An intro to this review archive!

PLEASE READ!! - Welcome to Warewolf95's "Idiot Review" archive!!

 Howdy folks! As the title says, welcome to my archive of live show reviews as I have posted on the Steve Hoffman Music Forums website! I pr...

Tuesday, October 14, 2025

2025-07-27 Saratoga Springs, NY

 FINALLY finishing up summer tour with the immediately legendary SPAC3...

7 27 25 Saratoga

Set 1

Always a great sign to get a Buried Alive opener! Aside from the atrocious sound mix, it's the perfect high energy opener we love and expect.

Immediately subverting all possible expectations of the universe, they do that Phishy kind of thing not only Phish does, and they launch into Twee....prise?? And its 13 minutes?!?! What in the love of x Factor magic! Obviously you must hear jam, this will take you by surprise like someone smashed me across the face unexpectedly. Again, 13 minutes, the jam going "as expected" until about the 7-minute mark. There it shifts into the eventually expected major key Bliss Rock. Eventually at 10 minutes or so it shifts back into the first section of the jam slowly getting stranger and wackier winding itself up into a robotic type 2 meltdown.. dude.....

And straight into Reba! :) And that was a genuine segue as well. Very cool! And its an excellent one! Technically it's tight and FLAWLESS. Seriously, they effing NAIL it!! The insanity continues when, during the slow build to a peak during the solo, Trey begins heavily teasing the ascending Tweeprise riff! They catch on and shift back into a full blown Tweeprise jam once more!!

Tweeprise>Reba>Tweeprise - how 'bout them apples, eh?

Tweeprise gets nice and filthy again for several minutes before shifting on a dime once again, this time into a burning Funky B. Probably must hear, this is just pure fire, even by Funky B standards.

As if all that wasnt enough, up next is a 17 minute Roses are Free!!!!! What in the love of what the hell is happenning?!?! Longest since....Big Cypress??!! Up tempo and high energy, the jam immediately goes type 2 around 4:30. The band shift into this stomping kind of shuffle beat (not sure what else to call it) with Trey and Page playing melodically on top. Around 8 minutes it returns to a more standard groove, with the mood getting very laid back, but still truckin right along. Slowly becoming a more atmospheric and slightly darker groove, synths and loopers begin to subtly make their entrances. They are building this sloooowwwww and sssstteeeaaadddyyty. This is so dang sick. This feel like a late 90s 1.0 jam where they are just sunk into the music, letting floooooowwwww patiently and organically. By 11:30, the energy has ramped up significantly. Trey jumps on the wah and proceeds to solo it up nicely above the funky groove machine beneath.
Around 13 minutes, Trey is properly beginning so slowly set up the peak conclusion. After a good while everybody syncs up on this little rhythmic motif. The jam is slamming on like a steamroller and builds to the expected energetic finale, finishing with ANOTHER Tweeprise!!!!!! Holy moly what is this set?!? That was awesome! It wasnt jam of the year, but it was proper type 2, totally in the zone, flowing and connected as hell....killer....must hear!!!!

Without a single second to catch their breath, its straight into a disgustingly filthy 46 Days!!! Absolute chaos, its extremely heavy on the down and dirty. Out of nowhere around 4:30 they shift into a soaring round of powerfully majest bliss rocking, sounding straight out of Prince Caspian or something. Dang!!! After about a minute, like a sledgehammer to the face, it smoothly morphs straight back into the filth. Must hear, X Factor all over this sucker. This show just keeps getting better, holy cow!!! And then of course we get the most screaming from the skyz hose annihilation explosion to finish.....damn...

The third to final song of the set is an absolutely bonkers About to Run. Always a burner, this is a rare next-level face melter that will make you sit up and take notice. If there aren't so many other highlights of the I would say it's must hear for sure!

The set ends with a 13 min Melt intow, what else, Tweeprise. :D As with everything else this set, Melt is absolutely insane and one of the most wackily destructive readings since the universe bending 7/28/23 rendition. Holy moly for real though, that Melt!!! It's not the typical slow robo deconstruction meltdown that most modern versions feature. Instead, it's something entirely unique. Very slowly it morphs into this extremely hazy and dark psychedelic kind of cloud. Just this explosive dark haze. Was Page using a freaking chanting monk chorus vocal sample throughout?!??? Dude
...

Eventually it's slowly begins to reach its conclusion and instead of finishing the song they launched back into Tweepris once again to send us out....

I cannot say enough good things about this Melt. Definitely add this to the true all timer renditions list. Seriously


And of course we get Tweeprise to close :)


Man, throw every other set of the year out the window. That was the first set of the Year possibly the decade. What in the love of x Factor magic did they do. Honestly probably the best first set since Chula Vista 21. Literally pretty much the entire thing is must hear. Just one big round of endless Insanity after another.

The Reba sandwich, 46 Days, Melt and Roses are among the finest pieces of music laid down this year. Of course we know how set to plays out but if this were any other show I'd be going how in the hell can they possibly top this.   

 

Set 2

The second half of the show begins with a giant 17 minute Kill Devil Falls. Unfortunately, though others mileage may vary, I didn't think this was a particularly great version. The song itself sounding kind of ragged, and the jam was pretty unrewarding overall. Aside from a terrifically strong peak, the majority of it is spent in meandering bliss zone. Others will call it soundscaping but I will call it boring and uneventful. Eh.

Thankfully the sonic torture comes to an end with a move into a 14 minute Twist. Right away it's apparent that the x Factor is back. There's all kinds of extra and spirit in this version. Fishman is just going nuts with all kinds of different accents and fills. It briefly dives deep for a quick moment getting dark and bubbly before moving back into the light. Ultimately, well it turns out to be one of the most "typical type 1" readings in a while, I'd say it's still ends up being must hear. It's an a++ reading, with explosive energy, taken out of ferry up-tempo rock and roll clip just exploding with energy. This one is like a 20 ton bomb. Fantastic. Must hear!

The craziness from set one finally resumes with Golden Age>23 minute Tweeprise. ?!?!?! (Is it actually or is it really just a Golden Age jam...you be the judge).

