playing of the highest order, truly a group effort and not just a Trey fest. This is damn magical (or at least as close as 3.0 gets, I think). Finally at 13 min the vocals begin only for them to immediately peak this sucker to a close. Hardcore. PLEASE LISTEN TO THIS! THIS WAS INSANE! A++++

Surprisingly the set doesn't end there!!

Big Black Furry Creature From Mars - No, it's not 2003 hot, but c'mon, this is always list-worthy! :D

>KUNG - STAND UP!!! STAND UP!!! STAND UP!!!! KUNG!! KUNG!!! KUNG!!!!

Wombat - Is Wombat. Is nothing special. But is still great :)

Possum - Is Possum. Nothing special. Rages hard to close a crazy set!

 

All in all, most of set 2 was incredible. They really worked it together like weaving a tapestry of music, all threads coalescing into an interesting whole. That Harry Hood and BBFCFM>Kung insanity was icing on the cake. Set 1 was great too. Don't sleep on this show! A strong 4 to 4.2 or so if you ask me on .NET 

2019-11-29 Providence, RI

 2019-11-29 Providence

Set 1

First Tube - Surprise opener! Absolutely KILLED and felt a little more "extra" than usual. Terrific opener.

The Final Hurrah - Wonderfully tight and funky version with so much groove. Moma Dance has some new competition. Very dynamic playing from the guys with some great interplay between Page and Trey while Mike slips in some bombs in-between. A+ FACEPLANT INTO ROKK!!!

NICU - Pretty fun version. Can anybody tell me why the crowd was going wild/what everyone was cracking up about? The crowd is NUTS on this sucker! Overall it probably isn't list-worthy but it's still a very fine NICU with some raging Page on it. :)

Steam - Pretty dang red hot!! Trey brings the HEAT and this sucker cooks!!!!

>Scent of a Mule - Is Scent of a Mule

Bye Bye Foot - Bustout!! But nothing really to say about it besides that. Great to hear though :)

No Men In No Man's Land - Pretty hot but not very lengthy. A strong type I rager, but not list-worthy. Still, good stuff!

Gumbo - Felt rather disappointing. It was 5 minutes but seemed to be over before it began and it didn't feel like much of note even happenned. It was gone before it began. Disappointing!!!

My Soul - Absolutely ripping!!! Killer!!!!


Maybe - Page debut. Pretty nice, I can see this having potential, but this isn't really anything super special. Always great to have a Page showcase though!

Sand - Return of the MicroJam! Ok, this doesn't completely get "out there", but we go to some lovely, blissful places, turning the darkness into light. Not the most incredible Sand but a nice little jam sequence in a pretty jam-barren set.

Fire - FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE FIRE!!!! RED HOT BABY!!!!! YES!!!!! LET IT RIP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 


Set 1 was a tiny bit of a slog. Not too much jamming (which is fine!) but it felt a little long. Several songs were top-tier renditions, some weren't great (Gumbo), and others were just ok, neither poor nor amazing. A fine opening set that was hot in the right places without totally melting our faces. B+  

 

Set 2

46 Days - This sucker spits and snarls and delivers some of that 2003-esque darkness. Heavy and groovy, grinding yet elegantly smashing. Trey absolutely murders his axe. RIP Languedoc!!! What a way to kick open a set!!! Not very long but absolutely top level.

>Back On the Train - Exactly as with 46 Days, this doesn't last very long, but the jamming is top notch. Totally beautiful vibe created on this one. Very relaxed and breezy like an uptempo Bird Song. Just beautiful!!!! Fantastic!!! Short but OH SO SWEET!!!

>Plasma - And the Plasma sandwich begins!!! This main portion is 14 minutes of extremely funky Type II goodness. VERY gooey and danceable. Synths-abound!! This slowly turns to a more upbeat vibe for a good while. Pretty dang hot jamming! The guys are killing it! Very feel good! This could easily go into Party Time or Undermind.

>Farmhouse - This version is so stupidly dynamic and beautiful. It really, really is a tearjerker rendition. Oh my goodness this is so friggin' sweet.....ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING 10/10 A+ FARMHOUSE. IF EVERY FARMHOUSE WAS THIS INCREDIBLE NOBODY WOULD EVER COMPLAIN ABOUT IT.