Either way, Tweeprise begins with extreme, hard funking like it's 1997. As expected in oh so absolutely glorious. It rages the fiery power funk until around 7 minutes, (IIRC, typing this an hour later), rocking hard and powerful, moving out if the funk. After a splendid peak section around 10 or 11 minutes. The jam shifts into a really cool kind of ethereal bliss rock... something. Dont know what you would call it. Extremely cool. Slowly getting more and more powerful, they ride this to the 15 minute mark. In one of those magical "blink and youll miss it" moments, in 1 second, outta nowhere, the jam DROPS into heavy darkness! They spend the next 4 minutes in the black hole, exploring the same territory as the Mex25 20 Years Later and Mex24 Chalkdust. Pure, unadulterated, dark annihilation supreme. Trey absolutely melting faces like it's the 1997 Tweezerbella again. Holy moly Christ on a cracker. Get it!!! Suddenly, and completely organically, at the 19 minute mark, Trey starts to slowly slide in the Tweeprise riff AGAIN, as if hes slowly trolling us, lol. You KNOW he had to be greening like an idiot when he was doing that, haha. Classic Trey. From here until the jam's conclusion at the 23 minute mark, they ramp it up hotter and hotter and just explode this finale section in the way you expect. Absolutely glorious.

And then in another ridiculous moment nobody saw, they shift supremely smoothly into Boogie On outta nowhere! Actually you can hear them setting it up but it sounds more like they are going to return to Golden Age, so I was pretty shocked when they went to something else. And of course you have to include this as part of the prior jam because it flows straight into its seamlessly. An absolute scorching ripper as expected full of the extra x Factor that has invaded this glorious show.

My God man what the hell is going on tonight this is mind blowing!! Now that being said I do have one extreme nitpick with that jam - it felt like a 35 minute multibeast compressed into 23. You got a bit of a taste of pretty much every style of Phish, but it felt like as soon as you were settling into the new zone they had reached they were all of a sudden moving back out again into something else. But I mean hell if that's my complaint that's the dumbest most nitpicky complaint in history of the universe so just ignore me.

How better to follow all that then with YEM!! 17 minutes, so rather on the short side, but, as with Reba, its played flawlessly and oh so tight. Not must hear, but in the context of the show it definitely crushes big time!!!

Following the vocal jam, they shift back into a brief bluesy bit before ANOTHER 4 minute Tweeprise to close the set. :D talk about a perfect set conclusion holy hell.

And of course in a show where they didn't play Tweezer, but instead played the reprise the entire night, how is else can you end the show and tour but with an actual version of the song itself, lol. :p

Probably the shortest proper Tweezer since.....when? Good stuff and pretty funny. And then of course Hood is the magical capper on one of the strongest tours in the entirety of modern Phish.

Great Hood. Definitely above average but I wouldn't call it the best of the year. Definitely gets the emotions running high though, and that's all it needs to do!

All in all, this show absolutely lives up to the extreme hype!! Chula Vista 2021 is always my benchmark for show quality to beat. I definitely think this is at least on par if not stronger than that show. This show is absolutely ridiculous, obviously.

What is there to say that hasn't already been said? How can you accurately critique perfection? I mean you can try but it's kind of pointless, haha. I will say that I think set one was stronger overall, but the entire show was just.... What are you even say to this? What the hell did I just listen to?

Phish in 2025. Thats what. And may we put to rest the what is a genuine contender for the greatest tour of modern Phish, Fall 2021 being it's only true rival (in my opinion).

THIS is what peaking looks like....
 

 

 

2025-07-26 Saratoga Springs, NY

 7 26 25 Saratoga Springs

Set 1

Uber fresh start with a Martian Monster into 2001 opener! MM is super, super thick and groovy. Tray never solos that much or goes bananas in this one but the whole thing is just this grimy and gritty swamp murk. Not essential, but excellent.

The same can be said about the following version of 2001. Definitely some extra and groove to this one, it totally delivers but again it ends up being nothing particularly must hear.

The first true must your piece of the night is an amazing 13 minute Mikes Song. This might be the strongest type 1 reading in years, seriously. Where in the hell did this come from?! This thing positively snarls and spits and snaps and bites like a pitbull on crack. Ridiculously powerful this one just steam rolls you into oblivion. Holy freaking moly......MUST HEAR!

Unfortunately the good times come to a brief end and they, astonishingly and very awkwardly, move into and not particularly great and horrendously placed version of Velvet Sea. Instant skip. Wtf yo....

They rectify matters by jumping straight into a 9 minute Weekapagug. It's average strong and does the trick but nothing special.

Versions of Sand and Evolve follow. Again, both are average excellent but neither standout. Strong on their own but nothing you need to run to hear.

The set concludes with a decently inspired pairing of MyFe into No Men. MyFe is pretty cool tonight. It never goes full-blown dark meltdown type 2 like we expect, instead staying in this pretty cool kind of dark and melodic zone where Trey and Pagee patiently play back and forth with each other for a good while. It's actually really cool but unfortunately the jam feels like it's missing a conclusion point and awkwardly goes into No Men. No Men thankfully delivers the goods and ends the set on a very high. An absolute Barn burning rendition as usual, this one seems to go on forever and ever in the best way with terrific explosive peeking. Must hear.


All in all, this wasnt a particularly amazing set. Nothing wrong with it, the energy is there, the playing tight, etc But theres very little to get particularly excited about either. ,

It also felt like Trey was under delivering or something like that. When he did decide to show up he was absolutely ripping it up like crazy, but it really felt like he was laying back way too much for a lot of the set. Weird. And wtf was with that Velvet Sea

Basically its on the strong side of a average. Perfectly fine and im sure great in the moment, but nothing more. All that being said, the Mikes Song is absolutely essential - some x factor on that! And the MyFe>No Men is a big keeper as well.

I don't know I just didn't drive with the set for some reason it's actually kind of annoying, because it was definitely not anything approaching poor.  

 

Set 2

Oh sick, an 18 minute Oblivion! Please go dark, I beg. Bring the wormhole, please! Spending too long an upbeat Bliss Rock mode, finally around the 11 minute market starts to shift to a much darker and moody or sound. Kind of meandering around nicely, until around 15 minutes we finally take Oblivion into outer space!!! We spend an absolutely glorious minute or two in the frigging wormhole before working our way back out. Man what a tease! This was a killer jam and definitely must hear but man what could have been if they kept!!