>Light -
Slowly they drift into Light, not bashing down the door but rather gently knocking on it. They did this at another recent show and I thought it worked great. I've never been a fan of them just bursting into the song (it never seems to work!). Easing into it like this feels much better, especially doing so gradually out of this Farmhouse. A+ for the flow, guys! This version is primo suprimo!!! It only has a 10 minute run time, but they QUICKLY go Type II and make damn good use of their time, covering every sound you can imagine in that time frame. How the hell they just condensed a show's worth of jamming into 10 minutes is beyond me. Overkill in the best way!

>PLASMA REPRISE #1 - Exactly as it says. The jam morphs seamlessly back into Plasma to end the jam. It's only a minute, but its pretty dang unexpected and cool. Also, the guys use it as a minute of dark space ambience before launching into....

>Birds Of a Feather - Red hot and rages big. Nothing to say that you haven't heard before. :)

Joy - RETURN OF THE SON OF MACHINE GUN TREY!!! Dang!!!!

Simple - Pretty short and nothing special (though of course its still highly enjoyable!!). Keep your ears peeled for the Manteca tease! :)

>Set Your Soul Free - So that Simple wasn't anything worth mentioning, but it did manage to facilitate a terrific segue into SYSF!! Talk about SMOOTH transitions!!! At first, the song portion isn't particularly strong. The guys have problems deciding on a tempo and locking in. But once the jamming begins, it's straight down the funky, dark Type II abyss once more!! After a solid 5 or 6 minutes of excellent jamming we are given another Plasma Reprise....

>Plasma Reprise #2 - ....which brings the sandwich to a proper close!!!! Didn't expect that. Awesome stuff!

Walk Away - Seguefest over, we start from scratch with possibly my favorite Phish cover tune. The song itself is ever so slightly rusty, but that can be excused for the rarity of it. As always, it sounds like the guys are having an absolute blast and they rock the joint HARD with this sucker. AWESOME AS ALWAYS!

Meatstick - Not what I would've picked at this point and it feels slightly awkward. Fun as ever but maybe not the best placement?? Look, it's Meatstick. You get what you expect. It's a fine version but nothing special.

Sleep - Very nice. Nothing else to say! :)

Driver - Great to hear as well.

Bug - Closing the show with 3 ballads in a row, it worked better than it looks on paper! Perhaps this was influenced by Trey's acoustic gigs? It's a surprisingly nice change. I wouldn't want it at every show but worked great in the flow of this one! The perfect come-down sequence to send us gently on our way. Wonderful!


All in all, this show was a very good mixed bag. A great start to the tour! The second set Plasma Sandwich sequence is all high quality and worth grabbing. The 3.4 on .NET is too low. IMO this deserves probably a strong 3.8 to 4.0. Not a perfect gig, but one in which they take a number of chances that pretty much all pay off, do some interesting things with the setlist, and overall just have a damn fun time. Great vibe and flow on this one. Not a classic but very strong B+ kind of gig! Seek out the highlights probably but considering that's half the show, you might as well just listen to the whole thing anyways :p



>Plasma Reprise #2 - The first time was enough. You get the gist, lol.  

2019-09-01 Commerce City, CO

 Dick's 2019 #3 :)

Set 1

Stray Dog ("Plague Dog") - Unexpected opener. I remember following this tour in real time and wondering which KV songs would be axxed permanently. Up to this point this appeared to be on the chopping block as its prior appearance was, I believe, New Years 2018. As for this one, I will give them points for trying it once as an opener. It's not the best opener but it rocks and Page rips it up and it gets the job done nicely :) A for effort!

Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - Thank Icculus this was not the opener. Opening with ST is like the Dead opening a set with Victim Or the Crime. Enough of my babbling, how is this one you ask? Slightly dark-jazz vibe to this one. It grooves pretty well! Page and Trey mesh pretty good on the jam, playing off each other. This is like a late-night Stealing Time or something. Pretty good stuff!

Turtle In the Clouds - My favorite KV song (yes, I must remind y'all each time!). HOUSE PARTY! In the end, this one is pretty strong but in no way memorable. Just a very good Turtle with some hot soloing in the back end.

Wolfman's Brother - Sounds sluggish to start but gets cooking quick. Great scat-vocal jam before sinking into the deep, dank abyss of wah-infused funk. After a while a hint of "bliss" creeps in and we go full Type II on this sucker. From dark to light and soaring peaks. This thing freaking rocks and goes for the STARS! THIS SUCKER IS A BEAST!!!! ALL HAIL WOLFMAN! ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC JAM!!!! PEAK UPON PEAK UPON PEAK!!!!!!!

Birds Of a Feather - THEY ATTACK! It's a pretty-hot-as-usual BOAF. Again, nothing noteworthy and it doesn't even last that long. Just a quick little headsmasher. :)

We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains
- A THIRD KV song in the first set! How about that?! This is maybe my second favorite of the lot. This one is quite lovely and the more delicate mood is perfect after the ragers preceeding it. The only problem is that it's short! If this was jammed out for at least a minute or 2 more this would be fantastic. As it is, it's nice enough to make my list. :) It's just REALLY good!

Taste
- Holy crap when is the last time Taste was played? Feels like I havent heard it in ages....Strong version imo. Must-hear for Page's soloing. Terrific solo peak from Trey!!!

My Friend My Friend - The song portion isn't exceptionally strong BUT HOLY MOLY THAT DARK MELTDOWN! Look, this is far from list-worthy, but that back end was pretty sick.

>Twenty Years Later - Pretty epic set placement here, coming perfectly out of that Myfe. Pretty dark and epic! Tons of backwards-guitar-shredding from Trey. Pretty psychedelic. This one stays firmly in the Type I box, but what's here is fantastic. Grab this!

>Sparkle - Is Sparkle. Is fun. What do you want? :p

Crazy Sometimes - Freaking love this. Always jams. C'mon, who doesn't love this?! This one isn't anything special but it's always great to hear!

Bathtub Gin - X FACTOR MAGIC ON THIS SUCKER!!!! GRAB THIS NOW!!!!!!!! 16 minutes of Type II MAGIC!!! GONG HITS AND ALL!!!! OUTSTANDING!!! AN ALL-TIMER GIN!!!!!


On the whole, while this set definitely had it's notable high points, it held together with a great flow and energy. If you must, grab Wolfman's and Gin. SERIOUSLY GET THIS GIN!!!!!!!!!!

:) 

Set 2

Sightless Escape - Ooh!!! Glad they finally played it! Also, why was this the only version ever?! This was pretty good and I could see this in the rotation with jam potential. I wonder how many people this threw for a loop opening the set!

>Fuego - Absolutely perfect set placement!!!! Felt like it was born to follow SE!!! And holy crap this one is just steaming with extra heat!! THIS FUEGO IS FREAKING FANTASTIC! JUST HEAT UPON HEAT UPON HEAT!!!! HOLY CRAP!!! Eventually the upbeat jam devolves into some slightly Type II dark-ambient-funk areas. It gets very dark without ever going off the cliff. Extremely cool and high quality jamming!!! This is one of those jams where everybody is playing the exact right thing at the exact right time and it is morphing into a perfect soup.....

>Piper - THANK YOU FOR NOT RIPCORDING US TREY!!!! YOU ACTUALLY SLOWLY TRANSITIONED US FOR ONCE! HOLY CRAP THANK YOU!!!! Yea, as I just said, lol, the Fuego jam was dissolving slowly into sludgy ambience and Trey worked in the Piper theme perfectly. The band obviously latches on and we get fantastic slow-build Piper like the good old days! AWESOME!! Interestingly, they don't jump into it at 500mph like in 1999 or 2000 - instead they really, truly do let it slow build for a while. Page has his jazzy keys going, Fishman is riding those cymbals, and Trey is picking his spots to weave in and out quietly. And beautifully, I might add! From here we move to a more floaty section with lots of sustained notes and widdle-widdle's from Trey, with Page on his synths in the background. The dynamics of this jam are insane - things are heating up but the overall "volume" is still low. They are slow-roasting this sucker. Around the 7 minute mark now, the tempo starts to increase significantly to the more "expected" Piper vibe. Trey lays back for a minute and lets Page take center stage, only occasionally interjecting. Is Page using a theremin?!?! What is he doing!! He's really going wacky on this sucker :D Things proceed in this manner to the end, but Trey comes back and does some great abstract lines here and there. Page introduces the droning synth and slowly the jam builds to a magnificent peak of epic proportions. The peak doesn't last though and morphs again into more mid-rangey ambient textures that segue us perfectly into..... (THIS JAM IS X FACTOR MAGIC! THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST JAMS OF THE YEAR, EASILY. MY MIND IS BLOWN. THIS IS SPECTACULAR. 1.0 AINT GOT NOTHIN ON THIS!)