And boy do they keep it going, onward with a freaking 25 minute Disease! And holy moly mother of sickness, they give up the ENTIRE enchilada with this!!!!

Whens theast time we had a full blown type 2 multisectional, outer space galaxy orbit Disease?!? Dick's 2017?? Now THIS is what every long ass version of the song needs to aspire to. The initial jam spends a decent amount of time flittering back and forth between dark and light type 1. Eventually it starts to go askew. Hell yes this is it!!! Let's go!!! Trey slowly starts layering loopers one by one by one as the minutes to by. The gym develops into this noisy and hazy kind of fireball wall of sound. Absolutely rocking and blazing but also this Sonic kind of force like the production on End of the Century by The Ramones. This lasts a long time it's absolutely incredible. Just layering loop after loop after loop!! Eventually the loop fest starts to die down and then all of a sudden they pull the rug out from under us and we DROP into full-blown outer space lunar orbit ambience. I'm talking Fukuoka 2000 ambience. For 5 gloriously interstellar minutes. Oh my sweet glorious Neil Armstrong!!! This is five of the most out there minutes of modern fish and not saying a lot considering we have such masterpieces as the Manchester Twist in recent memory to compare to. Eventually it dies its death into nothingness, and out of the ashes rises a 12 minute Light absolutely perfectly!!

Light out of darkness!!!!!

WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT DISEASE?!?!? OKAY NOW THERE'S ANOTHER GAME OF THE YEAR CONTENDER FOR SURE. HOLY MOLY WHAT IN THE LOVE OF GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY WAS THAT. PLEASE DO MORE OF THAT I BEG!!!!

Light is another must hear. 12 minutes of A+ type 1. This Light is exceptionally powerful and heavy with a ridiculous final minute of extreme "WOOOOAAAAHHHH" vocalization from Trey. Very funny. Think of this as the equivalent to the Mikes in set one. An absolutely killer must hear version!!!

Even stronger is the following 13 minute Life Saving Gun! You know the Piper I raved about from Forest hills? Apply that to this LSG. An absolute monstrosity, crushing everything, at warp speed and with more energy than a nuclear power plant. Holy moly. Even better it goes type 2 in the end for a couple glorious minutes. Absolutely must hear!!! Insane reading!!!

Finally we get a much needed respite with a very very nice Waste, before a nearly flawless version of Fluffhead brings the set to a close in the most majestic and celebratory manner. Another a+ reading for 2025. Maybe not must here but hot damn is it as fantastic as any other played this year!!!!

Hot encore of Golgi into a typically nuclear Rock and Roll. Heck yes.

All in all, this was ANOTHER very strong show! Honestly, my nitpicks would set one are probably just in my dumb head, and the second set is, again, ANOTHER 2025 monster!! Oblivion straight through LSG is just one SLAMMER after another!!!

Add that Disease to the all timer list. Thats gotta be "top 10 of 3.0/4.0" worthy. You better make sure you have your spacesuit handy before you listen to this one. And don't forget the Oblivion just prior - it's way better than I could describe. Never mind the heavy and crushing versions of Light and LSG...

I'd probably rate this show a solid 4.3 ish, maybe. Set one would get like a b+, set two would be close to an a+. So balances out.

ON TO THE TWEEZER FEST WE GO :D
 

2025-07-25 Saratoga Springs, NY

 Finally a decent listening job today!

7 25 25 Saratoga

Set 1

Really fresh choice of First Tube to open the show. Why isn't this a show opener more often?? It works great!! Good stuff!

Then immediately we go into a nearly 21 minute Gin, setting the tone that tonight is going to be one of THOSE nights!!! :D Unfortunately, as expected, its one of those "10 minutes longer than it needs to be and does absolutely nothing with its time" versions. To be fair, playing energy and tightness wise, it is excellent. And the peak is about 2 minutes long and absolutely nuclear, the brownie points for that. But the majority of the jam is them just stuck in that upbeat melodic Bliss rock that gets boring after about 3 minutes. Others will call this must here and I can see the merit, but for me personally this is a complete snooze and a skip. What I'm saying is, I can acknowledge its excellence, but for my personal preference it's a piece of crap.

ALSO, Good golly this is the worst mix of the summer by far!!! What in the hell is going on?!?!? It's just a wall of noise making it very hard to distinguish separate instruments aside from the constantly rattling symbols and when Trey is ripping. I THINK Page does some cool synth work at one point, but I really absolutely can't tell (for real) because the mix is so horrendous that you LITERALLY cannot hear him. He is inaudible!!! There is no excuse for this crap! UGH!!


Thankfully The inspired setlist calls continue with the following Devotion to a Dream! A really excellent reading, super high energy and rocking. Great stuff. Aside from the mix!! Listen to the first half of this - Page is INAUDIBLE. Not low in the mix, but INAUDIBLE. Eventually he is heard, but then Trey takes over the mix slack and it becomes extremely hard to hear him!!! This mix is so bad it's absolutely distracting in the most negative way.....

Thankfully things KINDA get acceptable soundwise for The Well. Another a+ song choice, this is a typical type 1 reading, nothing more nothing less. Excellent regardless. For the love of God though jam it out again please!!!

And the hits keep comin with a 9 minute BOAF. And this sucker just EXPLODES!!! One of those versions that just slowly builds and builds abd builds until you reach a point where you are slowly beginning to think "holy freaking crap". Absolutely must hear - some definite x factor at play!!!

Following a strong, and very welcome, Strawberry Letter 23, The Old Home Place and Lawn Boy give us a very nice respite before the next must hear of the show.

Hey Stranger is OFF THE HOOK tonight!!! Very lengthy (about 13 minutes!), this one is a complete funk WORKOUT from start to finish. Page is going nuts with the Clav (right?), making a funky, soupy base. Trey then comes and patiently robo wahs his way to oblivion. One of those slow build readings that stays in one zone but does so with absolute aplomb. Again, definitely x factor in play on this one. MUST HEAR!!! THIS IS SICK!!!!

The set proceeds to close on a RIPPING Walls of the Cave. Nothing special but a great, high energy choice. Strong enough to call must hear! They friggin go for it!!!! Damnnnnnnnn. Antelope territory big time on this one!

All in all, this was a very strong set from start to finish!! Super high energy and rocking from start to finish. Definitely among the very best first sets of the whole summer, made even better with the inspired and colorful song selection and flow. Never mind the actual playing.

There isnt THAT much thats must hear, but everything was genuinely at a base level excellent level of quality. Not a single weak link and a raging time from start to finish!!! One of my favorite first sets of the summer!!!

I would say Birds, Stranger and Walls are must hear, but most would include Gin as well. First sets dont get that much better than this!!! 

 

Set 2

An 18 minute SYSF into a 30 minute Chalkdust. My god.... Set Your Soul Free is terrific. Easily the strongest reading since god knows when. Super powerful and high energy, there is a ton of OOMPH to this one. Like a perfect 3 act play, it begins with a great kind of dark and tense psychedlic zone. Synths and robi wah, etc. Then it shifts upwards into fantastic bliss rocking, leading to a very large peakish kind of section. From there it gets psychedelic again, staying light this time. Just morphing and flowing, effect in play, etc. Extremely cool! Finally winding down, they successfully (though very awkwardly) shift into Chalkdust.

Chalkdust is a beast, of course. The song itself rips, smashing the door in forcefully. Immediately going type 2, it spends the majority of its time exploring every shade of abstract but blissful jamming imaginable. Very psychedelic and hazy, but also incredibly tight and FLOWING! This is one of those jams where it feels like one instrument played by 4 people as one. Tons of rhythmic shifts, wacky sideways up and down, this that abd the other, while staying upbeat. This goes all the way to the 18 minute mark. True strangeness creeps in with a wacky skippy beat and obtuse sideways synths, loops, bass fx...It goes full "upbeat Melt" on our asses!! Love and light meltdown destruction!!! Thats pretty unique!! LOADED with x factor magic, add this to the all timer list. An absolutely ridiculous and strange kind of "screwed up jazz" reading of Chalkdust. For the next 4 minutes, we descend into the wormhole from heaven. ENTER THINE VORTEX ALL YE WHO HATH CHOSEN ADVENTURE!!!!!! Out of the wormhole we morph into a VERY hard rocking section like butter. This builds to the expected hose explosion of a thousand suns. Picture the 2022 Bangor Disease - times 10,000. My effing god. The final 4 minutes see them shift again into this cool lowkey kind of skippy jam for a while. It slowly winds down and they organically morph flawlessly into Sea of Stars. Beyond Alzheimer reading right here, this makes the Mexico 2024 Godzilla Stomp version sound like child's play.

There is none more epic than the 2022 SPAC Chalkdust.....

Sea of Stars is gorgeous and works so amazingly well, winding down and naturally segueing perfectly out into a 12 minute Piper.

And OH MY SWEET UNHOLY MOTHER OF SATAN'S OUTER SPACE BUTTHOLE.
GOAT. GOAT RIGHT HERE OF THE MODERN AGE. GOAT TIMES 1000. CASE CLOSED. 100,000 NUCLEAR BOMBS AND 5,000 NASA SPACE SHUTTLES ARE NOT EVEN IN THE SAME UNIVERSE AS FAR AS THE INTENSITY AND SPEED AND HOSE EXPLOSION INSANITY OF THIS JAM. EVEN WITH PHISH 1.0 I HAVE NOT HEARD ANOTHER JAM APPROACH THIS LEVEL OF BRAIN EXPLOSION.

Um.... What can you possibly say when no words in the English language (or any other for that matter) can accurately describe and depict the events unfolding in this Piper?? Piper, is heavy, and grimy and fast and beyond ripping. Beyond nuclear. Beyond Jesus. Beyond anything your mortal brain can't even fathom.

If you have not heard this, stop what you were doing right now. Stop playing with your child, stop whatever important business transaction you're currently conducting, take your hands off the wheel and crash your car... Whatever you need to do to hear this Piper do so immediately.

APPARENTLY ITS POSSIBLE TO TRAVERSE OUTER SPACE WITHOUT A SPACE SUIT!

You know how I go on constantly about how 2023 was the year of pedal to the metal full-blown floor it Phish? There isn't a single jam in 2023 that even approaches the mind-altering intensity of this one performance. With this Chalkdust>Sea of Stars>Piper Trifecta we have officially blasted through the ceiling that is Mexico 2024 in terms of what the benchmark is to reach for in terms of modern Phish.

This was a masterpiece. This trio was beyond a masterpiece. What is beyond a masterpiece?!

I give up with this band I swear, every time they top themselves, they somehow come along again and top themselves 10 times harder. ....

Bringing us back to terra firma, it's like a kick in the teeth getting slammed with a 15 minute Everythings Right. I just mean that they took us so far out into the land of.....whatever, that it's like "huh?! What?!", getting shaken awake, haha. A terrific reading, the song is extra powerful. Wonderful laid back jamming to start with great connection between everyone, eventually turning into the expected cheerful type 1, again slowly building serious heat and rocking to a close. Maybe not essential, but damn is it great regardless and a perfect set capper.

Smashing encore of killer readings of Loving Cup and Antelope. Nothing to say. Great as always. What CAN you say after what we just heard?!

Now THAT was set of the year. F me, that trio of Dust through Piper has to be worth of being among at least the 50 greatest sequences in their entire career. They did it. They officially destroyed the benchmark of Mexico 2024.....

SYSF is fantastic and essential, but is absolutely laughable in the wake of what follows. That is beyond insane. That Chalkdust makes Mex 24 look like Lawn Boy .......It doesnt matter what else gets played this year. Jam of the Year, and maybe the last 5, is right here....

The nearly 4.5 rating on .NET is actually perhaps underrating this.
 

Sunday, September 28, 2025

2025-07-23 Forest Hills, NY

 7 23 25 Forest Hills

Set 1

A Free opener again - didn't we just have one a few shows ago?! Unfortunately, I thought this one was rather bland and sluggish. Not particularly great.

Thankfully things pick RIGHT the F up BOTT. A raging type 1 reading, it feels extra colorful with nice Leslie and wah playing. Not must hear but definitely highlight worthy!

Apply the same to the following Theme. A firmly ordinary type 1 version, the likes of which youve heard hundreds of before, but like BOTT, its very...powerful and weighty. Nothing special, it just has a great vibe about it. Check it out.