>Tweezer - AND INTO TWEEZER WE FRIGGIN GO!!!! This Tweezer is very early-90's sounding. They hit upon a certain groove and just ride it out forever, slowly adding something new here and there. It's blissful and upbeat and gorgeous. An really terrific Tweezer. I don't feel like doing the play-by-play right now but it's on the same level as Fuego and Piper for sure. A gorgeous, blissful gathering of the vibes. A+ stuff!!!

>Fuego Reprise - And Tweezer goes into a full on, "rollin! rollin!" Fuego reprise. Ok. maybe its just a line or two, but it joins the whole thing together for Conceptual Continuity and brings us back to the headsmashing, Machine Gun Trey guitar rock arena with aplomb before QUICKLY descending headfirst into 1999 DARK SPACE. Out. Of. Nowhere. What. This is like that Charleston '19 Split Open and Melt that I still can't comprehend. HOW THE HELL DID WE GET HERE?!?!?!?? Long, sustained synth blares from Page and Trey giving us some blissful little runs up and down the fretboard, lingering on those sustained notes when appropriate. Let me put it like this - Mike could start doing that Down With Disease intro right now and the world would explode :)

>2001 - We are in full-on late night OUTER SPACE AMBIENCE and then Fishman straight up just kicks into the 2001 groove we all know and love. OUT. FREAKING. STANDING. HO LEE HELL. No it's not The Great Went, but it definitely gives those vibes!!! WOW!!!! It's short and sweet and does the job of getting us over the hump to the next part of the show :)

>Chalkdust Torture - Another perfect segue and set placement! The guys are nailing that this summer!!! This sucker rages and snarls, it goes super funky and hard, and then goes to ambient bliss. What. It's all over the place in the best way possible. Fantastic section where they bring the volume down low and you almost expect a return to Piper. :) A+++

>Waste - Oh my goodness. This is literally giving me goosebumps like the studio version. Played this late in the set on the last day of the run, it feels like a massive "thank you" to everybody and a farewell for the end of a terrific summer. Just stunning and beautiful. A really, really great version. Better than usual.

>Cavern - Is Cavern, but this is loaded with extra hot sauce. Yes, its list worthy. :D

>First Tube - RAGES. It's hotter than the sun. It is exactly what you want and expect. It is jaw dropping. :)

The Horse/SITM - Is The Horse/SITM. Same as always, never different. Nothing bad, but nothing noteworthy. Talk about a comedown, lmao.

A Life Beyond the Dream - Absolutely 10/10 outstanding and a perfect way to finish the show. I remember in Charleston I didn't know the song yet but it still sticks in my mind as a terrific moment. This is like that, just perfectly placed to say "thank you" again like that Waste. Just gorgeous and beautiful and as perfectly placed as the star in the sky. Couldn't ask for a better closer to this run and summer. Fantastic.

Tweeprise - But we can't leave it on a ballad, can we? Gotta rock it out! AWESOME STUFF. :D


All in all, this show was face-melting. Set 1 was good but the Wolfman and Bathtub Gin were next- level. Set 2 was like Chicago 2011 or something - just magic and X Factor and perfect flow....Your jaw is on the ground going "how the hell do they do this?!" Absolutely outstanding, outstanding, OUTSTANDING 2nd set. One of the best 2nd sets ever performed. Fight me. Please.

Peace and love. Happy turkey day everybody.