And then, BAM!! OUTTA NOWHERE!! 15 minute hose explosion Cities! :D A terrific, terrific reading across the board. The extra funkiness is properly jammed out, slowly morphing into the expected bliss rocking. But they slowly keep turning the heat knob higher and higher and higher. Eventually you reach a point where the jam just EXPLODES and the hose rains down from above. The peakage on this is friggin magical, honestly maybe even stronger than the Carini from last night. Some definite x factor on this bad boy. MUST HEAR!!!

Thank God that wasn't just a fluke - from here the rest of the set ascends to the freaking sky. The following Divided Sky is extra in the best possible way. It feels like the paws goes on forever and the crowd is just erupting. The song is extra high energy and all full of extra oomph, tight playing and all. This version is an absolute beast, maybe even topping my beloved version from Charleston. Must hear!!!

After that, we get a NUCLEAR FRIGGIN BOMB reading of Timber. Yes, this song is always hot and this year has delivered multiple great versions, but honestly, no exaggeration, I think this version tops them all as well! It's just OVER THE TOP fire and power. Absolutely CRUSHING! Another true must here!!!

"But wait, there's more!!!!"

And into a 17 minute Ether Edge we go!!! Ok.... :p and Good golly Miss Molly what a version it is. There have been multiple jammed-out versions (surprisingly, of all songs), and while I don't know if this tops them, it's definitely in League with the best of them. This one stays firmly quote on quote extended type 1 raging. Basically it's Cities on steroids. If you enjoy the pedal to the metal jamming style of 2023, this will be YOUR jam. All day. The boys just FLOOR IT and crush us to bits. Of course it's must hear, duh!

The set ends on a nicer and more calm note with The Squirming Coil. Not much to say, it's a fine version.

All in all, HOLY FREAKING CRAP WHAT WAS THAT SET!!!! Honestly, that run of Cities through Ether was definitely as strong or strong then some actual second sets I've heard. And you know what?? That run might have just been as good as the sequence of the second set of night one.

Cities, Divided Sky, Timber, Ether Edge...Make sure you wear your flame retardant clothing to this set... 

 

Set 2

Set two starts on an amazing note with Punch>Ghost. Punch is another tight and slick version from this year, this one feeling even tighter and more concise, in a good way, then others. The intro jamming is shorter but oh so perfect. And the song is flawless basically. The best part is the incredible outro where the song kind of does a hazy fade out into Ghost.

The outro is one of the sickest mother freaking segues I've ever heard in my life. No, seriously, THAT WAS SO BADASS YOU HAVE NO IDEA. HOLY MOLY THAT WAS SICK!!!

Even sicker is this incredible 16 minute version of Ghost!!! Quickly going type 2 around the 8-minute mark, the jam starts to slow into a heavier more stomping kind of flow. Trey is inserting robo wall bursts and the band is flittering back and forth between dark and light, teetering on the edge but unsure whether to jump off or not. It's incredibly sick and last until about the 12 minute mark. Just all kinds of nasty and gnarly Godzilla stomping awesomeness. Somewhere around 12 minute mark they switch slowly back into rock mode and take us on into the sky. X Factor Magic at its absolute finest.

Keeping the insanity going, we move on into a 15 minute Wave of Hope. An absolutely incredible rendition, it feels like a 30 minute journey instead. Raging like a nuclear bomb, like a heat-seeking missile, until about the 12 minute mark. From there we just descend into the black hole vortex of Doom. From there the song goes full blown Fuego meltdown deconstruction mode. A glorious mess of dying robot sounds and wormhole vortex destruction. HOLD ON TO YOUR SPACE SUITS WE'RE GOING INTO THE WORMHOLE!!!!

And oh so perfectly, you can hear it coming from 10 miles away, out of screaming of that dying star, comes Whats The Use. Now, look, you and I both know that almost every version is identical, and you're lying to me if you tell me you can really tell them apart, but add this to the list of "oh my God this is so good I've never heard one this good" list of versions of this song. And good god did it work spectacularly coming out of that Wave, really. Damn.

My God what even is this?! This is blowing my mind this is CRUSHING!!!

"BUT WAIT, THERES MORE!!!!!"

Just when you think that there's nothing else to give, we get a spacey, hazy cloud of a 20 minute type 2 Ruby Waves!!! No seriously, there is no type 1 in this. It immediately goes type 2, morphing into this hazy kind of waaasssshhhhh of sound. A completely textural kind of soundscape type of jam. Not really any proper soloing if you will, just one giant cloud of psychedelic bliss. One of the most unique versions I've ever heard and definitely another case of x Factor magic for the night. Must hear, all day long. Its sick.

From here the big hitters come to a close and the show basically rages to a normal conclusion.

Numberline and Character Zero end the set, with Character Zero honestly reaching must hear status, imo. Trey just goes banana sandwich on this sucker abusing his poor old wall pedal to the fullest. This is the definition of an a+ type 1 reading. Nuclear!

Very fun encore of Sneaking Sally, Wilson and Rocky Top. Sneaking Sally is worth a listen as well, basically acting as C Zero Vol. 2. Just straight funky fire!!!

All in all, while I was blown away by night one, holy moly in hindsight night one has NOTHING on night 2!!

Currently the show sits at a 4.1 rating, which I think is pretty ridiculous. Hands down this is at least a 4.3 or 4.4 level show, again, imo. And again in hindsight, haven't heard this monster gig now, I must downgrade night one to somewhere around a 4.0. This second set...man. HEAVY HITTER AFTER HEAVY HITTER AFTER HEAVY HITTER!!!

Punch>Ghost
Wave of Hope
Whats the Use
Ruby Waves

All are downright spectacular readings with tons of proper type 2 magic throughout. There is basically no meandering Bliss Rock in this show. And thank God for it. I thought the show was so strong I would probably put it in the top three or four of the entire tour. Maybe. Top five for certain (of the shows I've heard so far!!!!!)

Damn ....
 

2025-07-22 Forest Hills, NY

 7 22 25 Forest Hills

Set 1

Very nice dual combo of Moma into Rift to open the show. Neither are anything special but both get the job done as expected. Good stuff! Both are hot and tight and excellent.

From here though, the set launches into the stratosphere and never lets up!!!

Sigma Oasis is 12 minutes of magic. The song is extra powerful feeling tonight. The jam sees them totaly eschew bliss rock and instead dive headfirst into a gnarly, dark and grimy jam fit for a Carini. Hypnotic. Absolute x factor magic on this sucker. MUST HEAR.

Possum in slot 4 is very refreshing and its absolutely nuclear as expected. A+.

The next must hear is Wolfman. Firmly type 1, it goes above and beyond the hottest type 1 readings of the year (and they are almost all terrific, lol). This thing positively EXPLODES in the most incredibly magical way. X Factor magic to the gills, this is a gold standard for type 1 reading that everybody and their mother needs to hear at all costs. Hot damn!

Stash and Blaze On continue the heat delivering scorching renditions both. Stash in particular is close to the craziness of that Wolfman. Stash is probably must hear.

And then comes maybe the gnarliest, sickest, most extreme version of Monsters played yet! I swear, it feels like every version of this song seems to top the one before it. This song is just a monster every time it comes out to play, and this one is no exception. MUST HEAR! NUFF SAID!

The set concludes on a great note with another version of I Am the Walrus. Is that four versions this year already?! Trey has a hard time with the lyrics fumbling them throughout but that is the least of anyone's worries. Getting a Walrus at any show would be awesome regardless of how well it would be played. Terrific ending to the set!

All in all, this was a fireball of a set. Definitely highly inspired with several absolute standout renditions. Wolfman, Sigma and Monsters are BIG BOY must hears and special shout outs to Stash.

Hell this may have been the strongest person in a while! Definitely count me a fan, this set was a barn burner. 

 

Set 2

The second set opens on an incredible note with a massive 29 minute monster of a Carini! This one is ALL love and light, but even as someone who counts themselves as a hater of excessive Bliss Rock even I was completely converted by this version. It rocks powerfully albeit slightly blandly all the way to the 12. The band are tight and powerful and have a driving energy so at least it doesn't feel meander. Then at the 12 minute mark slight loopers and delays and synthesizers start to come out. For the next 5 minutes they proceed to build a beautiful and hazy kind of blissful soundscape. Never going fully ambient but absolutely leaving the ground for the sky. Killer. Around 17 minutes some power begins to emerge and the jam heads back into more powerful in driving rock based waters. At around the 20-minute Mark after an absolutely incredible peak section, things finally begin to deviate sonically for a bit. For a couple minutes we get some very nice funky robo rock, but alas it's not to be. From about 24 minutes onwards they revert back into rhythmic Bliss rock type upbeat motif jamming, everyone in sync like one foreheaded beast. And eventually it somehow reaches a conclusion point with a very cool segue into an unexpected 15 minute Tweezer!

That jam was pretty damn epic! POWERFUL as all get out, even I could tolerate the sonic blandness of the jam because the playing was so damn tight throughout. It never felt meandering or lacking for direction and it felt like a giant journey. For a light and love rendition of a tune it was absolutely pummeling in the best way. Wow!!!

Tweezer is terrific as well. It feels more like a coda to the giant Carini if anything. Taken on its own I would call it a slight must hear, but as part of the greater whole of the set and whatnot it's an absolutely killer piece of music. Aside from a very slight section of robo deviation, it's basically 90% extended type 1 hard rocking raging. The final few minutes of peakage are absolutely insane, sing the jam swell into a giant sonic vortex of type 1 insanity. Unfortunately just as it crosses the threshold into weird zone Trey. decides to kill it and leads us into a 14 minute Mind instead.

Man the ending of that jam was some total BS but that's okay because what was there was terrific.

Mind is absolute funk supremacy tonight. Must hear just an absolutely smashing shorter version. The funkiness goes hard and deep, eventually evolving into a bleep bloop kind of blissful robo delay and looper wall of sound. This is killer and lasts a long while before seeing the jam naturally imploe in upon itself like a dying star. Yo, do NOT sleep on this! One of the sickest shorter jams of the year, hands down!!!

The set then concludes with an incredible magical combo of Life into Hood. All the Life haters can suck a fat one - this one is down right magical. No seriously this is what the song is SUPPOSED to sound like!! This is honestly the equivalent of say an a+ modern Slave or something. GRAB THIS IT IS INCREDIBLE!!!

Basically repeat all of the above for the set ending Harry Hood. If this isn't the strongest version of the entire year then I'm a deaf man. This is no average reading this is one of those "stars aligning", flowing manna from heaven, A+++ readings. If this version doesn't knock you out then you have no soul plain and simple. Holy
moly what a hood!

The encore is rather average tonight. Slave is ok and then we get Tweeprise.

All in all, this was another absolutely killer show. It was a slight step down from Chicago, but that's more due to some nitpicky things on my part. Such as not being overly exploratory on a sonic level or jams getting cut kind of short etc

But they aren't horrendously big issues just issues that are there regardless. The second set is basically must hear from start to finish. In any Life haters need to freaking hear this one. Its amazing. And the energy was HIGH!!!

Never mind the Carini! AND THAT HOOD!!! I'd say the show is worthy of a SOLID 4.2ish ranking. Nothing more, nothing less.
 

1998-07-15 Portland, OR - The O.G. Live Phish Series, Vol. 17

 In to work late today at 1030 so Im at the ""morning hype has subsided now im chilling" part of my day

The "1998" section of my day, if you will :)

So, skipping out of order from my "OG Live Phish Vol. 1-20" series of reviews I got distracted from 2 years ago, we jump ahead to Volume 17....

This review will be short it's hard to say anything noteworthy about a lot of songs in 1.0 shows considering the base level of excellence of most of them. It's like "well that was great and that was great too and that was also great!!!" By modern Phish standards everything would be highlight worthy.....

7/15/98 Portland

Set 1

Fresh off the summer euro tour, the band slowly glides into a lovely Wolfman to start the show. Very laid back, though it gets COOKIN in the back half. Nothing special, but know it's excellent.

Water In the Sky is next and I swear it just feels perfectly placed! Youll go "oh crap, that WORKS!" Great stuff.

I'm sure this review will be shorter than most - considering this is 1.0, even average readings of songs are still excellent on the whole, so differentiating between an average excellent version and a true must hear rendition is a little trickier than with modern shows, make sense??

After the excellent Water, comes a terrific 10 minute Moma. Basically Wolfmans counterpart, its nothing that special but is just overall REALLY NICE in the smoothest way. Good stuff. Hell, the vocals dont even come in until after the 5 minute mark!!

Guyuute is flawless. What is there to say? Horn is a nice little surprise. Horn is Horn, but out of it comes maybe the first must hear piece of the night. The song ends and they slowly morph into this really beautiful kind of hazey, atmospheric bliss jam. Total late night, starry sky ambience....just beautiful.... Slow building, growing from quiet peace up into a powerful kind of climax. This kind of stuff is why we Phish. Awesome.

And then Trey "ruins" the mood and rips us into a burning 9 minute Chalkdust. Typically killer reading, it kinda sticks out in this otherwise chill set. Still excellent though!!

Following lovely readings of Beauty and Brian and Robert we get the next must hear of the night. Cars, Trucks, Buses is loaded with extra rocket sauce. Check out Page's piano soloing - it's extra jazzy in a way that I have never heard out of this song. And then slowly it gets harder rocking until Trey is eventually on the wall pedal ripping it up. I'm calling this a genuine must here it's pretty dang sick.

Roggae is gorgeous as ever, this one sounding almost hypnotic. Nothing much to say, it's great. :p

Following Roggae, Trey gives a lengthy little speech regarding all the new songs that are playing and how they just recorded a new album prior to the recent European tour. "F-ck it, we'll play some new songs!" Lol

And indeed they do, moving the set onward with a killer version of Birds of a Feather. It's so cool to hear the song played very similarly to the album rendition, with lots of dynamics in the playing, as opposed to the straight up rager versions of later years. Great stuff.

The set concludes with a really excellent, and borderline must here in my opinion, version of Loving Cup. Hot but laid back at the same time. It rips as usual but has such a subtly groovy kind of....flow to it. Wonderful.

All in all, I generally really enjoyed this set from start to finish. No covers like this summer tour would be known for in the future, plenty of new material, a wide VARIETY of material....As expected from 1998, the set is chill as hell but, but more in that perfectly laid-back kind of way rather than a sleepy way. Plenty of heat, counter balanced out with groovy flowing vibes.

Id say the Horn outro jam, Cars and Loving Cup are must hear, but Wolfman, Moma, Chalkdust and Birds are all worth checking out as well.

:)  

 

Set 2

Really interesting and unique choice of a 13 minute Limb By Limb to open the second set! It's a genuinely terrific type 1 reading, good enough that I'm going to call it must hear. Just gooey and hot and flowing and powerful. Really killer reading.

After a brief minute or so of outro ambience it moves awkwardly into an excellent as well type 1 Simple. Really great stuff working as a perfect one to punch with Limb.

Great start to the set! And it only gets better from here, when we launch into a 17 minute Tweezer! And its obviously fantastic as expected. :) Following the typically unhinged 90s reading of the song, it immediately drops into a spacey, quasi ambient groove. Gordo and Fishman holding down the fort while Trey and Page layer synths and loopers and whale sirens atop. Very sick. After a groovy long while it gets a head of steam and slowly moves into a more rocking direction for a bit before winding up in the super funky stew kinda jam you expect from the song. Its hard to describe - its like a subtle 3 act play kind of jam. The kind you just sink into like a comfy sofa and let wash over you. Killer.

In a really awesome/awful ripcord/trainwreck moment, Trey actually picked up on a cool moment with which to make a transition out of the jam, leading into Free. It was actually a really creative and unseen kind of transition that would have worked amazingly. Unfortunately, Fishman seems totally startled and completely drops the ball, dropping out and ruining the segue entirely, lol.

Free, as a result, takes a long time to settle in, completely nerve racked by that horrendous disaster of a transition, lol.

Fear not though, as the song goes on to deliver a STELLAR performance! Utterly kick ass, the usual Free wah abuse soloing is 10/10 and blazing hot. Eventually it somehow starts to get more rhythmic and groovy - when the cowbell comes out its game on!!! The jam gets funky but also kinda... tropical? Beachy? Either way its absolutely SICK and must hear regardless. A freaking COOL version!!!

:D

The set then continues with the slowest, goopiest Meat Ive ever heard. No, seriously. Meat is a slow song and this version is almost at half speed, lol. Meat is merely a little interlude however with the set concluding with Harry Hood.
Must hear. A terrific slow burn version in line with the rest of the show, the extra relaxed nature of this version adds a whole nother level of magic to it, just flowing like butter and with a wonderful peak. Hell yes. Grab this sucker!

Slightly disappointing encore of Circus into Tweeprize.

All in all this is a fantastic show. I'd probably rate it like a 4.3 or something. For set two, Limb, Tweezer, Free and Hood are all must hear.

Classic show is classic, enough said. Nothing else really needs to be said!!!
 

2025-07-20 Chicago, IL

 7 20 25 Chicago

Set 1

The set opens with the excellent triple thread combo of Cars, Bag and Funky B. Not much to say - the energy is high and these are excellently energetic type 1 readings. But also they are nothing particularly amazing or noteworthy either.

And thats fine! Good stuff! :)

A nicely placed Alaska gives the set some nice flow, bringing in the groove and letting us get on down, if you will. Ever the stomper (whoulda thought?), its another hot version as expected. Again, good stuff!

The setlist finally start starts getting interesting with Mikes Song, unfortunately another shorter version (cmon you heathens, jam it out!!). Thankfully this one is excellent. Its friggin bumpin' from the get go. I mean, its nothing unique, but its always awesome to just dive into some Mike's funk, eh? :D
Maybe its just me, but I swear this one is REALLY cookin tonight! Honestly, despite the shorter length, totally check this one out. It just kills! Must hear? Honestly? Maybe.

Averting Hydro-like expectations, we the continue on into Reba. The composed section is strong if not perfect, but you are here for the solo. It absolutely EXPLODES!! Must hear just for the solo, some definite magic on this, imo!!

Keeping the flow going nicely we get a slowly-becoming-less-rare Leaves. TERRIFIC version, with a gnarly, ripping solo from Trey. A+ version, imo. Definitely must hear.

The set ends on an energetic note with the combo of Taste into Izabella! Taste is supremely average if still very energetic, but Izabella absolutely burns down the effing building as expected. Terrific reading and definitely must hear.

All in all, this was a bit of an interesting set. The whole thing was base level average excellent, and there were very few true standout moments, but also nothing at all that disappoints. Mike's>Horn is a "small" must hear, but Reba and Leaves and Izabella are all killer.

Not every set or show needs to be an a+ all-timer to be great. Sometimes just fine is, well, just fine indeed!

 

Set 2

Set begins with an 11 minute Jibboo. Im a big Jibboo guy but I didn't really care for this version and didn't think it worked as a set opener. Even though it has a legitimate whale siren like its 2000, that's not enough to save it from feeling like a slightly meandering and non-delivering version. It's not bad or anything like that it's just not incredible. The soloing has an interestingly grimy kind of feel about it that is kind of unique but on the whole this isn't anything you need to rush out and hear.

Much better is the following 19 minute Fuego!! Tight and solid, smack at the 10 minute mark it goes proper type 2. Initially the jam just takes on a heavier more kind of stompy and darker groove type of feel. Very hypnotic, if you will. But after a few minutes Fishman starts playing with the beat changing it to a more up-tempo feel. It's a really weird section in a great way. Slowly it becomes more ethereal and blissful, with lots of backwards loops and chirpy playing . Total deviation! Welcome to the psychedelic soup kitchen. Somewhere around 14 minutes it really feels like Trey is trying to set up Izabella once again! The jam is becoming more rocking by the second. Now this is what I'm talking about! Give us that x Factor come on boys! :D Trey jumps on the wah and the jam takes on a more straightforward HEAVY rocking feel, loopers still going in the background. This is like a 10 ton boulder of awesomeness just pummeling you into the pavement. Hot damn this is SICK!!!!! This is just FILTHY!!!! At 1845 this incredible jam winds to a close with Page STRAIGHT UP playing Izabella, lol. But Trey doesnt take the bait....wtf Trey.... :(

Either way, a genuinely KILLER jam!!! Must hear, of course!

And outta nowhere, the most hilariously and unexpectedly placed Sparkle follows. Fun as ever. :p Somehow, it doesnt feel out of place and works great as a fun little interlude before the next round of world destruction.

The 27 minute duo of Scents>Twist present one of the finest jam sequences of a year absolutely bursting with all timer and GOAT contenders. Scents is 14 minutes of flowing perfection. The song begins with a wonky intro out of Sparkle (in a good way!), the jam slowly evolving out of type 1 into this really sick and ethereal kind of upbeat bliss undercut with Pages flowing synthesizers. Its a gooey "ocean in the sky" scenario. Totally sick. It slowly morphs again back into a much more slow and deliberately hard rocking STOMP of a jam. Absolutely raging with WEIGHT. They easily could have morphed back into Izabella during this section. :)

Aside from the awkward sudden ending ripcord out of the jam into Twist, its just incredible for a modern Scents. Must hear, duh!

And then comes Twist. Holy mother of "where in the F did this come from, how did we get here?!" Get your space suits on because it's time to fly to the outer regions of the universe!!! This jam is, simply put, a damn masterpiece. Honestly, I think it tops the mind-blowing adventure from Manchester back at the start of the tour, and it's probably even crazier than the GOAT of 3.0/4.0 reading from Hollywood on 4/27. THIS IS WHAT X FACTOR MAGIC LOOKS LIKE ON FULL THROTTLE BOYS AND GIRLS. MY JAW WAS FIRMLY PLANTED ON THE FLOOR. WHERE IN THE HELL DID THIS COME FROM?!?!

After a standard but very nicely played version of The Lizards comes Shine a Light and KDF to finish the set. Continuing the stellar flow of the show, Shine is a wonderful choice for this spot! And and honestly, Shine is must hear, imo. It's just an a+ perfectly played perfectly enthusiastic version loaded with extra heart and soul. And it's one of my least favorite songs that I would much rather hear anything else of in the setlist so that's saying a lot for me to say that

Twist begins with very inspires type 1 as usual. Right around 5 minutes, the bottom totally drops out. They rebuild it into blissful, rhythmic type 2. Page on the wah-wah-wah synths, Trey doing chirpy melodic work. The beat begins to stutter and go awry. Quickly things start getting strange!!! We shift into some kind of abstract heavenly bliss jamming. Extremely "soundscapey", if you will. Super textural in the best way. Like a warm, comfy quilt on a cold winters night. The pulsing synths continue in the backdrop while Trey and the boys just build this majestic, ethereal, cloud of bliss atop the bedrock of ooze. By 9 minutes we are in full blown, 1999 style POWER HAZE!!!! This jam is just soaring! Slowly and beautifully, second by second, everyone locked in tighter than Fort Knox. Somewhere around 10 minutes, the jam finds itself evolving into a massive slow burn, explosive peak straight from X FACTOR MAGIC HEAVEN!!! HOLY BANANABALLZ LETS FREAKING GO!! ANYONE GOT A PARACHUTE?! WE ARE SOARING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Oh my sweet mercy this is one of the most mindblowing, earth shattering, soul crushing finales ever. My god.

And with that, a new Twist legend was born......

After a nicely played version of The Lizards comes a terrific reading of Shine a Light. This is personally one of my least favorite songs ever that I hope to never get in a setlist, so take me seriously when I say this is a terrific reading. Just perfection from start to finish. I'm calling this must here it's so stupidly good.

The set concludes with KDF. At first it's surprisingly chill, but thankfully in the back half it delivers the screaming peak you expect and closes the set on a great note.

Terrific encore of Fee, Paug and SANTOS. Fee is excellent and terrific to hear as always, but the real winner here is the Weekapaug we were shortchanged in set one. Small must hear on this one, it's just another type 1 reading but it's REALLY, REALLY good one!!!

After that Paug, SANTOS almost feels unnecessary but still is a welcome show closer as usual.

All in all, wow this set killed!!! Set one was pretty good overall with little that was most hear, but set two definitely brought the goods and then some!! Fuego and Scents were TERRIFIC reading, but that Twist reaches genuine all timer status imo. I don't know how anyone could hear that and not be blown away. Holy moly. So grab those as well as Shine and Paug.

On the whole, I thought set one was a solid 3.7 or 3.8 level set, while set 2 was like a 4.3ish level set imo. So it evens out nicely to the 4.3 rating over on .NET